Cutting along one side?
-
What is it you want to keep and what is doing the cutting?
It only took a few seconds to create solids from your shapes.
-
I want to keep just the outside mesh. How did you do this?
-
So you want the large "wave" surface with bumps? Or with recesses?
I'll make a list of what I did to make the solids.
-
The bumps, only. Basically everything you can see on the outside of the object.
-
To make the components solid, I deleted the inner components for the "bumps" and also removed the internal face. For the larger component I just added end faces to it and pulled the bottom face down temporarily to get rid of the sharp edge at the bottom.
After that you should be able to use Solid tools to trim the bumps with the large component. You'll also need to deal with the bumps that touch each other, too.
I don't know what you are expecting at the lowest bump so I didn't push the bottom face back up flush. You'll notice the completed shape is also a solid group.
-
Nice...
@dave r said:
To make the components solid, I deleted the inner components for the "bumps" and also removed the internal face. For the larger component I just added end faces to it and pulled the bottom face down temporarily to get rid of the sharp edge at the bottom.
But, how did you delete the inner components of the bumps? That is what I am looking to find out!
-
Your original "bump" components contain two components or groups (I can't remember which they were) which I exploded. There was an internal face down the center of the bump which I deleted. this made the bump components solid. I made the large shape solid by putting faces on the ends. Then I used the large shape to Trim the bumps. This got rid of the inside part of the bumps for me.
After that I exploded the bumps one at a time, cut the resulting geometry, opened the large component and used Edit>Paste in Place and then deleted the unneeded internal faces under the bumps. In order to get at those internal faces I hid one end face of the large component. I watched Entity Info to make sure that large component remained "solid" throughout the process, which it did.
-
I tried to do the same thing, using intersect-with-context, but I was unable to intersect some of the areas. Not sure why.
"Then I used the large shape to Trim the bumps."
?
-
Before you used Intersect, did you place the bump geometry in the same context as the large shape?
I used the Trim tool from the Solid Tools set.
It seems to me that you might benefit from starting with some much simpler geometry to learn how to do all this stuff.
-
I exploded the whole thing. It just got real bad. Will try again.
-
Did I say to explode the whole thing?
I exploded the bumps one at a time to make sure I didn't have an issues with lots of geometry.
As I said, I think you try a similar but much simpler version first to learn how to do it.
-
I think my biggest issue was with removing the lines. I've been doing Sketchup stuff for a while now, on and off.. sometimes the more complex geometry gets annoying to work with. Should have used Weld.
Anyway, all this is manual. It would be nice to just be able to remove everything "inside" the object with some plugin.
-
I have to say. I don't get it. I didn't find the inside faces but even so. It was pretty quick to make solids and use solid tools to cut chunks out of the bumps where the intersected the wave. I didn't do all of them... maybe some were more tricky according to the angle. It was pretty straightforward. don't know what weld would do here.
But I think when you do more of this organic work, you might look at other programs too.
That WOULD be great plugin if possible.
-
Dave is patiently trying to show you how to fix the issues with your model and then get the result you want. He is teaching you about smart modelling and how to model cleanly. Without neat clean models plugins won't work, you'll spend more time trying to fix your model so you can use the magic plugin. So understanding the basics is key here. Listen to Dave, he knows what he is doing.
It's 6am and I'm off to the dentist so forgive the voice, but this shows you the basic steps. Even if they aren't solids it should be as straight forward as shown here.
Take note, at the section where I mention everything is a solid, at that point you could use "SolidTools" which I don't have, to simply subtract the large shape from the small shapes therefore removing the interior bits as you want.
[screenr:1m5mqpws]hl97[/screenr:1m5mqpws] -
Thanks for the video.
Tried it again.
First fan/bump: OK.
Second fan/bump: Intersection doesn't work for some reason. I checked the edges... they line up. Tried all 3 intersection options as well as just exploding the entire geometry.
-
As dave said above, you need to practice on some easy shapes so you understand what you are doing. I can see without even looking closely that you have more than one group in your Bump. No wonder it isn't solid, and it can't intersect in one go because it's in a different context. Try intersecting some spheres or cubes with a simple face so you can understand the construction of the geometry properly.
You can see in your image that the bottom section has intersected, the yellow highlighted hard line. The red circle and the cross are showing the different contexts.
-
Box is correct. How many times do you need to be told? Your bump component needs to be a single thing and not a nested component.
Leave this model alone until you sort out your process on something with much simpler geometry.
-
What?
No, I'm not saying that. The highlighted area should be two parts, but it didn't slice through. The lines are there, but it's still two separate areas!!!
It doesn't matter if it's a solid or not. It still doesn't slice through.
I've attached a simplified example.
If I do intersect-with-model on the bump that hasn't been cut out (the same one in the picture), it won't split.
Edit: I noticed that after splitting, there was a single polygon where the outline formed along the surface of the main object that was not cut . When I drew a line cutting it (the polygon), the bump shape separated immediately in two. I don't know why Dave didn't experience this:
Advertisement