Still looking for a good drafting companion for Sketchup...
-
@honoluludesktop said:
Edson, William is no longer with IMSI. He has moved on to a "greener pasture". I don't know if he reads this forum much.
I am sorry to hear that and hope it does not mean the company is in trouble as DoubleCad seems promising. my emails to them keep returning...
-
Now Doublecad V3pro wit ruby progamming is out
see http://www.doublecad.com/Products/DoubleCADXTPro/tabid/1099/Default.aspx?CID=6063965309
Bep -
Even though I've had an offline conversation with Edson I thought I should respond here too.
I actually do still read things here because even though I may not work in CAD s/w any more I do enjoy using it... SU in particular.
I left IMSI because of a great new offer, not because of anything at IMSI -- they are still making progress as was seen with their DoubleCAD v3 launch.
Their forums, http://forums.doublecad.com, are a great spot to get quick responses -- they monitor them carefully, and take customer feedback very seriously so speak up over there if you have requests and opinions.
- Mac has been an ongoing internal debate, I don't know their plans now.
- IMSI/design does have very good educational pricing for the Pro (and XT is already free).
- I believe the general email is CustomerSupport@ imsidesign.com (or CustomerService@ -- I don't remember which).
- TurboCAD and DoubleCAD are both built from the same code base, but diverge in UI and feature sets with different intended audiences. But for the best answer to that question I would refer you to IMSI at their forums.
Give v3 a try and provide them with a lot of feedback (good, bad, etc) on their forums!
William
-
I wanted to follow up on this thread and say that I ended up actually with DoubleCad XT 3 despite my initial misgivings.
I decided to bite the bullet and buy the training videos for DoubleCad. It turned out to be a solid move. They are easy to follow and well worth $50.
3 pros for DoubleCad:
-free, unless you want the added features. (so I had time to get used to it's "quirks")
-easy integration with Sketchup
-fast with 5-10 meg SKP files(v3 might be better with larger files, haven't tried that yet)1 con:
-not as stable as I would like. I understand software bugs, I've never met a program that didn't crash sometimes. Overall I'd say the bugs are not the end of the world, but take some time to experiment with your workflow before any big projects or you might regret it.
-
If free is your thing:
http://www.3ds.com/products/draftsight/download-draftsight/
was about to try this (thank Mike Lucey for the find) but then Autocad for Mac came out. -
I've dabbled with Draftsight. It works well, but it lacks the features of DoubleCAD and feels a little "lite". However as Draftsight have a Linux version coming soon I think they will win a lot of support.
-
I tried Draftsight a little. I am impressed by some of its interface for a free program, like the layer window (except you can't leave it open). HOWEVER it dogs down my MacBookPro heavily--even the other open apps and the finder. Simply moving a window correctly becomes impossible. I might find it useful to open some DWG and resave. Anyone else try it on a Mac?
I use PowerCADD, but, note, it is expensive and only 2d and only Mac. But it is a good stable production program with some nice tools (if you also buy "WildTools"). Lacks in any groundbreaking development recently (except in some topo tools perhaps). At present I just stay with it as that is what I know best. It could have a copy and paste SU translator if someone at Google (or perhaps a ruby writer) will pick up the ball. The newest version can make vector objects from some pdf files. I guess that could be "ground-breaking" depending on your needs.
-
When you think about it, any good drafting program is a suitable companion to Sketchup as long as it can use the date from it. Just because it can read a skp, is not enough. It must access the data in a meaningful manner.
Someone should write a drafting program that interfaces with the skp database without any translation. The file should be opened in Sketchup, and by the drafting program seamlessly, without additional entities. If there is a weakness in this, it will have to wait on Sketchup to be enhanced.
-
Another option
Turbocad Deluxe V17
(this version has the Design Director included)
Easy to setup and use.
Interface and keystrokes user configurable
Super import/export including
dwg up to 2011
(SU dwg import editable text and dimensions from SU)
Obj
3ds
Import SU
Paper space/model space
xref (limited)Good value and under $70 US if you call.
I have used Tcad for over 10 years as Architect of record for both residential and commercial projects of substantial scope.
Very good for 2d production docs but no BIM (Revit)
option.
If the above is a project requirement then you are out of luck using Tcad or equal.
Well worth a look and a demo is available too.dtr Architect
-
Don't know if you're looking for 3D capabilities in the CAD program or strictly 2D. If the latter, AutoCAD LT just came out with a CLOUD version.
Rick
-
Free version of Draftsight has been released, for both MAC and PC
I think the official release data was 23 Feb 2011. Prior to that it was beta testing for about a year.
Only 2D, but might come in handy for someone.
