Let's build a new 3D software!
-
I think it may be possible the Blender core could accommodate some tweaks to make 3D modeling easier. You can do basic inferencing by locking to an axis and turning on vertex snapping. There's probably preferences that let it get a little looser, but right now it's very harsh, and snaps to everything all the time. I'm sure there's ways to lock to normals and stuff like that, I actually think it's not that out of reach. I just don't have time to tinker, and am so used to churning out geometry quickly in SU.
I think there really is quite a hurdle in bringing people to yet another piece of software. Even the "Super-SU" per Oli's original concept means another thing to learn. I think Box may be on to something - that the next big thing will come out of a different field. Here's hoping...
-
@andybot said:
I think Box may be on to something - that the next big thing will come out of a different field. Here's hoping...
Same here. I don't believe we are looking at 3D software with fresh eyes.
We need something completely new. While I compare my ideology to a mixture of SketchUp and Blender, what I mean is I want the ease of SU with the power of Blender. There are simply some models you can make in Blender that you can not make in SketchUp.
This is not to say the new software should resemble either SU or Blender. I just can't believe the 3D conventions are set in stone, there must be something more fluid and intuitive to come.
-
Modo is the perfect example of such commitment to new conventions.
-
I hate to say it but FormZ 8 looks very good with some of it's new features. Worth looking into if nothing else for ideas.
-
It's all about controlling topology.
There are excellent applications around, maintaining the appropriate control on topology.
Non of them is easy to use. Not a SU like UI, I mean.
Let's face it. The 3d world has it's own rules. It is a virtual reality.
We have to talk using a deferent language.
This becomes a real PITA regarding UserInterface.
A UI is the essence of the code inside an application.
This is the real problem, IMO.
When we are in Pshop, trying for a decent CMYK conversion, we have to understand the language of an offset printer or any other printer. The limitations of the inks.
When we're going for 3d printing, we have to understand how the 3dprinter works.
When we're going for video game assets, once again, we have to understand all about the art of baking nice normal maps. (and much more limitations of the game engines)
When we design for real building, concrete, wood work, etc this we should have in mind.
To create a friendly UI, what does it mean, really?Most people hate the zbrush UI. I faced the same difficulties when I started learning it.
However, start sculpting, try to handle it using a wacom only. You may think otherwise.My english don't help me much, sorry.
-
Ur English is perfect.
-
Hello Michalis
Have you try Verve? It's only 2D but...
-
Maybe Trimble should be looking at Euclideon with a view to incorporating their technology with SketchUp?
"With a claim of “unlimited geometry,” an Australian start-up called Euclideon is getting serious industry and media attention, even though their product is not yet released. Their technology uses point-cloud data rather than polygons and, as a result, they promise digital environments that are 100,000 times more detailed than the current state of the art."
-
This is more impressive!
It's a pity that is used only for wargames or violent things!
-
Some engines that could be used:
@aerilius said:
this is quite innovative, but would need to rethink 3d from scratch, and design the platform from the ground up to be scalable, extendible ...
Sounds more and more like FreeCAD
http://freecadweb.org/It's just that it uses Python instead of Ruby (and I love Ruby so much. But alas... I can live with Python too.)
Another OpenSource project that I think the UI is fantastic, is QCad.
http://qcad.org/
It's extensions use ECMA Javascript. That is ok too.
But currently QCad is 2D only.
(LibreCAD is itself an implementation of Qcad.)ADD this also as an engine that could be used for the "project":
http://archimedescad.github.io/Archimedes/
It is Java based on the Eclipse platform.
This also is only 2D at this time, and very very basic,... but the 2D CAD newbie should not have issues.
-
I think it might be faster to tweak FreeCAD.
It already has a right-click orbit option ("Inventer navigation",) that is assigned to the left mouse button. Add a "SketchUp navigation" that changes it to the middle button.
There already are a whole bunch of Workbenches, including an Architectural workbench. (Workbenches are UI setups that can have there own special UI features like toolbars and genre specific commands.)
