Twilight Render for Mac - beta testers wanted
-
@ jeff
I certainly did not have any intention to insult you. I only gave my observation and I am sorry if it offended you.
-
@andybot said:
@sepo said:
Twilight gui looks same on mac...if not broken do not mend it
So you've had a chance to look at the Mac beta? If its the same as the existing Windows GUI - then it sounds like it's more just testing compatibility than any grand sort of re-design. Which makes this whole "I'm a true Mac user" seem rather OT... There's only so many ways to dress up those five buttonsAndybot I am not sure how to read your reply.
I certainly do not think I am true Mac user, I like macs because of build quality. As hardware they are behind pc in general but well built computers. The whole hoo ha mac thing does not impress me.Yes, twi GUI is same on mac side apart that you have additional option to import material libraries directly from GUI. Guys at Twi did great job so far. There is nothing wrong with existing GUI. It is intuitive and easy to get grasp of.
I would agree there I s only so many ways to skin the cat. -
Hey Jeff, I only got in this thread because I was interested in your questioning the logic of having only valid license holders having access to the beta - which in my mind restricts it to a small subset of cross-platform users. I'm still curious about the reasoning and who the target audience is.
However, I found the discussion about GUI on Mac versus PC, bringing in Thea, etc to be tangential, but that just my opinion (And it sounds like there are basically no changes to the existing GUI - which I think btw works very well.) Take offense if you'd like... makes for a more amusing thread.
Sepo - I was just shooting a rhetorical barb at Jeff
-
oh yeah.. I forgot about that part of the thread (licensed users)
I guess they just want to avoid a free for all and think the licensed users (that also own macs) are going to actually care about the testing?? probably a good idea in that regard
I'm not offended by the way. (nor by sepo)
it's all good. -
Haven't read through the entire thread, as it seem to be mostly about personal preferences and personal judgment...
@unknownuser said:
using thea again.. for me to use thea, not only do i have to learn how to use the parameters etc, i basically have to re learn how to use a computer in general..
What kind of nonsense is this...
It's been a long time since I've heard crap like this...!
Please point me in the direction of any render application on the market today, where you don't need to learn some basics about parameters etc...
The parameters used in Thea is identical to parameters used by all other render applications on the market (Vray, Maxwell, Fryrender etc...)
Even with the v1.x Podium you need some basic knowledge if you want your renders to pop...No-one is forcing you to use Twilight or Thea... It's a free world...
If you feel the GUI etc. is so difficult to comprehend, then go somewhere else...
There's a lot of render apps on the market today... Find the one you comprehend the best and use it...
Lots of users have a lot of joy using Thea, why should developers listen to you at all...??@unknownuser said:
so the thea devs are probably sitting around thinking "see, we made this mac port but barely anybody is using it.. therefore, macs are still irrelevant" (or whatever)..
You're SO wrong... This statement couldn't be more wrong...
@unknownuser said:
going into a mac port with the idea "hey, this is a great UI on windows so we'll make the mac version the same..
This statement clearly shows that you understand zip about programming...
If it was so darn easy to port a Windows app to Mac, why don't we see all Windows applications being available for Mac...??
If you even want to take it further and change the GUI so it has a better Mac'ish feel and design, then you're asking for almost the impossible...!
Take Adobe applications, I can't tell the difference between Mac and Win versions, but I don't feel they look, feel or smell very Mac'ish as a Windows app...
You seem completely ignorant to the difficulties developers are facing when developing applications, which are able to run on both Mac and Windows...
There's no such thing as a compiler, which is able to take your source code and port it to Mac...
It simply doesn't exist...! Obviously you know zip about programming...!What I see is a lot of your personal opinions and preferences... In particular about the GUI design as well as the lack of Mac design and feel...
-
@frederik said:
Haven't read through the entire thread, as it seem to be mostly about personal preferences and personal judgment...
it shows.
take bits and pieces of what I say and twist them into your own version.. I don't care.
you're missing the point.I will say this though.. there isn't a single render app out there, that I'm aware of, that was written natively for OS X... and if there was, it wouldn't look like any of the ports.
re: thea.. open it on Mac and do something simple like resizing the window.. what is that all about? you're right, I don't know a whole lot about programming but I do know that resizing a window shouldn't do that.
