A new home for SketchUp
-
Are people really going to walk away from SketchUp before they even see the direction it's going?
-
@thomthom said:
Are people really going to walk away from SketchUp before they even see the direction it's going?
Neah...it's just fear talking.
-
Some people are on the edge of moving this could be the push they need. I am however hopefull my only issues with sketch up are performance related and high poly support. This is surely a given now they are entering the pro market. I do fear for the free users however who may eventually be dropped. Googles do no evil was a good thing. Has Mr Bacus mentioned version 9 anywhere, it has to be in development right ? I'm guessing it will be launched under the trimble banner and then they will start producing their add ons.
-
@chedda said:
Some people are on the edge of moving this could be the push they need.
Push for what? There is no clear indication to what this involves. Why abandon ship before it's sinking?
I understand cautious - I am. But saying goodbye already now is just rash.@chedda said:
I do fear for the free users however who may eventually be dropped.
From the announcement it seem clear that there will remain free SketchUp version.
@chedda said:
Googles do no evil was a good thing
Well, do no evil doesn't mean they do just good.
How much enhancement did SketchUp get during the Google era vs the @Last era? Thing did for sure slow down - at least for those that didn't have that much for the integration with Google's mapping services. In terms of modelling tools, Solid tools for Pro was about what SketchUp got while Google managed it. Google is a might large company - but that doesn't mean all their projects are on unlimited budget. Also observe the amount of information that came from the SketchUp developers during @Last vs Google.
Just say, while I am a Google fan, they aren't automatically the best thing.@chedda said:
Has Mr Bacus mentioned version 9 anywhere, it has to be in development right ?
I wouldn't expect such announcements during an acquisition. They will need to re-group and re-plan. The game just changed. Observe what happened to V-Ray for SketchUp and V-Ray for Rhino when ChaosGroup acquired ASGVis - their planned roadmap had to be revised.
@chedda said:
I'm guessing it will be launched under the trimble banner and then they will start producing their add ons.
There is what I hope it will be - as addons - as plugins. So SketchUp remains lean and simple. A core platform we can build our own software on.
-
A smart move would be to tidy up what work has already been done on SU9 and release it ASAP in order to dispell the fears of the user-base and show that Trimble has a progressive attitude to the development of SU.
They can then take their time and leave any major changes and Trimble integration until SU10.
-
Without deviation from the norm progress is not possible. - Frank Zappa
-
Indeed a bit scary this change.
But on the other hand, I worried about SketchUp's future within Google.
With the focus on "core-business" these days, the investments in SketchUp would have at least diminished to a bare minimum.I don't really know Trimble, but I believe their "vision" for BIM is O.K. from what I have read about Tekla.
I am also really glad it's not Autodesk!!!Good luck to the SketchUp team, and I agree "keep the focus on user-prowdness"!
Untill now I always tell anyone that SketchUp is the most fun piece of software I've ever used
I hope to be able to say that a year from now!Jan
-
As a free sketchup user and google opensource "fan", this not the best annoucement I would have expected (wouldn't dare to say a sad one ).
we can't deny the fact that google brought a lot of new users ( mainly because of the free version) .that it has blown a fresh air on the AEC softwares( compare how many sketchup clones and how many free softwares since its apprearence under the google umbrella. )._ not to mention the Sketchup plugins from the leading softwares in the industry...
All I Hope is that it will continue with Trimble...
@last has done a great work with SKetchup, but I didn't pay attention to Sketchup until google bought it ( even if i've heard about it when it was @last ). I do understand their feeling when seeing their software not evolving as they wanted it to be . And also Glad that they continue as Sketchup developpers. ( more success Wishes.)
-
Regarding V9; from what I understand it is on indefinite postponement. This isn't as dire as it sounds...with acquisition in the wind and almost certainly new enhancements that would at least in part be aimed at further Google Earth integration (and therefore maybe not relevant to Trimble), it would make absolute sense to hit the brakes and take stock of new directions and new possibilities, whilst at the same time perfoming some sort of feature-ectomy on stuff that might be no longer relevant.
I'm sure most people would welcome some kind of mid-version release (sooner rather than later)...if only to give us some idea as to what they have been working on, as concrete evidence of continued commitment and maybe a glimpse of which direction we may be heading in the future.
-
It wouldn't surprise me if SU9 is used as the licence transfer sweetner in the same way Google moved the @last users...
