Not breaking faces & not making faces

[TIG]

Try changing it manually and see what it is next time you startup Sketchup...
It just might be fixed !
You might have a script that's resetting it to 'false' at start up.
Although I don't know of one.
If you do a search through the files in Plugins and subfolders for the text Sketchup.break_edges it might reveal a culprit [unless of course it's compiled]...
OR you Sketchup is foobar...

[wind-borne]

i did try a restarting SU a couple times after changing and so far so gooooood

[driven]

Hi just got back in and ran the suggestions,

I'm on 10.5.8 and V8 Pro M2

Sketchup.break_edges? with all plugins turned ON returned false

Sketchup.break_edges? with all .rb plugins turned ON and all .rbs plugins OFF returned false

Sketchup.break_edges? with ALL plugins turned OFF returned false

ran Sketchup.break_edges=true in Ruby Console

after restart...

with ALL plugins turned OFF Sketchup.break_edges? returns true

with ALL plugins turned ON Sketchup.break_edges? returns true

ran a few plugins that break or restore edges SU still returns true.

I greped my plugins folder and edges.rb [by TT] uses
break_edge = Sketchup.break_edges? Sketchup.break_edges = false and then
# Restore the break_edges setting Sketchup.break_edges = break_edge return temp_edges.size

is that the same as saying
Sketchup.break_edges = true???

I was using EdgeTools recently, but didn't notice a change afterwards, it was the OP that made me think about a few oddities, very recently...

Everything seems to be OK, I'll keep an eye out for it failing again.

cheers TIG and Thomas.

[TIG]

TT's tool does temporarily reset the edge-splitting to 'false'... BUT it is failsafe-trapped to 'ensure' it's set back as it was when the tool started off [even on a crash]... so it should never mess with your settings...
This is weird ?

[driven]

It is possible I had a hang , caused by another operation, the last time I used EdgeTools.

Could that effect the reset?

john

[TIG]

It might do...
You [we] need to ask TT... as I can see no reason to reset it at all, because API-made-edges never break whatever the main Sketchup setting ? So changing it back and forth seems to do nothing anyway

[thomthom]

hmm... thought the fail catching should be safe. But I might have to look into this. If TIG is right and the setting only affect the native tools and not Ruby API made edges then is is redundant...

[driven]

cheer TT,

since I did the reset I've had a couple of crashes and it's still returning 'true' at the moment.

so it maybe something else...

john

[wind-borne]

@driven said:

I was using EdgeTools recently, but didn't notice a change afterwards, it was the OP that made me think about a few oddities, very recently...

Close Gaps of Edge Tools breaks SU setting on my Mac if tolerance setting doesn't allow ends to meet.

Thanks for the help all, good learning experience now that I know the way out.

---

[driven]

hi wind-borne,

I was doing something similar then running other scripts that caused hangs... I need try those scripts now... they might work after all

a question, does it stay false after a restart when induced?

john

[wind-borne]

@driven said:

hi wind-borne,

a question, does it stay false after a restart when induced?

john

yes, restarting SU or computer has no effect but =true works like a charm

[thomthom]

hm... I cannot see why this should be happening at all. But I'm inclined to just remove the break_edges references all together.