-
[off:3a7vebqc]Guys, I have been asked several times to moderate (and "police") topics less but this is really going off-topic here.[/off:3a7vebqc]
-
@gaieus said:
[off:17nzejw3]Guys, I have been asked several times to moderate (and "police") topics less but this is really going off-topic here.[/off:17nzejw3]
do what you gotta doโฆ
i'm just waiting for a dev to come in and say 'the app's gui is perfectly fine.. you're just holding it wrong'
now that would be very mac like.. -
Great to see these applications like Twilight coming to the Mac platform. Congratulations.
What with MOI and Rhino coming aswell things are looking good.
Last time i looked the thing infront of me was firstly a computer and the tools i use are primarily applications.
Regards
(A happy Thea on Mac user)
-
Edited:
Perhaps the Thea interface is instructive in what can be done well or not well setting up a Mac version. I've got my opinions, but I'll save those for another thread...
-
[off:1ggpp32l]I find this thread very interesting but not in terms of Mac users getting a great render tool. More so because it highlights that those of us that are loyal OS users are passionate about interface.
If someone asked me to start using the opposite corner of a window to close, minimise or maximise a window I'd beat them to death with their own arm.
I'm assimilated in Windows. It works for me because it's all I know. I like Macs but rarely get to use them. Mostly I'm trying to find the start button. I usually end up saying that they UI and experience is shit. Why? Because I'm too ignorant to learn.
I agree with Jeff's overall sentiment though. If you're gonna drive a nail don't use your nob.[/off:1ggpp32l]
Meanwhile....
I'm really glad to see Mac users get the very best render plugin around. It also integrates with Kerky and Thea which is a big plus. And the support forum is a true lesson in rendering.
I hope the testers are enjoying it and I look forward to seeing some output soon
-
Chill guys!
I'm not experienced enough to really talk about GUI's however I am experienced enough to discuss my opinions based on being a user of various render apps.
IMO the complexed and feature rich an app has the more tricky the UI is going to be, heck look at 3DMax or Blender as an example of complicated UI's.
One cannot really compare Thea to any other render app as it is both biased and unbiased, has relight, Colimo, animation, instancing etc all combined into one app. I have never used or even seen the Mac version of it and cannot tell you if it's the same as the Windows or Linux versions.
I can tell you without giving away the farm that those SU users that are interested in Thea but want to use it through SU like a simplified plug-in need not stress as there are bright things on the horizon.
I do own a Mac but would not dare do any real work on it as it's so unstable and frankly too weak for 3D, not forgetting not really supported by all the apps I use, however if a gun was put to my temple and had to use it I'd like the UI of the apps to be exactly like my PC version, that way support does not need to be tailored to platform or tutorials to be made separately to cover different OS's etc.
Just a thought
-
@solo said:
Chill guys!
I do own a Mac but would not dare do any real work on it as it's so unstable and frankly too weak for 3D, not forgetting not really supported by all the apps I use, however if a gun was put to my temple and had to use it I'd like the UI of the apps to be exactly like my PC version, that way support does not need to be tailored to platform or tutorials to be made separately to cover different OS's etc.
Just a thought
exactly my point
-
@sepo said:
@solo said:
Chill guys!
I do own a Mac but would not dare do any real work on it as it's so unstable and frankly too weak for 3D, not forgetting not really supported by all the apps I use, however if a gun was put to my temple and had to use it I'd like the UI of the apps to be exactly like my PC version, that way support does not need to be tailored to platform or tutorials to be made separately to cover different OS's etc.
Just a thought
exactly my point
right.. and in a round about way, it's my point too..
