[Plugin] SolidSolver

TIG

Here is v1.1 http://forums.sketchucation.com/viewtopic.php?p=359994#p359994
Now if it contains nested groups/instances you are told, and given the option to explode these - remember that it will never be considered to be a 'solid' otherwise: any nested groups/instances within the exploded ones are exploded too...

TIG

Here's v1.2 http://forums.sketchucation.com/viewtopic.php?p=359994#p359994
It now spots if problems arise from nested groups/instances, shared-edges or geometry that can never form a 'solid' - no matter what you try to do to it !
The closing dialogs now explain what's what... as appropriate...
So... it's best to use this tool on a group you think is nearly [or could easily become] a 'solid'...
You're wasting your time using it on a poorly made mess because it won't be 'solvable'...

TIG

Here's v1.3 http://forums.sketchucation.com/viewtopic.php?p=359994#p359994
It now merges any split colinear edges into one continuous edge.

pbacot

Thanks Again TIG.

Now that you mention it, is there any merit in combining two coplanar faces (remove edge) where the material is the same. This is something I have to fix occasionally when joining solids. Usually it heals itself.

No wait. Do that and you'll soon get the opposite request.

Peter

TIG

It [already] removes coplanar edges if the two faces have the same material/back_material.
It now merges split colinear edges into a single edge

Pout

Hey Tig,

I get this error when i try to use it on attached model
Error: #<NameError: undefined local variable or method entities' for TIG:Module> C:/Program Files (x86)/Google/Google SketchUp 8/Plugins/TIG-solidsolver.rb:294:in solidsolver_heal_small'
...

example.skp

TIG

Pout

Thanks for the feedback - a stupid typo!
I'll fix it asap.
As for your SKP... it can't be made a 'Solid'. There are reversed faces, hidden edges, many multi-vertex straight edges, coplanar/unfaced edges, tiny edges, clear large gaps and holes etc... that all need 'fixing' - best to at least try - the tool is intended to fix issues with groups you think ought to be solid but aren't - rather than make a solid out of a collection of mismatched geometry that clearly is nothing like a solid to start with and which might never achieve solidity, no matter what is tried in code - although some manual redrawing it editing could nudge it in the right direction...
So do some tidying up [perhaps using SolidInspector after an initial attempt to see where the problems are - e.g. you have many 'coincident faces' - try intersecting the geometry with itself or group/explode/regroup] - it tries to fix hundreds of issues and fails - it can become a solid.

TIG

Here's v1.4 http://forums.sketchucation.com/viewtopic.php?p=359994#p359994
A daft typo in the heal small faces/holes code has been fixed.

rachmatrf

Thank you TIG. You Rock!

ken

TIG

Found an interesting error. If I use this program to fix a non solid, and do nothing else except go to the file save option to save the file. Before the file is saved, the solid reverts back to the non solid status. If I do something other than go to save, like draw a line the file will save without reverting to the non solid.

TIG

Weird... I'll try to reproduce it...

Anton_S

Thanks, TIG!
SolidSolver is incredibly easy to use. Just go through a couple of steps and ur model is a solid! Although, it won't completely solve shapes that have edge with 3+ faces, but I understand it's complex.

jgb

TIG; Just curious....

Any reason SS does not work on components, but only on groups?

Since almost all my drawings are made of solid comps, I only use groups to keep stuff together, or for layering options. When SS says "Select a group..." when I select a comp, I have to edit the comp, select all, and group it to work, then explode the group. A bit of a pain.

Otherwise it works reasonably well on SU 8-Free. I generally like to cleanup my solids manually, after SI reports problems. SS tends to clobber very complex solids, which I generated in a quick but sloppy manner, so the fixing after SS may take longer than doing the fix manually in the first place.

Mind you, SS is far more adept at fixing some real toughies, such as co-linear lines, and co-resident faces. I had one "celebrated" comp that had 7 (count-em) 7 co-resident faces in 3 places. I went nuts fixing one of the faces, then sent SS after the others. I only had to redraw 2 lines to fix that after.

TIG

It could readily deal with component instances too - it's just easy to write for a group...

TIG

Here's v1.5 http://sketchucation.com/forums/viewtopic.php?p=359994#p359994
it now works on groups AND component instances; makes the result unique, if needs be.

Anton_S

jgb

@tig said:

Here's v1.5 http://sketchucation.com/forums/viewtopic.php?p=359994#p359994
it now works on groups AND component instances; makes the result unique, if needs be.

Thanks a bunch. I'll check it on Sunday.

smicha

Thank you TIG. Great work as always.

jgb

TIG;
Seems to work fine with comps now. Thanks for the response.

Bertier

@pout said:

Hey Tig, ...
Hey Pout good to see you there !
Sorry not to see you in Boulder !