[Plugin] SketchyFFD (Classic)

jonorman

Hi..

I think there might be a problem with FFD an ASGVIS V-ray for scetchup.. FFD did not work while i had V-ray installed but now that i have uninstalled V-ray FFD works fine again.. Same problem as with subdivide and smooth script..
can anyone else confirm this ?? Btw, FFD is a brilliant script.

GJV

woooaaaa

amazing plugin
just what I needed

thanx a lot !!!!

Dee256

Works nice! But "transformations reset" needs sometimes before FFD starts.

ideas_arte

.. thanks a million!

really useful too

niarfe

this looks like a wonderful ruby!!!

too bad it's not working for me, it doesn't do anything, and when I try undoing it beaks my geometry apart!

would have loved to use it

Chris Fullmer

Its not over yet. If its not working, then its installed wrong or your using it wrong. Or you have version 4 of SU

Could you provide a better description of what its doing wrong? Perhaps screenshots, maybe a video. Just give us some more detail and we'll get it working for you.

Chris

sprezzaturon

I'm running Sketchup 7 and just added your FFD tool. I can move points but there is no 'update FFD' option when I'm finished. Is FFD not compatible with Sketchup 7?

Thanks!

remus

The shape should update automatically, you might have to give it a bit of time, though.

If that doesnt work delete the control points, explode the group, regroup and try again.

sprezzaturon

After waiting on a 2.4 GHz dual core XP system, nothing changed. I've just installed FFD on my computer (2.1 GHz dual core) and created a circle so I could elongate one point. Nothing. This is disappointing.

remus

Have you tried it on 3d geometry? i think it can work on 2d things, but ive never gotten the hang of it.

hasan

@cphillips said:

@unknownuser said:

I can't get this script to work. Nothing happens.
I create a sphere, group it, right-click and do 3x3 FFD, enter the new group with Construction Points, move some to another position, exit the group, right-click the sphere group and choose Update FFD. Nothing happens.

Can you open the ruby console and see if it is printing any errors?

Chris

steven-arts

Hi Chriss,

it really makes fun to work with FFD! I looked at your code and found the factorial function where you mentioned to encrease performance by adding a table for factorials. I made it dynamic and it boosts your code! Just replace the section with:


#used by calcBernstein. could be replaced by a table since in 
#this application n is never more than 3 (number of control points).
$fTable = []
def factorial(n)
    sum = $fTable.rassoc(n)
    if sum
    	return sum[0]
    else
	sum = 1
	sum.upto(n) { |i| sum *= i }
	$fTable << [sum, n]
	return sum
    end
end

Ciao, Stefan

CPhillips

Thanks Stefan! Its a nice idea. I updated the plugin with an adaption of the code and applied it to the Bernstein Polynomial as well. It sped up the initial weighting of a big model from 75 seconds to 15 seconds.

I also figured out a way (in theory) to speed up the actual deformation by like 50x. The only problem is I would have to handle moving the control points without using any of Sketchups tools like select, move and rotate. Ugh!

Jim

Just wanted to bump this and make folks aware of the update.

http://forums.sketchucation.com/viewtopic.php?f=180&t=6029

mitcorb

Thank you for the update. It really is an effective modeling tool.

CPhillips

I found another way to speed the updates. A model with 11300 verts takes about 90 seconds to update in this version and about 6 seconds with the new method.

But it order to get it ready for release I would almost have to rewrite it. Because it would be a significant amount of work I am thinking I might make the new one a "Pro" version.

Question: How many would be willing to pay for a version with some significant updates? And what would be a fair price to charge?

EarthMover

Sounds like a significant speed improvement. I would pay for a Pro version with a few new features. I think in the range of $15 is fair.

MALAISE

By the way, about 10 € ( 15$) seem to be a fair sum, as far as this version is also
available for SU ( not the Pro version )...

MALAISE

boofredlay

I would pay for it too. $15 seems reasonable.

lancaster

@regis said:

Hi Tobobo

It's due to the hidden geometry.

Look at this one, it's different with the hidden geometry, you can easilly deform it where you want.
Just create the group and choose your FFD setting.
[attachment=1:3nq28v7h]curtain.skp[/attachment:3nq28v7h]

cheers

Edit

After some FFD
[attachment=0:3nq28v7h]curtainFFDv6.skp[/attachment:3nq28v7h]
cheers

FFD isn't working on my computer aswell, so i've read the whole topic to see for an answer. Unfortunately there are no answers yet.
I've downloaded the curtain.skp-file so I could try to FFD it with the sketchup version I am using. That worked fine! Other objects drawn in the curtain.skp-file transformed aswell by using the FFD plugin. However, copying the curtain into a new file: no result, no transformation.
I'll just try some other options and hopefully I or someone else will come up with an answer on why the FFD-plugin not always work...

EDIT:
In a new file I've created an 10x10 patch to transform. The transformation is succesful with an NxN FFD with default settings (4x4x4 false) and moving all 4 guidepoints.

Other tried and failed setting: 4x4x1 false, 4x4x2 false, 4x4x3 false, 4x4x5 false, 4x4x4 true, 5x5x4 false....

Seems like only the default setting work at my computer.