@jql said:
- If you could vote by mobile phone/online, what if your identity is stolen, hacked, pirated?
JQL,
I often hear arguments about voting by phone / online. These arguments are normally put forward by politicians. My answer is simply that I do a lot of transactions via the phone and online. I bank online, I pay bills online I book services online and I buy products online. Yes, my identity could be hacked and my bank account could be cleaned out but I think there is probably more chance of my house being broken into.
If I were to regularly vote in referendums a simple double check system would be to publish the votes using a reference code. The voter can then look up their reference code and be sure that their vote is per their wishes.
@jql said:
- If you put matters into the hands of people do you trust the wisdom of masses of people which have not the formal education of well trained politicians (one of the arguments of defenders of monarchy)
I feel that there is far more expertise on all subjects in the mass population when compared to politicians. Currently the two leading politicians in Ireland are ex-school teachers ..... I rest my case.
@jql said:
- What about the minorities rights? (which is exactly what democracy is there to defend in what politicians is concerned)
Its the overall population of countries that take care of the minority groups in the country. Current day politicians only seem to be interested in taking care of the bankers!
@jql said:
There are more but I really think every one of the arguments can be rebated. All except one:
What about the influence of the media? If power shifts sides from politicians to the people as true democracy means, then people who controlled the mind of the people are the new rules: This means mass media, which get's me really scared as they, without votes, can influence the world way of thinking right now, with much greater efficacy than politicians do.
When you say, "If power shifts sides from politicians to the people", I think you may be missing my point. 'Power' should remain with the 'People' at all times. There should be no difference in politicians aims the aims of the 'People'.
After all they are suppose the be serving the People.
I don't worry too much about the influence of the (establishment) media, newspapers, state controller TV / radio and big TV networks. The Net has countered this with alternative 'information givers' also these sites offer the readers the ability to have their say also.
@jql said:
Overall though, I believe there's only 2 things that can grant us freedom and peace, and those things can't be ruled: they're tolerance and culture.
Unfortunately there's not much of both in the world.
I agree that tolerance is important but there are times when we have to stand up and be counted through force if need be.
Culture is also important but the 'new culture' of Corporate Power I see encompassing the World is not a culture I would embrace.
Its easy to moan and groan, as I am doing here. So here is what I propose for my neck of the woods.
a. Eliminate the Political Party System. As elected politicians serve the Party before their electorate.
b. In Ireland we have 15 Ministers, Finance, Health, Social Protection, Industry etc etc. I would like to see individuals putting themselves forward for elections. The best man / woman would be elected on their policies / abilities.
c. As these 15 individually elected Ministers sit around the Government Table and come up with compromise policies as would have to be the case they then put the various options to the people for final approval via referendums. If an agreed number of citizens want a further voting options put on the table to be put before the People this should be implemented also.
d. Each Minister would be required to get approval of over 50% of the electorate each year in order to hold the post. If he /she is deemed 'not performing' as per their initial policies they get kicked out and a new person, possibly the runner up in the initial election take over the reins.
JQL, 'Group Knowledge' has very high correct answer / decision rates and the bigger the group the more times it hits on the correct answer / decision.
I believe we now have the technology to use the knowledge / ability of the total electorate and should be doing now. Politicians and the People should be working in partnership on an ongoing basis.