sketchucation logo sketchucation
    • Login
    ℹ️ Licensed Extensions | FredoBatch, ElevationProfile, FredoSketch, LayOps, MatSim and Pic2Shape will require license from Sept 1st More Info

    Helix Along Curve - Is not working on curves?!

    Scheduled Pinned Locked Moved Plugins
    18 Posts 5 Posters 20 Views 5 Watching
    Loading More Posts
    • Oldest to Newest
    • Newest to Oldest
    • Most Votes
    Reply
    • Reply as topic
    Log in to reply
    This topic has been deleted. Only users with topic management privileges can see it.
    • R Offline
      Richard-Leeds-UK
      last edited by

      Hi everyone.

      Helix along curve - great plugin, always worked without any issue.

      But today , all of a sudden it refuses to work on a curved path. See attached image. Straight lines, no problem, curve - nope!

      Is anyone else finding this / ever found this?

      Have uninstalled / reinstalled plug in. Tried absolutely everything I can think of.

      Thank you.


      helix problem.png

      1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
      • Rich O BrienR Offline
        Rich O Brien Moderator
        last edited by

        https://i.imgur.com/1CM513w.png

        Works on 2022 and 2023 for me.

        Download the free D'oh Book for SketchUp πŸ“–

        1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
        • R Offline
          Richard-Leeds-UK
          last edited by

          Thanks for the reply Rich

          1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
          • BoxB Offline
            Box
            last edited by

            Looks like a tiny face issue, when it goes around the curve it is failing to form the tiny faces.
            Scale up by 100 and try again.

            1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 1
            • Rich O BrienR Offline
              Rich O Brien Moderator
              last edited by

              @box said:

              Looks like a tiny face issue

              What he is saying is that SketchUp dislikes kids πŸ‘

              Download the free D'oh Book for SketchUp πŸ“–

              1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
              • R Offline
                Richard-Leeds-UK
                last edited by

                @box said:

                Looks like a tiny face issue, when it goes around the curve it is failing to form the tiny faces.
                Scale up by 100 and try again.

                Thanks for the reply, Box - still no joy 😞

                Scaled up the path, and also the radius dimensions to match.

                1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                • Dave RD Offline
                  Dave R
                  last edited by

                  @richard-leeds-uk said:

                  Scaled up the path, and also the radius dimensions to match.

                  Share the .skp file so we can see what you're working with.

                  What version of SketchUp? What operating system? Please complete your forum profile.

                  Etaoin Shrdlu

                  %

                  (THERE'S NO PLACE LIKE)

                  G28 X0.0 Y0.0 Z0.0

                  M30

                  %

                  1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                  • R Offline
                    Richard-Leeds-UK
                    last edited by

                    @dave r said:

                    @richard-leeds-uk said:

                    Scaled up the path, and also the radius dimensions to match.

                    Share the .skp file so we can see what you're working with.

                    What version of SketchUp? What operating system? Please complete your forum profile.

                    Thanks Dave have attached the .skp file and updated profile.


                    HELIX CURVE ERROR.skp

                    1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                    • Dave RD Offline
                      Dave R
                      last edited by

                      Does this look like what you want?
                      Screenshot - 12_11_2023 , 10_47_59 AM.png

                      First I welded the edges so it's easier to select the entire path. Then I created a component which I copied. I scaled the copy up by a factor of 1000. In the UI for Helix Along Curve I entered the values as you showed (although I used the recommended value for Adherence).

                      The issue in your model is the tiny size as Box alluded to. Scaling up gets around that. There's no error in the extension.

                      Here's the file with the large copy. Select that copy and delete it. Then hit Zoom Extents to see the orignal one.
                      HELIX CURVE NO ERROR.skp

                      Etaoin Shrdlu

                      %

                      (THERE'S NO PLACE LIKE)

                      G28 X0.0 Y0.0 Z0.0

                      M30

                      %

                      1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                      • R Offline
                        Richard-Leeds-UK
                        last edited by

                        @dave r said:

                        Does this look like what you want?
                        [attachment=1:2nb17x6r]<!-- ia1 -->Screenshot - 12_11_2023 , 10_47_59 AM.png<!-- ia1 -->[/attachment:2nb17x6r]

                        First I welded the edges so it's easier to select the entire path. Then I created a component which I copied. I scaled the copy up by a factor of 1000. In the UI for Helix Along Curve I entered the values as you showed (although I used the recommended value for Adherence).

                        The issue in your model is the tiny size as Box alluded to. Scaling up gets around that. There's no error in the extension.

                        Here's the file with the large copy. Select that copy and delete it. Then hit Zoom Extents to see the orignal one.
                        [attachment=0:2nb17x6r]<!-- ia0 -->HELIX CURVE NO ERROR.skp<!-- ia0 -->[/attachment:2nb17x6r]

                        Brill, thanks Dave R for your help.

