Have you had a model stolen?
-
Yes i see, heres another example, if i were to construct a model from the beginning while using anothers as reference, then would credit need to be used, heres an example, i browsed turbosquid for a Afgan town, and found pictures of a town from all angles, so i used these pictures and made a reconstruction of the town in SU, the Afgan town was on sale for $500 on turbo squid, now should i claim the modelling is mine or should i give credit to the modeller on turbosquid?? please bare in mind im not using these models to profit and i dont have them on display over the net, i just usedd this model as a test to see if i could make a reconstruction in SU
-
Just another note i think should be added, im totally against other people using others models and claiming them as their own, dont get me wrong, im not all for this carry on, i do believe credit should be given to those who create these models
-
Heres something i just tried, i looked for a car in SU Warehouse and found this Aston Martin DBR9, grenn in colour, with some yellow, search it on the warehouse, then look at this on turbosquid for $49 -
http://www.turbosquid.com/3d-models/3d-aston-martin-dbr9/507500
exactly the same, is this a stolen model?? infact everything on SU warehouse can also be found on turbosquid for a price, very gray area indeed
-
Moral of the story:
Turbosquid is overpriced crap so rather go to warehouse and get the crap for free.
-
If you create a model of something that didn't already exist you have intellectual property of it.
But if you model something that already exist you don't have any right on it. And you can't show or sell the model without express permission of the inventor. -
sounds like "someone's selling Google Chrome on the net". or, someone's selling any other freeware, open source, etc. on the net. if it's really there in 3d warehouse too. it may sound funny, if people know that the ware offered as freeware or opensource. yet someone trying to sell it.
that's for the "money making from other's effort" part.for "credits", i guess what Dave wrote above is adequate to give the idea of how bad and low the person might be. not to mention giving slime a bad name
-
@iichiversii said:
Heres something i just tried, i looked for a car in SU Warehouse and found this Aston Martin DBR9, grenn in colour, with some yellow, search it on the warehouse, then look at this on turbosquid for $49 -
http://www.turbosquid.com/3d-models/3d-aston-martin-dbr9/507500
exactly the same, is this a stolen model?? infact everything on SU warehouse can also be found on turbosquid for a price, very gray area indeed
While I'm not defending Turbosquid, and I'm certainly no expert on this or anything else, how can you be sure it's the same model? If two people choose to create an accurate model of the same car, they are bound to look very similar, and the colors could simply be a popular color scheme for that car. Unless there is something visually very distinctive in the model, something that there is virtually no possibility of two people coming up with the same design, the only way to be certain is to compare them both, in SU.
-
@gilles said:
If you create a model of something that didn't already exist you have intellectual property of it.
But if you model something that already exist you don't have any right on it. And you can't show or sell the model without express permission of the inventor.Ok, so should the architect get credited for his building you created in 3D form on a PC? after all it was the architect who designed it, your simply copying it from reference pics, measurements and so on, i used pictures of a model, but not the model to replicate a model in SU, this is a gray area no matter what, i dont agree with people stealing models and selling them
-
I'm kinda bummed out because I just checked Turbosquid and none of my models in the Warehouse have been stolen.
Guess I just don't make the cut....
-
@unigami said:
I'm kinda bummed out because I just checked Turbosquid and none of my models in the Warehouse have been stolen.
Guess I just don't make the cut....Well, from what I've heard whenever someone stole one of your fantastic models and put it up for sale there, the demand was so great that it crashed their server. So they've had to ban your models, sorry
-
@unknownuser said:
Ok, so should the architect get credited for his building you created in 3D form on a PC?
Yes. It is his masterpiece, he could hire you for modeling or built it, but it will always be his idea.
-
@gilles said:
@unknownuser said:
Ok, so should the architect get credited for his building you created in 3D form on a PC?
Yes. It is his masterpiece, he could hire you for modeling or built it, but it will always be his idea.
I totally agree
-
It is a grey area, yes...but you can't really state that a model has been stolen on the basis of thumbnail pictures. You'd need to have both meshes and do a vertex by vertex comparison. I've actually been accused of stealing stuff from the Warehouse, based on nothing other than a small preview pic, but it was a totally unfounded BS claim...precisely because of what I've just said.
As somebody already stated; if two people model the same object from the same stats (and they are any good at modelling) then the models are going to look superficially identical. In fact, my versions were more accurate and contained about 10% of the faces in the Warehouse versions....many of which are just high poly Max models imported into SU, complete with reversed faces and micro missing faces galore.As for 'borrowing' somebody's model and substantially editing it so it doesn't look the same...can you claim it as your own? No, you can't. If there is any of the orginal mesh in there, then it's not your model. Your model starts with a blank drawing window.
I've also had loads of models pirated and posted onto warez sites, but we're pretty hot on that kind of thing and Rapidshare and others are very efficient at removing them quickly.
I can't imagine why anyone would buy something from Turbosquid without checking out the Warehouse first. I'll bet a heck of a lot more stuff heads in the other direction (TS to 3DW) than the other way round.
So if you have genuinely had a Warehouse model stolen and posted to TS, I wouldn't lose any sleep over it. -
3d modeling is one of my hobbies and I enjoy sharing my creations with others. Some will download them to study and learn from and others may use them as components in their projects. Some will edit the original to suit their tastes and possibly morph it into something very different. And there are the talented rendering and post p folk who surf for models to be used to create fantastic images. I endorse all of this utilization. I do expect to be credited for my original efforts.
