[Plugin][$] Curviloft 2.0a - 31 Mar 24 (Loft & Skinning)

mac1 · 9 Sept 2011, 14:32

jgb
have you tried this http://www.smustard.com/script/StrayLines

jgb · 9 Sept 2011, 15:45

jgb
have you tried this http://www.smustard.com/script/StrayLines

I think I looked at this some time ago, and found it not quite suitable in several, but common to me, occurrences. It works well with lines, but I had too many "no finds" when 2 or more vertexes of existing faces had a "no-face" micro gap between them. Maybe I used it wrong, dunno; too long ago.

I will try it again; thanks.

mac1 · 9 Sept 2011, 16:17

@jgb said:

@mac1 said:

jgb
have you tried this http://www.smustard.com/script/StrayLines

I think I looked at this some time ago, and found it not quite suitable in several, but common to me, occurrences. It works well with lines, but I had too many "no finds" when 2 or more vertexes of existing faces had a "no-face" micro gap between them. Maybe I used it wrong, dunno; too long ago.

I will try it again; thanks.

Applying multiple times helps some times and of course it does one seg at a time ,so you can make a stray line shorter and shorter
There are programs with filters that allow you to close close vertices based on a tolerance you input. Meshlab comes to mind but would not recommend you use. Check out ThmoThoms clean up since it may have a similar function. You may need to contact him to find out how to modiy code if it uses a fixed tol

ivreich · 14 Sept 2011, 04:46

Soft Diagonals Feature?

Hi Fredo

Any plans to allow Curviloft to generate meshes with soft diagonals? This will enable Curviloft meshes to be edited with thomthom's new quad face tools (if i'm not mistaken)

Cheers,

Joel

thomthom · 14 Sept 2011, 07:43

@ivreich said:

Soft Diagonals Feature?

Hi Fredo

Any plans to allow Curviloft to generate meshes with soft diagonals? This will enable Curviloft meshes to be edited with thomthom's new quad face tools (if i'm not mistaken)

Cheers,

Joel

http://forums.sketchucation.com/viewtopic.php?f=323&t=39442&start=0#p348519

ivreich · 14 Sept 2011, 13:42

@thomthom said:

@ivreich said:

Soft Diagonals Feature?

Hi Fredo

Any plans to allow Curviloft to generate meshes with soft diagonals? This will enable Curviloft meshes to be edited with thomthom's new quad face tools (if i'm not mistaken)

Cheers,

Joel

http://forums.sketchucation.com/viewtopic.php?f=323&t=39442&start=0#p348519

ahhh woops. my bad. didn't see that.

j

jgb · 14 Sept 2011, 14:40

Posted in another of my threads, this is slightly edited version.

Curviloft; when it fails to form a surface (as part of a solid construction), even though it shows a black pre-form surface, still generates an empty, or perhaps an almost empty group that SU interprets to be as a non solid. Solid Inspector will correctly say it finds no errors, but SU will not see it as a solid. And if you try to re-do that failed surface, you get another empty group.

The only way out, is if you know you do have a valid solid after a Curviloft fail, but SU says not, then edit the solid and do a sweeping left select to select everything. Using TT's selection tools, select only groups, and there it is. Just hit the <delete> key to get rid of it. You cannot select just that empty group. If you have other valid groups in that selection, then deselect them first.

Fredo.... Could you please do something about NOT creating an empty group when CL fails to form a surface?

fredo6 · 14 Sept 2011, 17:21

@jgb said:

Fredo.... Could you please do something about NOT creating an empty group when CL fails to form a surface?

Thanks for signaling this problem. I will indeed fix it.
Do you have an example of a model where it fails?

@ivreich said:

Any plans to allow Curviloft to generate meshes with soft diagonals? This will enable Curviloft meshes to be edited with thomthom's new quad face tools (if i'm not mistaken)

I have plans!
Note that it will slightly slow down the generation of the faces however.

Fredo

jgb · 15 Sept 2011, 14:15

I will try to duplicate the problem, because I modified the object in that area since that happened, but if I can't I will post next time it happens.

But when you say you will fix the problem... which one; the fail to form a surface when a black face does pre-form, or the empty group when that happens???

EDIT ---------------

Fortunately the problem box model still had the empty group problem when I reversed my changes.

You are looking at the open face from beneath and inside the box structure. That box was a clean solid but I had to change the angle slightly on the 2 end faces (4 faces total). 3 of the faces remained intact, 1 face vanished. I selected its' 4 edges but the SU "Face" command would not form the face.

