Joint and Split don't work in groups?

bjanzen

Split / Join in groups: yup, known issue. I also filed a bug to request inferencing be turned off, so that you don't get the impression that they should work. Workaround is to ungroup, do your split / join actions, then regroup.
Shape with hole: like this?

b

bjanzen

Here's what the LayOut document contains...

Yours truly, and with deepest thoughts of gratitude and ever-growing respect and love with a mild dose of humor and sarcasm,

b

Gjenio

That's exactly what I was looking for.
How did you do that?
Wonderful!
Thanx a lot

bjanzen

Try this, and I'll clarify if necessary.

bjanzen

Dave R

Hmmm....That's interesting. I would be nice to have an Intersect function so you could just delete the face in the center.

Thank you for showing that.

Charlie__V

bjansen,

Good stuff....thanks for the detailed explanation.

I would only add that if you would like to still show a stroke @ inner and outer shapes.

Before splitting shapes, select....shift....both shapes and copy to clipboard.
After splitting and deselecting stroke per your tutorial for the combined shape, paste initial shapes from clipboard and deselect fill from these shapes, then group the lot.
If necessary arrange order front to back etc.

Best,
C

bjanzen

Yea, the only issue with grouping is you can't use a group as a clipping mask. So either method (intersection, use group as clipping mask) I'd take as a feature request to accomplish the same thing. Personally, I want to make those postcards with the name of your state in big stencil block letters, and put nature images in the background clipped by the letters, ya know...

b

Dave R

Could you make the text in some other app--even SketchUp--and then make a PNG with transparency and use it as the clipping mask?

bjanzen

Yup, that's what one of my co-workers came up with. You wouldn't have to do a clipping mask, just arrange one model (or whatever you want to mask) behind another model that's the square with the circle intersected. Not a bad solution at all - I just like circles (and the freehand tool, being able to move points) better in LayOut 2.0.

There are always options...

b