Solid tools on components
-
Hi sketchucation I have a problem.
When I perform a solid tool operation (like trim) of one solid component against an other solid component I would expect that the operation affects all other components of the same instances in the model the same way. But in my modell it doesn't it only affects the two componets on which I perform the solid tool operation. Why is that so? I want all components to be affected.
...I'm relatively new to components and have been mostly working with groups so far.
-
What you are seeing is normal behavior although I wish it wasn't. The component that gets modified by the Solid Tool operation becomes a group called 'Difference.' I've asked for them to change this since the release of the Solid Tools in V8 but you can see how much good that did.
On the bright side, Jim wrote Trim and Keep which is available in the Sketchucation Extension Store and Julia Eneroth wrote an extension that covers the solid tools, too. You can get hers from the Extension Warehouse. For my use, Trim and Keep does the job and I prefer how it works. I use it so frequently, it gets its own keyboard shortcut.
-
Thanks for the heads up on the plugins Dave!
If you have a bunch of component instances. edit the component, make a group, then perform the solid tools function.
-
I don't understand Peter.
-
I also don't understand Peter.
I had a little workaround going which was to create a nested component containing component A and B by copying component A into B, then to transform the former content of component A while in A into a seperate component to end up with a nested component of A and B and then to perform the solid operation and afterwards explode the nested component. This way all instances of the components are affected by the solid operation. However it did only work so far for some of my components because of impractical axis of some of my components.
Thanks Dave your post was very enlightening! The next thing I am going to do after this post (after I have had a look in my fridge) is to install your recommended Trim and Keep extension.
-
That's what I meant. I didn't add the detail of bringing in the cutting component and all.
-
Good luck in the fridge.
FWIW, Jim's Trim and Keep made quick work of the mortises, dadoes and grooves in this model. There's lots of them, too. I'd probably still be drawing this if I'd use the Trim tool from the Solid Tools set. No. I tell a lie. I would have done all those manually in much less time than I'd have spent using the Trim tool. I'm thankful for Jim.
-
Missed that model, Dave. Sweet! I like the drawer fronts. Makes the clear parts look fancier, no matter the grade or species. How do you use that pegboard thingy?
-
Thank you Peter. On the original, the drawer fronts and the tongue and groove panels on the back and sides were painted with blue milk paint which was then oiled to give it a rich deep color.
That "pegboard thing" is called a dead man or a lazy jack. There would be a large peg inserted into a hole to support a wide board or a door on edge clamped in the front vise for planing. It slides on its shoe in the groove.
-
Thanks Dave, Trim and Keepp is working flawless. I was succesfull in trimming all the strut instances against all the hub instances of my geodesic dome model.
-
Good deal.
-
@newnoob said:
Thanks Dave, Trim and Keepp is working flawless. I was succesfull in trimming all the strut instances against all the hub instances of my geodesic dome model.
I am glad you were successful too. FYI Trim and Meep purposefully does not remove the components left around after performing the operation. They are all still available in the Component Browser. Run a Purge Unused operation to clean them up.
-
@jim said:
FYI Trim and Meep purposefully does not remove the components left around after performing the operation. They are all still available in the Component Browser. Run a Purge Unused operation to clean them up.
That's a good point and I should have mentioned it.
Meep
Made me choke on my coffee. -
@jim said:
I am glad you were successful too. FYI Trim and Meep purposefully does not remove the components left around after performing the operation. They are all still available in the Component Browser. Run a Purge Unused operation to clean them up.
I suppose you are the Jim who wrote "Trim and Keep", many thanks for that!
-
-
@newnoob said:
I suppose you are the Jim who wrote "Trim and Keep", many thanks for that!
Aye. You're welcome. Thank Dave - he's the one who conceived it - I just wrote it.
-
Advertisement