Most impressive SketchUp modelling

Dave R

I don't have any problem with a critique. I think it's a good thing if it is constructive. Vague comments like "not... so impressive" don't qualify as constructive criticism and comments like this aren't useful in any way in a thread like this with work from so many different people.

Rich O Brien

It's a subjective topic. I find architecture, rendered or not, impressive as I'm not in that field. There's one particular member, tadema I think, has great models showing English cottages. Dave's furniture too is always something I enjoy viewing.

There's also stuff that I roll my eyes at that others get in a tizzy about. I choose not to comment unless asked for crits.

But what I like most is members solutions to tricky shapes. Jeff Hammond's skatepark stuff where Elisei showed such a clever solution that continued to get refined just blew me away. None of this stuff is here but it's the things I bookmark as pure modelling.

If you wanna see what I call genius at work, watch Kito Kraupp on YouTube. That's impressive to me. Wish my brain work like that!

CoreMaster110

I dont say that some of the models are not impressive because they are simple nor am I trying to say that they are bad, but what im trying to say is that you could find thousands of models from warehouse that are more impressive then some of the models here.
If these models can't impress me than how can they impress people who use 3ds, maya etc???

Rich O Brien

@CM
They're not solely to impress you I suppose. But have you offered your criticism in the original thread? A model/artist/hobbyist can improve through good critique.

Imagine if I said that your tanks look crap. And left it at that. Wouldn't you like to know why I said they were crap. Or would you shrug your shoulders and move on?

Personally I'd like criticism. It makes you strain your abilities.

But your entitled to come on this thread and state your opinion and leave it at that. It makes 'no' difference to this threads content or purpose at the end of the day. All it does is drift away from the OP topic.

@modelhead
So true. SU is turning into the Swiss Army Knife of the 3G world.

Dave R

@unknownuser said:

If these models can't impress me than how can they impress people who use 3ds, maya etc???

Wow! I didn't know you were the final authority on what impresses people who use 3ds and Maya.

Why would someone like me care about impressing those people? I don't really do anything with the intention of impressing anyone. If it does, that's great.

@Rich, thank you very much for the nice words.

Pixero

@dave r said:

Why would someone like me care about impressing those people? I don't really do anything with the intention of impressing anyone. If it does, that's great.

From my initial post:
A collection of the best of the best that would impress most on people that are not aware of SketchUps capabilities.
So he does have a point. This thread was created to gather some great examples of what SU can do so that I/you can point people complaining about SU beeing a "toy software" here and show "the best of the best".
Enough complaining, keep posting, but only the best...

Stinkie

Okay.

How about this one by Remus (the render is Sepo's)?

Stinkie

Wow, wow, wow. I may not necessarely agree with CoreMaster, but 'violent', 'clear intention to be destructive'? Let's not overreact here. This is a forum, there's bound to be disagreement.

Pixero

@coremaster110 said:

... what im trying to say is that you could find thousands of models from warehouse that are more impressive then some of the models here.

Instead of arguing if posted images are good enough, please post one or two of those warehouse model images YOU are impressed by.
To all, now try to get this thread back on track.

CoreMaster110

Ok whatever I lost. I dont want to argue anymore. and I'll STFU!

@simon le bon
why did u but these pictures of my models here??? these were not meant to be impressive... and they are for a game.

Rich O Brien

There are 'no' losers in an honest debate. I think your comment was taken personally because we all know the personality behind each 'impressive' submission. And for some it's personality that is sometimes more impressive.

Your comment was correct just not in the right context at the right moment unfortunately.

numbthumb

First that "to plugin or not to plugin" thing, then this debate which is leading nowhere and is dangerously close to insulting IMHO... And now it would be the right time to chill out and to get back on track. It´s spoiling all the fun of enjoying some great work.
Not to mention it´s Saturday. Hope you all have a great weekend!

Marian

Getting back on track, here are the models of COSEDIMARCO.
He's a member here though he hasn't been active in a long time.
http://cosedimarco.deviantart.com/gallery/
http://sketchup.google.com/3dwarehouse/search?uq=1647755737780017857929040&scoring=m

simon le bon

@unknownuser said:

I dont want to be rude but some of these works are not... so impressive tho im not going to point out the ones that I have in my mind.

I wasn't only looking the render itself but also the model.
As the name of this topic is "MOST impressive sketchup modelling" then I realy hope to see MOST impressive modelling.

I dont say that some of the models are not impressive because they are simple nor am I trying to say that they are bad, but what im trying to say is that you could find thousands of models from warehouse that are more impressive then some of the models here.
If these models can't impress me than how can they impress people who use 3ds, maya etc???

Coremaster models: -> -> pictures removed(by myself)

@stinkie
my words are rude yes. But please read under the lines and look how Dave had been touched.... Despite there where no personal attack.

*s

PS: @pixero +1: that's what I was meaning

simon le bon

Sorry Pixero,
I come after the war and I have some things to say.

First that I reprobate firmly the violent approach of CoreMaster110. What he had done here is not constructive criticism but he had come with the clear intention to be destructive. Can he shows us something of his job so impressive that we are going to acclaim?

Secondly we know that a very pure and may be simple shape can be very hard to achieve. May be very much more than a vast complex model only made with thousands of pushpull acts. So before make a quick judge, first try to imitate

Thirdly, men that can and must be criticized are those who had posted the works which had hold their admiration. In any cases the authors who do their job with all their heart, skill, talent and generosity are to be not denied ..

As I have chosen to post a lot of the last reports, CoreMaster110 if you have something to add come one, come to me by PM and stop bumping this nice thread.

simon.