Then I re-selected the 4 edges and used CL "Skin". The black preform appeared with only a single face. But when I clicked finish, it disappeared and nothing showed. I tried a few times, but same result. So I just drew a diagonal and the surface formed with 2 triangles. When I exited the object, SU said it was not a solid. SI said it was a solid. I had this problem before with an embedded group, not knowing why it happened, but I knew now how to fix them.

So I went back into edit mode, and did a left sweep select, then a TT Select "groups". and there they were, several empty groups outlining my 4 edges. When I hit <del> and exited, SU said I had a solid.

I did a CL skin on the posted model but left the empty group intact for you to analyze.

Empty Group on 1 inside face.

fredo6 · 15 Sept 2011, 21:29

I see the empty group. It is true that it is not easy to detect.

At least I can try to prevent empty groups to be created (except if the face disappears afterwards).

Playing with the 4 edges, I could reconstruct the face, whether the empty group was present or not, with pre-selection or manual selection. The mystery remains why the face was not generated or vanished.

Fredo

jgb · 15 Sept 2011, 22:58

@unknownuser said:

I see the empty group. It is true that it is not easy to detect.

At least I can try to prevent empty groups to be created (except if the face disappears afterwards).

Playing with the 4 edges, I could reconstruct the face, whether the empty group was present or not, with pre-selection or manual selection. The mystery remains why the face was not generated or vanished.

Fredo

The "Black Face Forms - No White Face formed" has happened many times before. It seems more prevalent when I try to form a flat face that would not face via the SU face command. But other curves have generated a "Black Face - no White Face" as well, not just flats. But in many of those cases if I do the curve in 2 or more sections, it works.

fredo6 · 21 Sept 2011, 21:49

NEW RELEASE: Curviloft 1.2a - 21 Sep 11

IMPORTANT: you need to install LibFredo6 4.2 (or higher). With this version of LibFredo6, the ZLoader__Curviloft.rb is no longer necessary.

This release includes the generation of pseudo-quads for usage by the new QuadFaceTools by Thomthom.

The surface is generated out of quads with a diagonal which is Soft and Smooth.

Because there always 2 ways to triangulate a quad, Curviloft offers both options.

This release also prevents to get an empty group when something goes wrong in the generation of the geometry. This problem was signaled by jgb (see this post ).

See main post for download

Fredo

thomthom · 26 Sept 2011, 07:24

Very nice Fredo.
I'll be looking into the revised definition of a Quad this week. I like your suggestion.

(Btw, I see that the preview still display black meshes - you know that SU8 now makes use of view.drawingcolor, yes?)

fredo6 · 26 Sept 2011, 09:19

@thomthom said:

:thumb:
Very nice Fredo.
I'll be looking into the revised definition of a Quad this week. I like your suggestion.

I will release an update with

Border: Soft + Smooth
Diagonals: Soft + Smooth + Hidden

@thomthom said:

(Btw, I see that the preview still display black meshes - you know that SU8 now makes use of view.drawingcolor, yes?)

I know, but for Curviloft, I'll keep Black anyway (due to the visual matching with the various colors of the lines).

Fredo

fredo6 · 26 Sept 2011, 11:09

NEW RELEASE: Curviloft 1.2b - 26 Sep 11

IMPORTANT: you need to install LibFredo6 4.2 (or higher). With this version of LibFredo6, the ZLoader__Curviloft.rb is no longer necessary.

This release includes more options for the generation of pseudo-quads for usage by the new QuadFaceTools by Thomthom.

Options are available in the Default Parameters dialog box

By default, pseudo-quads are generated with:

Borders: Soft + Smooth
Diagonals: Soft + Smooth + Hidden

This allows to have a nice-looking surface, while being compliant with all functionality of Thomthom quads tool (which should be upgraded soon)

See main post for download

Fredo

thomthom · 26 Sept 2011, 11:17

FYI to users of QuadFace 0.3 and earlier, you must set the border edges to not be soft.

So for QuadFace 0.3 and earlier:
Diagonal: Soft + Smooth (Hidden may be set - not required)
Border: Not Soft (Smooth and Hidden can be set, but not a requirement)

QuadFace 0.4
Diagonal: Soft + Smooth + Hidden (All required)
Border: Not diagonal. (Any combo can be used as long as not all the checkboxes are ticked.)