Although (so far,) I have not found inferencing, it does have both object snaps, and geometric constraints. One or both can be used.
It has grid and grid snap, which SU does not have.
SO basically a team could setup a FreeCAD workbench that acts similar to SU. (Being careful not to violate their patent on Push-Pull.)
FreeCAD has solid modeling and boolean operations natively.
.. and it is free.
-
Why not try Fusion 360 free for a year for Student & enthousiast ?
Only disavantage you must have Internet Connection!
It has all! Very clear Interface of the 21 Century
Subdivision, Tsplines, Nurbs, Boolean, Sizing, Historic, Physic animation, Render etc...
A very cool monster!
Perfect for a plane not yet for an aircraft carrier ! 
-
yes, fusion looks very interesing! But i think more for product or mechanical design than for archviz. But there are many interesting things that could be very useful in architectural design too. Looks like they had been "inspired" by spaceclaim...
-
Fusion does not look like an engine that can be tweaked, or a custom UI built upon it.
And it is AutoDesk (proprietary.) -
Dimensions can be turned on in the properties panel. Press n with cursor in 3d workspace
Pen tool equivalent is to extrude a vertex.
Hold CTRL and click for the extrusion to follow ur cursor. Or with vert selected hit e then xyz to constrain to that axis
Snapping is the magnet icon at the bottom of the workspace. You can toggle various snapping types.
Blender has also various action centres to perform translations around. Like the 3D cursor, pivot point, origin etc....
It can definitely mimic SU in terms of modeling behaviour it just needs to be activated.
-
This is really interesting discussion here. I am more like a hobbyist in 3d modeling but I still feel that Sketchup has not developed too much over the years. Anyway, I can't really complain because I have always been using the the free version of Sketchup. I would definitely be frustrated if I was a professional and using commercial version.
I have also been experimenting Blender multiple times and it has always been complicated. Anyway, nowadays I am already testing Blender by importing my Sketchup models and trying to find an efficient workflow to bring my models into game engines like Unity3D. For me this is more like learning Blender step by step. Hopefully I can already manage the tool after a couple of years! When experimenting modeling in Blender I have really been missing:
- Tape measure tool for drawing construction lines in order to model efficiently with dimensions
- Proper pen/line tool
- Object snapping like in Sketchup
By the way, has anybody tried Bonzai 3D recently? They are now in the version 3.x. A couple of years ago people seemed to complain that there was just too many bugs and crashes but I would assume that it has improved since then.
Link to Bonzai3d version history:
http://www.formz.com/products/bonzai3d/versionHistory/b3d_History.html -
@miikka1978 said:
By the way, has anybody tried Bonzai 3D recently? They are now in the version 3.x. A couple of years ago people seemed to complain that there was just too many bugs and crashes but I would assume that it has improved since then.
Link to Bonzai3d version history:
http://www.formz.com/products/bonzai3d/versionHistory/b3d_History.htmlI mentioned Form-Z with is just Bonzai 3D's pro version. It's new release seems to be adding tools that users have been requesting. Sure the $1,390 USD price tag is almost 3 times the SU Pro cost but that is quite a bargain for what one gets.
-
Obviously the wrong forum to discuss this. Should be in the Developers Forum.
But still the "Defenders of SketchUp", "Naysayers" and "Suggesters of alternate software" flood the discussion and take it offtrack.
So,.. it may be that SketchUcation is not even the right site to discuss this. -
@dan rathbun said:
Obviously the wrong forum to discuss this. Should be in the Developers Forum.
But still the "Defenders of SketchUp", "Naysayers" and "Suggesters of alternate software" flood the discussion and take it offtrack.
I think many of us are all three
@unknownuser said:
So,.. it may be that SketchUcation is not even the right site to discuss this.
It's an interesting discussion, glad to see it here. Not sure that it's "obviously" in the wrong place.
-
It's fine here....
Advertisement