If Trimble can turn SU into a pro product e.g. arcs are true arcs and LO becomes a lot more professional with hatching etc then things will be moving forward. If it is absorbed as a core engine into specialist products then its appeal as a do anything modeller may be diminished. I dropped ArchiCAD because SU is flexible to my design needs, I don't need another "expert" system telling me how to design and what I can include in my projects.
Fingers crossed Trimble have seen the SU & LO wishlists and they will form the basis for their road map!
-
"People work so hard on new plugins because they believe in your software, they even offer to help and inspire newcomers. This is pride, and I recommend your team lets that become your navigation as SketchUp develops further. Good luck!" -- Christopher Vela
Hear, hear! SU's USP I would say.
-
Hello Google Earth....goodbye subdividing, smoothing and the nurb nation.....Blender anyone?
-
In the old Dassualt thread ( http://forums.sketchucation.com/viewtopic.php?f=15&t=43693 ) I said pretty much everything I thought (and still think) about Googles poor stewardship of SketchUp.
The best thing Google ever did for SketchUp was attach their name to it -- therefore I was more enthused about Dassault only because it is a company already known for 3D software and they have some clout in the marketplace. This would be my only concern with Trimble... but I have no doubt that SketchUp can be made into a very profitable and much more productive tool now that there is new ownership.
Best,
Jason. -
@brewsky said:
Untill now I always tell anyone that SketchUp is the most fun piece of software I've ever used
I hope to be able to say that a year from now!+1
-
@unknownuser said:
Hello Google Earth....goodbye subdividing, smoothing and the nurb nation.....Blender anyone?
That should be Goodbye Google Earth, surely? Sounds more like pessimism for its own sake. SU development was far more dynamic under @Last stewardship than it ever was under Google (Anyone remember that wonderful off-the-wall 3D materials that dynamically added depth to single-skin walls?) Even Google's Forum was totally sucky...which is why we are all here (and I speak from my experience both as a beta tester and as a Moderator on the original @Last forum). Here's hoping we get a little more of that old style in future.
-
Good luck, Sketchup Team .
Please tell your new boss that it is very important that Sketchup runs faster for bigger projects (64 bit/higher polygon capabilities , faster with sun-shadows on/ faster outliner etc...
For architecture , especially bigger projects that incorporate photorealistic rendering with external plugins, it has been a dream since the @Last era to have a smoother running Sketchup for that goal.
In architecture, Sketchup is still the 3D product where everybody has a laugh with.
Whenever I tell people I use Sketchup mainly as my architecture modeling software , response usually is "are you serious?", expecting the 3DStudio, Maya, Revit, Archicad as the answer. -
@unknownuser said:
That should be Goodbye Google Earth,
No it is going to become the focus of their activity...they are in the positioning business.
Good news for the arch-vis community. -
@kwistenbiebel said:
very important that Sketchup runs faster for bigger projects (64 bit/higher polygon capabilities , faster with sun-shadows on/ faster outliner etc...
You are aware that 64bit doesn't mean faster speeds, right? Just more memory.
http://blogs.sas.com/content/sasdummy/2012/04/19/myths-about-64-bit-computing-on-windows/ -
@unknownuser said:
.[/size]
imo, all sketchup free development could cease at this moment and the free users would still be left with a great product..
years ago, i spent $500 on an app that was far inferior to what sketchup free is today.. and i was hyped when i bought it!
but they're saying that a free version will remain available and i honestly don't see them down scaling the free version to something unusable.. in fact, i really don't imagine they will downscale it all..
I believe a free version will remain, but I still have a concern regarding what will be available on that version. Also, plugins are a concern. As SU advances under Trimble, will compatibility exist for the current plugin set or will it be phased out in favor of paid plugins?
-
@thomthom said:
@kwistenbiebel said:
very important that Sketchup runs faster for bigger projects (64 bit/higher polygon capabilities , faster with sun-shadows on/ faster outliner etc...
You are aware that 64bit doesn't mean faster speeds, right? Just more memory.
http://blogs.sas.com/content/sasdummy/2012/04/19/myths-about-64-bit-computing-on-windows/Scratch 64 bit, just 'faster' and more responsive in which ever way that would translate technically
.
I suspect it has more to do with how Sketchup was coded than any other reason.
A very simple example: exploding a large model is not possible in an elegant way, if you're lucky it actually worked after SU being unresponsive for 4 hours.
Those kind of immensely annoying things
Advertisement