[REQ] Edge 2 Groove

EarthMover · 28 Apr 2012, 22:07

I remember also, just can't seem to find it.

Actually support for adjoining faces which are not coplanar would be preferable.

I would like to add groves to something like the following -

EarthMover · 28 Apr 2012, 22:08

@unknownuser said:

Sorry Pilou...don't have V6 installed anymore.

Last V8 don't permit Save as V6 ?

The viewer V8 don't work on my old computer!

Sorry Pilou, I misunderstood. I updated the test model saved as V6.

pilou · 28 Apr 2012, 22:33

No Problem
Many Thanks !
In therory if the there no special element like DC or other news it's better to save in V6
As like, V6, V7, V8 users can reload it

Rich O Brien · 28 Apr 2012, 22:35

@Pilou

Do you have v8 installed? Surely you must...

sdmitch · 28 Apr 2012, 22:45

In my plugin, the top groove is not a problem. But the side grooves either cross or diverge when pushpulled due to the faces not being coplanar.

as the image shows.

pilou · 28 Apr 2012, 22:45

Yes but on other computer
I have this old one (ten years) for test some programs for old configs for some coders

pilou · 28 Apr 2012, 23:13

@ EarthMover
Why your model has no bottom faces?
That will not solids! So possibilitiy to use boolean operation will be forbidden!

pilou · 28 Apr 2012, 23:29

So the plug is not optimized
Keep the good work!
I have not yet found a super trick with plugs existing
It's not very easy to select only the section between "elements" for some tricky actions

And carreful here you have quadrangular sections, but your plug must work with any polygonal "sections" !
So regular PushPull will not work!

pilou · 28 Apr 2012, 23:32

Curiously the Select Lines by Length By Chris Fulmer don't work with your object

TIG · 29 Apr 2012, 10:08

As sdmitch has found, doing it programmatically is fraught with challenges...

pilou · 29 Apr 2012, 13:05

like this

Red and Green prism volumes are equal
Groove is constant
Click for all image

TIG · 29 Apr 2012, 13:47

That only works for parallel faced boxes - it won't work if it has non-parallel facets or only some faces are to be grooved...

pilou · 29 Apr 2012, 13:53

That is the case of the EartMover example asked
Just angle change between elements so the prism will be not always the same

EarthMover · 29 Apr 2012, 14:04

@unknownuser said:

@ EarthMover
Why your model has no bottom faces?
That will not solids! So possibilitiy to use boolean operation will be forbidden!

Sorry Pilou, I forgot I deleted the bottom faces while playing with Profile Builder. Forgot to add them back. If you close the bottom face, you can add the edges back using "Split Sausage".

The shape was made by drawing 2 curves, then using BZ Convert to Polyline Divider to regulate the segments. (Or SDMitch's EqSegCurve would work) I think I then used Extrude Edges by Vector in the Z direction and JPP to add volume. (Or you could go Extrude Edges by Offset, JPP) Thus maintaining the segments throughout the process.

Not sure why select edges by length doesn't work for you. Quad Face tools, select loops and rings should work fine as it's all quads. Also , with Selection Toys > Selected Quad Face Loops to select the faces in loop. Also easy to drag select all and Selection Toys > Select only edges or faces.

EarthMover · 29 Apr 2012, 14:25

@tig said:

As sdmitch has found, doing it programmatically is fraught with challenges...

I see. The distance changes between the perpendicular offsets. I guess ideally would be to move the offset edges via their verticies, essentially moving four verts and connecting them, instead of four edges and trying to align them. Of course I have no idea if this is possible, just thinking out loud!

What if the top and sides were run with separate operations? Or if corners were restricted to only 90 degrees? My example is a bit extreme for most users who would need a tool like this. Things like furniture, buildings and other wood structures are typically square. I do a lot curved step treads, curved knee walls, pool copings, brick banding, arches, etc. However, what I do might be too generalized for what would benefit the masses. I just don't want to put my needs ahead of others.