Regards,
Bob -
You guys need to check out jDraft, a multi-platform Java-based 2D drawing application which is currently in beta. The developer is very responsive, and we've both already been talking about a plugin for SketchUp (Ruby scripting dudes? Can U help? )
-
@bob777 said:
Bottom line I think DraftSight is it.
Do you really think so? From a perspective of being a user of the Macintosh, I find Draftsight's workflow very un-Mac like, throwing my workflow completely off course. Maybe this is okay from a linux and PC perspective, but not from a Mac GUI perspective. Google have managed to code SketchUp correctly for both Mac and PC, so why can't Dassault get this right?
I also found that even on a quite powerful Mac, that DS runs quite slow and is choppy in use. I've binned my copy already.
edit; and Ive just checked the website, the Mac version is still in Beta.
-
going again through this topic I realized something you guys are probably overlooking: why think of a "good drafting companion for Sketchup" if it already has one that costs nothing and comes along with it? I am talking about LayOut.
why do something twice –in 2d and 3d– when you can do it once in 3d and extract the 2d from it in LayOut? I have tried it in a real life job and it works fine, provided you prepare your model for that.
as jean lemire would say, just ideas...
-
@edson said:
why think of a "good drafting companion for Sketchup" if it already has one that costs nothing and comes along with it? I am talking about LayOut.
Edson,
First of all please remember that LayOut isn't free... It's a part of the SU Pro version, but not the free Google SU...
Secondly, I assume you've overlooked the first post...@drfabinex said:
I've trolled the Layout discussion forum and everywhere else I could think of to find a companion program for Sketchup to produce good construction drawings.
Currently I tolerate the limitations of Layout, but I'd prefer something like Viacad, Doublecad or Turbocad. Of the 3 Turbocad is my fav but they're all PAINFULLY slow to navigate models with a high poly count.
-
hi, kim.
thanks for pointing that out to me. however, let me make two additional points here.
- I am not sure what is said on the first post rests on a thorough knowledge of what LayOut can do. there has been dramatic improvements from v2 to v3.
- I can hardly understand why someone who uses Sketchup professionally would not be willing to pay for a pro license. $495 for the license + $95 for updates does not seem too much for an office's budget. besides, none of the posts on this thread asks for a free "good drafting companion to sketchup". so if people are willing to pay for the companion app why not buy sketchup pro and get layout too?
best regards.
-
Comments on Layout must be in comparison to AutoCAD. I mean I can understand frustration with some of the CAD software, but I can't imagine using LayOut instead of my 2d CAD (PowerCADD) with all it's graphic, drafting, and text capabilities.
Alternately it is so easy to import any image from Layout or SU to PowerCADD for final composing and notation.
I understand, of course, that Layout is a as close to SU as one can get in terms of being a companion. I just don't think it compares to all you get on CAD software. Yet--it hasn't been around so long. I have to admit I haven't worked in LO really, I just see what it has and doesn't have.
Draftsight just crawled and crashed on my CoreDuo (Snow Leopard) MBP. Am I missing something?
-
@pbacot said:
Comments on Layout must be in comparison to AutoCAD. I mean I can understand frustration with some of the CAD software, but I can't imagine using LayOut instead of my 2d CAD (PowerCADD) with all it's graphic, drafting, and text capabilities.
Alternately it is so easy to import any image from Layout or SU to PowerCADD for final composing and notation.
I understand, of course, that Layout is a as close to SU as one can get in terms of being a companion. I just don't think it compares to all you get on CAD software. Yet--it hasn't been around so long. I have to admit I haven't worked in LO really, I just see what it has and doesn't have.
Draftsight just crawled and crashed on my CoreDuo (Snow Leopard) MBP. Am I missing something?
peter,
you would be surprised to see what LayOut can do. it is an evolving piece of software so we can expect great advances in the future. nonetheless, many people have switched to the sketchup/layout combo for their documentation and not for just small stuff or for hobby purposes.
-
Hi Edson,
I don't disagree with you - on the contrary...
@edson said:
besides, none of the posts on this thread asks for a free "good drafting companion to sketchup".
I agree, but you wrote...
@edson said:
...if it already has one that costs nothing and comes along with it?
So in order to avoid any misunderstandings, I just wanted to point out that LayOut isn't free, but is a part of the fee you pay for the Pro version...
(I know you can't get a Pro version without LayOut at a smaller fee, but it's still a part of the fee...) -
well, my point was: if you buy sketchup for your work then layout comes to you for free, sort of...
either way, it is a promising app and I hope google keeps developing it. if they do, it may allow us not to keep looking for the drafting companion to sketchup.
Advertisement