Sketchup is Inacurrate???
-
Inaccuracy of SU is between the chair and the computer.
-
@tridem said:
actually there are known issues, eg with follow-me tool, when the geometry is small compared with the measure unit... I cannot say if this could be considered a "inaccurate" behaviour
I would not call that "inaccuracy" but "limitation". There is a limitation with too big sizes (faraway objects from the origin) but then you need to know your (and the tool's) limitations when working, too.
Picasso could draw excellent pieces of art with a single pencil. But he would not start drawing a huge picture on a house wall with a single pencil either.
-
@gilles said:
Inaccuracy of SU is between the chair and the computer.
Sure is. For instance - while AutoCAD is know to be able to handle very small and very large units, that doesn't mean the users draw accurately. I often see problems when I need to work with AutoCAD files - and the problem is not the application, it's the users.
And most of the time when I hear people say SketchUp is not accurate - it's just that they fixated on SketchUp and assumed that it only draw rough sketches.
-
In fact, it would be much harder to program SketchUp not to be accurate. Imagine how hard it would be to code inaccuracies and tolerances so big that they are even noticeable!
A raster based program can be inaccurate. A vector based program is just what it says; mathematically calculated. If it is inaccurate, maths itself is inaccurate.
-
@gaieus said:
In fact, it would be much harder to program SketchUp not to be accurate. Imagine how hard it would be to code inaccuracies and tolerances so big that they are even noticeable!
Kindof like this? http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mOZqRJzE8xg
-
Nice tool!
-
This is what frustrates me when you see comments on the net that Sketchup is inaccurate. Maybe it had a bigger effect in the early days of Sketchup. However, these days a lot of people in the trade know about it.
Oh well I suppose you cannot stop people opening their mouth before their brain is engaged (assuming they have a brain). It really shows that you have to do your own research most of the time.
Walter -
Yes - people are very quick to making assumptions. Allays verify claims. Often it turns out they never even used the software...
...doesn't stop them from "knowing-it-all"... -
Accuracy and precision are related concepts. When you model something with no particular units in mind, and a whole bunch of people say hey it looks just like the real thing--that is accuracy. When they say hey it's exactly the same size as the real thing--that is precision. Both terms are relative, or can have a range of values.
I think folks are interchanging one term for another in their arguments. If you work with Sketchup, mindful of its "limitations", you can achieve your purpose. -
I've seen complaints about models distorted and skewed when imported to Max. These are usually from the 3d snobs using pirated software. I calmly explain to them that if they have a licensed subscription version of max that a sketch up importer is available and works fine. I've never used max personally but i've seen people dragging geometry randomly about, and of course i've received some really horrific auto cad files. It seems to me that autocad makes you sloppy ?
-
Is SU inaccurate. The answer is YES. IT is a digital machine and they all have an native inaccuracy and then quite often some program design "quirks". It is up to the user then to understand and decide if what is provided is adequate for their intended application. If one is really interested in the native accuracy look up IEEE 754 Single Precision 32 bit and you will find numerous papers on the subject. There are pathological cases where large errors can occur.
-
@chedda said:
I've seen complaints about models distorted and skewed when imported to Max. These are usually from the 3d snobs using pirated software. I calmly explain to them that if they have a licensed subscription version of max that a sketch up importer is available and works fine. I've never used max personally but i've seen people dragging geometry randomly about, and of course i've received some really horrific auto cad files. It seems to me that autocad makes you sloppy ?
Probably not AutoCAD. Some people probably feel if it represents the object in print, that's enough. They didn't draw to be accurate to the computer.
One thing about SU--if you are drawing buildings (for which it was designed) it gives you cues that your line work is lined up and connected, in fact you can't really model well if it isn't. On the other hand AutoCAD will let you draw whatever and you might not pick up your tiny mistakes.
You could say it's a matter of precision, not accuracy, that SU has 6 decimal places for inches, and my CAD can go up to 12. SU has 3 decimal places for degrees and my CAD has 5. If you are drawing a survey, SU won't give you the precision expected in a computer file, but I guess it can be said, within its own range of precision, it seems to be accurate.
-
@pbacot said:
that SU has 6 decimal places for inches
The developers has said that SketchUp's internal precision is one thousandth of an inch. What you see in the UI is one thing - when SketchUp does 3D calculation its to 1/1000".
-
I have searched more than once for Google backup for all these number limits thrown around.
Have you ever seen any?
The floating point has a accuracy of 7.+ digits so I don't know where the developers get the 1/ 1000 value and does that not mena it is not a 32 bit application as stated? You will see more digits reported (like the value I listed above form a float 32 online IEEE 754 Single precision 32 bit conversion ) and there was a post not long ago about Google changing the conversion in dae for inch to cm to 2. 53999969330360 which causes then the file to use a more storage and considerable larger file size.I don't think that change was necessary , but again could find zero SU8M2 release notes on that issue.
In fact some processors ( non 64 machines aka my P4 CPU ) will use 64 bits but then gets reduced to 32 bits when the value is stored. -
a couple of decades ago solar energy had a bad reputation in brasil as being inefficient. it turned out it did not work because the people who introduced it to us had no idea as to how to make it work: panels very seldom faced the correct direction and the height relationship among the parts was wrong. as soon as cleverer people started dealing in it solar energy become known for what it is.
could something similar happen at times with sketchup users? I remember hearing a colleague at my university say it was a pity sketchup could not be used to produce precise models...
-
I imagine these naysayers negativity comes from a possible perception that 'free' can never be 'good'. On the other hand I've yet to read a negative SketchUp assessment from a knowledgeable source. I think those are the ONLY sources that we should be listening to, not the, I'm sorry to call them, SketchUp ignorant begrudgers
-
Sure it is : a circle is not a circle, it's a polygon!
But we love it anyway!
-
But when you think about what a 'circle' really is, it can only be a polygon, all be it, in some programs, one with extremely short 'line' segments, a position beside a position, so to speak.
But of course, anyone that knows about CNC work also knows that SU is not the app for this. But I imagine certain commentators have grasped this idiosyncrasy of SU and jumped on the old band wagon
-
sometimes it's innacurrate.. the vast majority of the times-- it's fully accurate.
knowing what the sometimes are and how to avoid them is key.
[for instance-- draw an arc at 90° and try offsetting it]
-
@mike lucey said:
But when you think about what a 'circle' really is, it can only be a polygon, all be it, in some programs, one with extremely short 'line' segments, a position beside a position, so to speak.
But of course, anyone that knows about CNC work also knows that SU is not the app for this. But I imagine certain commentators have grasped this idiosyncrasy of SU and jumped on the old band wagon
I'm not sold on that. I work directly with a contractor with both a CNC and robotic plasma cutter with my sketchup modeling, and we make some pretty complex structural knife plates for wood to wood and wood to concrete joinery. The end result has been pretty cool.
Advertisement