                        I still can't understand why the helix generates on a straight path of the same dimensions but not the curve (even at 100x scale) - but never mind! πŸ˜„

                        Thanks again - everyone!

                        1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                        • Dave RD Offline
                          Dave R
                          last edited by

                          The edge segments were still too short at that size. How will you use this helix now that you have it? I'm wondering if you even need it to be so small.

                          Etaoin Shrdlu

                          %

                          (THERE'S NO PLACE LIKE)

                          G28 X0.0 Y0.0 Z0.0

                          M30

                          %

                          1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                          • BoxB Offline
                            Box
                            last edited by

                            @richard-leeds-uk said:

                            I still can't understand why the helix generates on a straight path of the same dimensions but not the curve (even at 100x scale)

                            The tiny face issue isn't actually about the faces, it is the spacial relationship of the vertices of the edges. When they get very close together Sketchup decides they are suppose to be in the same place and will just ignore them. An over simplification but basically the problem.
                            So while the helix is following a straight path the vertices are just far enough apart to work but as they go around the arc their spacial orientation changes moving them closer together causing them to fail.
                            It is very common with a simple follow me to have it work along a straight edge but then fail around a radius corner, Or a small sphere will end up with a hole in the top and bottom. In the sphere the edge lengths should be long enough for it to work but it is the distance the vertices are apart on the z axis that causes the problem.


                            Screenshot 2023-12-12 090817.png

                            1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                            • R Offline
                              Richard-Leeds-UK
                              last edited by

                              @dave r said:

                              The edge segments were still too short at that size. How will you use this helix now that you have it? I'm wondering if you even need it to be so small.

                              I was modelling a kitchen tap for CGI on our website, it was drawn at 1:1.

                              One of the final renders attached πŸ˜„


                              sample tap render.jpg

                              1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                              • R Offline
                                Richard-Leeds-UK
                                last edited by

                                @box said:

                                @richard-leeds-uk said:

                                I still can't understand why the helix generates on a straight path of the same dimensions but not the curve (even at 100x scale)

                                The tiny face issue isn't actually about the faces, it is the spacial relationship of the vertices of the edges. When they get very close together Sketchup decides they are suppose to be in the same place and will just ignore them. An over simplification but basically the problem.
                                So while the helix is following a straight path the vertices are just far enough apart to work but as they go around the arc their spacial orientation changes moving them closer together causing them to fail.
                                It is very common with a simple follow me to have it work along a straight edge but then fail around a radius corner, Or a small sphere will end up with a hole in the top and bottom. In the sphere the edge lengths should be long enough for it to work but it is the distance the vertices are apart on the z axis that causes the problem.

                                Thanks, Box for the explanation - most appreciated & useful πŸ˜„

                                1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                • ntxdaveN Offline
                                  ntxdave
                                  last edited by

                                  Your final result looks good to me. πŸ‘ πŸ‘

                                  1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                  • R Offline
                                    Richard-Leeds-UK
                                    last edited by

                                    @dave r said:

                                    @richard-leeds-uk said:

                                    it was drawn at 1:1.

                                    If it's for a render like you show, it wouldn't have to be 1:1.

                                    Yes I appreciate that - it's a habit i'm in drawing in millimetres for many years - I should totally set my units to metres and pretend they are MMs when using sketchup.

                                    Lots of my work however is necessary at 1:1 for transferring to layout etc.

                                    1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                    • Dave RD Offline
                                      Dave R
                                      last edited by

                                      @richard-leeds-uk said:

                                      it was drawn at 1:1.

                                      If it's for a render like you show, it wouldn't have to be 1:1.

                                      Nice render, by the way.

                                      These are just quickie renders from a model I did. In reality the base of the key is 3 in. wide by 4.75 in. long. In my model it's 3 meters by 4.75 meters so that I could create the tiny detail like the screw threads, spring, and raised text without risking loss of faces.

                                      https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/53229724914_5789ca626c_b.jpg


                                      https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/53229043938_5a7e43dc1c_b.jpg

                                      Etaoin Shrdlu

                                      %

                                      (THERE'S NO PLACE LIKE)

                                      G28 X0.0 Y0.0 Z0.0

                                      M30

                                      %

                                      1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                      • ntxdaveN Offline
                                        ntxdave
                                        last edited by

                                        Like you model too Dave R. πŸ‘ πŸ‘ πŸ‘

                                        1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                        • 1 / 1
                                        • First post
                                          Last post
                                        Buy SketchPlus
                                        Buy SUbD
                                        Buy WrapR
                                        Buy eBook
                                        Buy Modelur
                                        Buy Vertex Tools
                                        Buy SketchCuisine
                                        Buy FormFonts

                                        Advertisement