@ pete.. i understand you prefer the way things work on your pc as opposed to your mac.. likewise, the opposite occurs and some people prefer the way macs work..so imagine if many of the apps you want to use on your pc looked like mac apps.. and people told you that it needs to be like that because the mac version looks that way etc.. you'd be bummed.. you probably wouldn't be using many apps that follow this train of thought..
well, if you're a mac user, that's how it is a lot of the times.. and when there's an opportunity to shout out 'i don't want the windows version!!" ..you'll more likely than not -- say so.
-
I gave you an example of VectorWorks.... The reason why I am pushing this is simple. A lot of studios have mixture of computers macs and pc.... it just make sense.
-
@sepo said:
I gave you an example of VectorWorks.... The reason why I am pushing this is simple. A lot of studios have mixture of computers macs and pc.... it just make sense.
Agreed! and like I mentioned, no need for customized tutorials is they are the same.
-
i guess we'll just wait and see what happens with rhino..
they're actively developing one app for two platforms which will share the same core yet have different user interfaces.. (and most of what i'm saying in this thread corresponds to the way mcneel is going about it.. and that i wish more devs would take this approach)..sepo, you say autocad bombed on mac.. maybe you're right.. you probably are right.. i never used it so i can't agree or defend..
i don't think it's an impossible task to pull off though.. hopefully mcneel gets it right.[fwiw, rhino is already super powerful and stable on mac.. i've already done a few projects that i couldn't of pulled off without rhino (well, not with the same ease etc.).. they could basically clean it up (get rid of duplicate commands and/or other glitches) and release it now and it would suit a lot of people just fine.. but once they get the plugins hooked up and polish up the UI, i think it's going to be amazing on mac.. fingers crossed
]
[Edit] i guess i should amend my 'super stable' commentโฆ most of the time, it's super stable.. they put out a new beta every week or three.. and on occasion, one of those versions may go berserkโฆ but when you get a smooth version, the app is as stable as one could hope forโฆ i can use it for 3 days straight on a single launch.. unheard of in sketchup world
-
@sepo said:
I gave you an example of VectorWorks.... The reason why I am pushing this is simple. A lot of studios have mixture of computers macs and pc.... it just make sense.
ok, so i just looked at some vectorworks screenshots from macs and windowsโฆ and have concluded that if you're using vectorworks as an example to counter what i'm saying then i'm definitely not properly communicating my thoughts..
here's vectorworks on mac:
here's vectorworks on pc:
here's thea on mac:
thea on mac looks like vectorworks on pcโฆ it has all those weird panels with Xs in there.. everything is stuck together.. moving things around is awkward.. what are those strange tabs? what happens when i push one?.. etc..
vectorworks on mac looks like a mac app.. i could open that app for the first time and all the UI elements are already ingrained in my head.. i don't stop and wonder 'what happens if i click on this strange button' etc.. i already learned that stuff when i learned how to use my computer in general..
vectorworks on mac looks nice and usableโฆ but if it looked and acted like the pc version, in the same way thea looks like pc on mac, i'd be saying the same thing about vectorworks as i'm saying in this threadโฆ
but you are saying vectorworks on these two platforms match each otherโฆ i'm saying they most certainly don't.. so it's somewhere inside of that realm where our disagreement is taking place..
-
We were well aware of many mac users that already own a license for Twilight Render. They already used Twilight, and therefore do not have a lot of questions about how it works. They can easily take a scene they already prepared in Windows, open it in Twilight on their Mac, and render. It is therefore, both fair and quite practical that we should seek licensed users of Twilight to beta test.
We are not trying to exclude anyone, and hope that no offense was given. We do believe that Twilight Render Mac lovers will give us their honest opinion.
We are sorry if it offends you, but we are also confident that we will not be creating great UI changes just for Mac, as development and technical support is more efficient when everyone is on the same page... and UI.
Twilight Render is a fully integrated plugin for rendering within SketchUp, it is not an independent rendering studio.
-
In windows Vectorworks screen shot you are showing docked pallets... If you undock them they look the same as on mac. Granted there are no coloured minimise, close and expand.
And x is no different to x on mac....
More importantly the icons are same one does not need to learn new software....
Jeff let us agree to disagree.... If you were not over the pond I would have asked you to meet up for pint.
Advertisement