[Plugin] SolidSolver
-
TIG; Just curious....
Any reason SS does not work on components, but only on groups?
Since almost all my drawings are made of solid comps, I only use groups to keep stuff together, or for layering options. When SS says "Select a group..." when I select a comp, I have to edit the comp, select all, and group it to work, then explode the group. A bit of a pain.
Otherwise it works reasonably well on SU 8-Free. I generally like to cleanup my solids manually, after SI reports problems. SS tends to clobber very complex solids, which I generated in a quick but sloppy manner, so the fixing after SS may take longer than doing the fix manually in the first place.
Mind you, SS is far more adept at fixing some real toughies, such as co-linear lines, and co-resident faces. I had one "celebrated" comp that had 7 (count-em) 7 co-resident faces in 3 places. I went nuts fixing one of the faces, then sent SS after the others. I only had to redraw 2 lines to fix that after.
-
It could readily deal with component instances too - it's just easy to write for a group...
-
Here's v1.5 http://sketchucation.com/forums/viewtopic.php?p=359994#p359994
it now works on groups AND component instances; makes the result unique, if needs be. -
-
@tig said:
Here's v1.5 http://sketchucation.com/forums/viewtopic.php?p=359994#p359994
it now works on groups AND component instances; makes the result unique, if needs be.Thanks a bunch. I'll check it on Sunday.
-
Thank you TIG. Great work as always.
-
TIG;
Seems to work fine with comps now. Thanks for the response. -
@pout said:
Hey Tig, ...
Hey Pout good to see you there !
Sorry not to see you in Boulder ! -
Brilliant as usual!
-
Here's v1.6 http://sketchucation.com/forums/viewtopic.php?p=359994#p359994
It has:- Improved internal partition removal, even when they are not full width etc.
[It is still fool-able though!] - A context-menu item is now available if there is an appropriate selection.
- Its progress ... is now indicated in the status-bar.
- Improved internal partition removal, even when they are not full width etc.
-
Thanks TIG. This is something I am looking at daily--ways to make solids.
Probably an obvious idea to many: I was getting a shape that had way too many interior faces. I decided that with smoothing, I had very few outside surfaces to deal with. So I selected the outside surfaces one by one (double click) and grouped--and had a solid rather quickly, without fussing about the center.
Your work on this is really appreciated.
-
Thank you for the update!
-
Thank you TIG.
-
Here's v1.7 http://sketchucation.com/forums/viewtopic.php?p=359994#p359994
It has some speed improvements.
It has a better/harder-to-fool internal-partition removal algorithm.
The removal of coplanar-edges [if any] is now a final option. -
Here's v1.8 http://sketchucation.com/forums/viewtopic.php?p=359994#p359994
It has some more speed improvements.
It has an even better/harder-to-fool internal-partition removal algorithm.
You can repeat the process once if it's still not solid.
You may also need to try processing again 'manually' - if there are several internal-partitions facing each other etc... -
15 minutes between updates, that is fast
Thank you! -
@cotty said:
15 minutes between updates, that is fast
Thank you!Fast and accurate
This is how TIG works Thank you again TIG.
-
Updated version too fast, thank you
-
Here's v1.9 http://sketchucation.com/forums/viewtopic.php?p=359994#p359994
It has some more speed improvements.
Internal partition removal is again improved, multiple parallel face to face partitions now removed [up to ~10,000 per near-normal].I have successfully tested it on several non-solids - including the dreaded 'coil' and some others with complex internal flaps and multiple partition faces, as well as holes etc...
Please report any 'breakages' and supply me with an example SKP so I can see what's up...Sorry this update took so long but I had to go to the grocery store...
-
Advertisement