But...for someone to take outright credit for my work when there has been no value added by them, or worse yet, openly offer same for sale is totally unacceptable to me.
I'm willing to compromise a bit, but will not wholesale give up my freedoms in trade for better security, (encrypted software, password protection, etc...). I will probably be more discrete in the future and offer my major works by invitation only.
Here is the final reply from TurboSquid relative to the incident that prompted the start of this thread.
Recently a friend of mine submitted a request, see #87588 & #91544, regarding a model of mine that was downloaded from google 3d warehouse and offered for sale on your site by jessel sullivan. I go by the name JMJ-Ohio in the 3d warehouse. I do not know a jessel sullivan and gave no one authority to sell this model. Model in question is "Ford 427 V8 SOHC". Would you supply me details relative to the resolution of this issue.
Thank you,
Jim JeffriesHello,
I handled the case. We found that the model offered on the Google 3D Warehouse and the one on TurboSquid were the same. We took the model down and contacted the artist who posted it. The artist did not respond to our message and has been banned from TurboSquid.
Sincerely,
Kevin
TurboSquid Member Services
Basic | Advanced | Product | Licensing & Usage | Copyright & Trademark InfringementJan-09 2012 13:09
-
hi Jim,
i'm glad to read your post and see the replies from Turbo Squid.
hopefully that "slime" learnt a lesson from this. -
Just received email with the following message concerning the '67 GTO I have on the Warehouse -
Hey man Just letting ya know some dudes trying to upload this model in Second Life and trying to sell it
Tried to check it out but have no idea what "Second Life" is, couldn't find anything.Must admit that I am surprised at low number of responses in this thread, surely there are more people out there that have had their model ripped off. Sharing our experiences might help to come up with some sort of solution to this problem. As JMJOhio's experience shows, positive results can be achieved.
-
Second Life is a virtual world, where 'residents' interact via animated avatars. Rather like a 3D game but without the explosions. It was created by Linden Labs.
It's an entire community which has different areas and islands on which you can build virtual residences, shops, nightclubs or other businesses. These are built on virtual plots which can be bought with Linden Dollars. Some of these business include designing a house, creating furniture for it, or producing clothing fashions, hairstyles and other commodities. There is a system for converting real money into Linden $$$ and back again. You have to pay Linden Labs to open such a franchise I believe; and some people now actually make their entire income this way...trading virtually.
I'd have thought all the free models in the 3DW are an obvious target, not only for ordinary 2nd Life users looking for a new sofa, car or luxury yacht (fair enough), but also for unscrupulous types looking to spruce them up and convert them to the necessary format then sell them in the online marketplace linked above.
-
Reminds me of a post on pushpullbar; http://www.pushpullbar.com/forums/showthread.php?13868-Stolen-project
To summerize; someone applied for a job with a cv which included a project he stole from the firm he was applying to!
[can't find an emoticon which expresses what I feel when I read about it] -
@jmjohio said:
Recently a friend of mine submitted a request, see #87588 & #91544, regarding a model of mine that was downloaded from google 3d warehouse and offered for sale on your site by jessel sullivan. I go by the name JMJ-Ohio in the 3d warehouse. I do not know a jessel sullivan and gave no one authority to sell this model. Model in question is "Ford 427 V8 SOHC". Would you supply me details relative to the resolution of this issue.
Thank you,
Jim JeffriesHello,
I handled the case. We found that the model offered on the Google 3D Warehouse and the one on TurboSquid were the same. We took the model down and contacted the artist who posted it. The artist did not respond to our message and has been banned from TurboSquid.
Sincerely,
Kevin
TurboSquid Member Services
Basic | Advanced | Product | Licensing & Usage | Copyright & Trademark InfringementJan-09 2012 13:09
But you would wonder was this model sold at any stage and if so how many times was it sold, i believe this goes on alot and i dont post my models on the warehouse for this sole reason, until there is a solution to this on going problem ill never post models on the warehouse, it also makes me wonder how many models from the google warehouse have being stolen and sold on turbosquid, or is stolen the right word to use since we upload our models for others to freely use, i was unaware su models could be imported into second life also, if we were to look trough the second life store what would we find there, for example if i owned a furniture shop in second life i could simply download every bit of furniture from the google warehouse and sell it for a price in second life, would i?? No, its wrong but there are people who would, second life is so big, i once read that a virtual house was sold in around $160,000 give or take, this is a booming virtual world and like in the real world there is crime, but is it a crime, for example in the real world if i want to get rid of a sofa i cold simply leave it outside and within a day or 2 some1 will take it, what they do with it is there problem not mine, if i upload a model in the warehouse its practically the same, what they do with the model isnt my problem, we can argue this forever and simply end back where we started, i agree i wouldnt like someone selling a model of mine on turbosquid or second life without my permision but if i load a model onto the warehouse its bound to happen, if there was a way you could copyright your models in su where a code is added to a model and this code could be viewed by turbosquid or secondlife administrators i think this would be the only way this problem could be solved, so what are your views on a way to copyright your models in su?? just an idea
-
Legally speaking, according 3D warehouse terms of Service 11.1.b. and 11.1.c. downloader of your uploaded model automatically obtains a license to sell modify redistribute etc (except google proprietary content like satellite images, terrrain, photo textures etc.). There is nothing wrong about someone selling your 3D warehouse models in TurboSquid. I think Turbosquid may have overreached by banning that user.
Ethically it is a different matter...
Cheers
Ogan
Advertisement