SubD examples and models
-
I think you can get away with even fewer polygons in your control-mesh. I had a quick playaround where I stripped away some of the loops:
-
@thomthom said:
I think you can get away with even fewer polygons in your control-mesh. I had a quick playaround where I stripped away some of the loops:
Again, thanks for sharing. And I will look at this closer again. I had tried this but not sure what the heck I did wrong. All part of the learning process.
I am glad that people are so willing to share and will put up with all of these questions from someone like me. I REALLY appreciate it.
-
-
More silly questions:
-
Hi Dave
most of this particular model is done in Basic SketchUp as shown in the added video.
So the lines around the hole (your question 2) were simply moved or drawn with
native SU-tools in this case - there was no magic stick
The mesh change 1B (your question 1) I just did to hit the edges of the octagon-hole
perfectly in order to just get quads.
For lifting the 4 lines I used Vertex Tools. If you hold CTRL, the lifting of the
Vertex Tool gizmo will create a new "tube" section. If you don´t have Vertex Tools,
you can do all this with basic SU-tools as well but it is important to avoid any internal
faces. Also the scaling can be done with basic SU-tools as well. But using Vertex Tools
for scaling, rotating, moving ... is much better in order do get a "clean" Quad mesh...
Also Quadface Tools are important if you want or need to "divide" your model in certain
sections or if you want to add, select or edit loops without doing all that manually...
I am far from understanding all that and am just starting to discover these functions by
testing and playing
-
QFT, Vertex Tools & SubD, proved to be the most enjoyable tools for modeling. Here's a WIP of my earpods..
-
@unknownuser said:
you could wind up with some huge files. Is this normal?
Yep! Basically SKetshup is a "box modeling" program, not a "Subdivision" program!
It's was not provided for that!
We are lucky that works for some little objects, but that will be very difficult for biggest project!
Manage millions of polygons is not its speciality!
-
@pilou said:
@unknownuser said:
you could wind up with some huge files. Is this normal?
Yep! Basically SKetshup is a "box modeling" program, not a "Subdivision" program!
It's was not provided for that!
We are lucky that works for some little objects, but that will be very difficult for biggest project!
Manage millions of polygons is not its speciality!If they're working with render engines and if you have Thea Interactive Rendering capabilities, you'll be able to fire up a render with subdivision without Sketchup Open GL viewport even being aware of it!
Then it will be fast even for millions of polys, if you have enough power in your CPU+GPU combo, it will actually be a zip!
-
Yes thanks to Proxies!
-
@HornOxx Thanks a ton. I see what I did wrong. I thought I had used the Ctrl when using the Gizmo tool but I must not have.
I tried selecting the grids at both end and scaling at the same time but for some reason it would not do it. I was able to do it by scaling one end at a time.
I wish the ConnetEdges tool that is part of the QFT tool would give you a little better control over the division (like being able to split the selected surface evenly) but I also know that you can use the move tool to position the rings/loops so there is more than one way to get the job done. I also like the way you went into wire frame mode and used guide lines to drag the ring/loops. That was pretty neat also.
Ultimately, I would like to be able to put together a beginners guide to quad face modeling.
Here are the sections I would like to see:
-
What is Quad Modeling
-
Why is it necessary/Why would you want to use it
-
Step by step example
-
This would be a step by step guide with pictures that showed each step with an explanation of why you are performing it* I think a written guide might work better than a video but maybe some animated gifs because the newbie needs to understand both how and why you are performing the step* The sample model needs to be comprehensive enough to see all (or at least most) of the features yet not so complicated that the beginner cannot understand what is being done
-
Glossary
-
Poly* Quad* Tri* N-Gon* Other Terms
Just some current thoughts - a long way off though.
-
-
-
Here's a quicky to show how to slice things up with QFT.
-
@ntxdave said:
What are Proxies?
The Proxy in this context is the simple raw geometry.
Also for example Artisan uses this term - also there is a simple raw geometry (the proxy)
which then gets subdivided in a much complexer and biger geometry. The Proxy allways is the
"placeholder"(? don´t know if that word exists in English?) for something modified.
A lot of Render tools replace simple Proxys with most complex replace-geometrys or components.
So you can draw (or use) for example a simple line-box in SU, wich then gets replaces within a renderer by a most complex 3D-tree... -
@cuttingedge said:
QFT, Vertex Tools & SubD, proved to be the most enjoyable tools for modeling. Here's a WIP of my earpods..
Is the colour there from post processing? Or is that actually a SketchUp style?
-
@jql said:
If they're working with render engines and if you have Thea Interactive Rendering capabilities, you'll be able to fire up a render with subdivision without Sketchup Open GL viewport even being aware of it!
Indeed. At the moment I'm moving towards using OpenSubdiv as subdivision engine. It actually have support for fast display of the subdivided mesh for OpenGL and DirectX - however the SU API doesn't provide access to the GL pipeline. Otherwise you'd have it override the normal drawing of the mesh in high-poly while SU itself would only know about the control mesh. dreams
But I got some ideas here ... need to make some experiments.
-
@ntxdave said:
- Poly* Quad* Tri* N-Gon* Other Terms
Have you looked at the links on the SUbD site?
http://evilsoftwareempire.com/subd/quadsCurrently there are four links to external sites that describe the general concept of tris, quads and ngons. Is there information there you feel is missing?
-
@thomthom said:
however the SU API doesn't provide access to the GL pipeline.
Tomasz did it! It needs some heavy hacking, but your colleagues in the core team may help you?
If you do succeed, I'd love to know how
-
@jiminy-billy-bob said:
Tomasz did it!
Yea, I know there are way to get access directly to the SU viewport. But I got another idea that might be less hacking. I'm hesitant to dig too deep into host applications like that as it could easily break. I was thinking more in terms of overlays. Separate transparent window in a separate process (that way if it breaks it shouldn't take down SU with it.)
But yea - BaseCamp hackathon?
-
@jiminy-billy-bob said:
@thomthom said:
however the SU API doesn't provide access to the GL pipeline.
Tomasz did it! It needs some heavy hacking, but your colleagues in the core team may help you?
If you do succeed, I'd love to know how
Damn I love Thea For Sketchup!
-
Is there a tut for terrain and especially road modeling in quads?
I'm struggling to find examples for correct crossings topologies...
Advertisement