@richard said:
Seriously you aren't alone with battling emitters, you certainly picked a hard one! BTW is your glass to the bulb AGS or real glass?
I put a george nelson shade in a client render the other day - spent SO LONG to get it almost right and then they didn't like the fitting so luckily I didn't have to pull hair to get it absolutely right!
I congratulate you for taking Massimo's critique on board - Sometimes we have battled SO hard to get something we are so proud of, yet as often so attached that critique is hard to swallow. The truth is that we had our heads stuck where they shouldn't be. When we extract it and be strong with an "f*** you!" attitude to "I'll show you!", we nail things that without that encouragement, we'd have sat thinking my best, when the truth is we have another dimension to our best!
Well done!
I avoided doing the whole light bulb design for ages. Initially I just had a normal bulb and then thanks to the 3D Warehouse I found that teardrop shape. I manipulated it a little, added the filament and then created the brass fitting. I wouldn't have been happy with the final render if I had have proceeded with a standard bulb design anyway. I think being a 3D Visualiser or CG Artist we're (unfortunately) sticklers for detail. It's both a curse and a bonus. The glass material is an MXM material that's real glass. It's extremely fine with a high reflection. There was a little noise at the bottom of the bulb in the final raw render - not too many but I removed them in Photoshop. It was an absolute dream when the flame-like reflections appeared, just the way it appears in reality. It's a serious thumbs-up for the accuracy of unbiased rendering. I didn't add those in post-processing but I did exaggerate them.
I had to take Massimo's critique on board for two reasons: 1. His credibility and 2. My own personal development. You're right, it isn't easy to accept someone else's critique and it's even more difficult when you know they're right! Grrrrrrrrrr!!!! haha
When you mentioned linking my first post with the first image, did you mean uploading my first image again?