Joint Push Pull Conflict?
-
Bug splat crash? Have you any of the known bad plugins installed? I've used JPP a bunch recently with no problems.
-
bad plugins... I do have a few but I had been using JPP recently with no issues. The only thing I can remember installing recently was. OpenStudio, DesignSpace, V-Ray 1.6 Height from Datum and Tag from Datum.
-
Vray beta is well know to mess up legit plugins... it awaits a fix, which I understand should be ready [soon]?
BUT meanwhile I recommend that you disable it using the Plugins Manager, and then only temporarily load it when you want to make a render...
It is pointless having memory-hungry renderers etc and other more frequently used modeling tools loading all of the time...
It is Vray that is crashing when its observers go bonkers - NOT JPP, which just does some legit grouping operations which Vray looks at [unnecessarily...] and then gets its knickers in such a twist there's a splat !] -
ok... If I pull outward it works fine. If I push backwards... towards the concave side. it fails. crash no splat.
-
It crashed for me the first time I opened it and before I could do anything to it. The second time I opened it, I was able to start JPP on it and push it inward but after hitting Enter I got a message from Windows indicating the program had stopped and it was searching for a solution. Third time was the charm. I got the attached. This third time I was pushing on a face toward the left end where the curve is tightest. The first time I pushed on a face more toward the middle.
I wonder if there is something corrupted in the model.
-
Thanks Dave... I think something is wrong with the geometry. I'm not getting an issue on other geometry.
I uninstalled V-Ray Tig... no effect. I've run into issues with it and Vali Architect.
-
The problem appears to be in some of your verticals, on several I was able to select parts of the edge and delete them without losing the face. There seems to be soft edges and hard mixed together.
Once I had removed them it worked fine.BTW you still have your profile saying SU8 but the file you put up is SU13
-
yeah I was trying to see if I had updated too far... Thought maybe JPP was updated to work with 13 and didn't work with 8 anymore. The face in the file I upload was actually made from JPP from an earlier face that was 3/4" inwards from this one... I wonder if once faces have been JPP'd if they should not be JPP'd again? does JPP soften some edges?
-
@krisidious said:
yeah I was trying to see if I had updated too far... Thought maybe JPP was updated to work with 13 and didn't work with 8 anymore.
I had a quick look at your model and, as Dave, I found that some edges were overlapping and not aligned. You can see in the wireframe that JPP has got into trouble.
So it may be a source of problem and possibly crashes.Could you try with a Normal Push pull (N) to see if you get a crash too.
And, at least in the intention, JPP should work in SU8 and SU13 (and SU6, SU7).
Fredo
-
Fredo, yes it ended up being stray edges... not a conflict or the plugin itself. thanks for looking.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
Advertisement