sketchucation logo sketchucation
    • Login
    ℹ️ Licensed Extensions | FredoBatch, ElevationProfile, FredoSketch, LayOps, MatSim and Pic2Shape will require license from Sept 1st More Info

    Do humans have a free will?

    Scheduled Pinned Locked Moved Corner Bar
    189 Posts 24 Posters 3.5k Views 24 Watching
    Loading More Posts
    • Oldest to Newest
    • Newest to Oldest
    • Most Votes
    Reply
    • Reply as topic
    Log in to reply
    This topic has been deleted. Only users with topic management privileges can see it.
    • plot-parisP Offline
      plot-paris
      last edited by

      thats a great anecdote, Jackson. I have to say I feel a bit sorry for your poor group leader (I was one of these nasty, questioning children too 👿 )

      @jackson said:

      @solo said:

      "Without religion, you would have good people doing good things and evil people doing evil things. But for good people to do evil things, that takes religion."- Steven Weinberg

      Oh, I like that line. of course he does not talk about religion converting people without hope, people with no goal in mind who do bad things, to find a new purpose in their lives and help others. but nevertheless, a amusingly sarcastic remark!

      to come back to free will:

      if we look at an animal that is very simple in it's actions - a crocodile for example. a scientist will have no problem to predict what the crocodile is going to do. if he stirs the water, it will come to him. if he moves violently, it will bite. if he doesn't move at all, it will go away.
      so from our point of view we can't really talk of a free will, because we know what it is going to do.

      but perhaps the crocodile itself is absolutely convinced, that it decided to approach that noise in the water and bite the poor creature. it is not aware of the fact, that this action was absolutely predictable to other, more intelligent beings.

      therefore, if a being, far more intelligent than us humans, is able to predict our actions with as much certainty as we can do with the crocodile, this observer may not grant humans a free will.

      to us that is utterly unimportant, because we live under the believe, that our actions are results of our own decisions - free will. the same may be true for the crocodile - it feels absolutely free in it's decisions.
      it is all a matter of your point of view.

      and that is why I think, we are free enough in our decisions.

      1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
      • C Offline
        cornel
        last edited by

        Alan,
        God, using different writers, inspired them (even dictated them) His Word to have a precise and complete communication with us – The Scriptures).
        It wasn’t a coincidence that the Pope, like Athanasius of Alexandria and others decided the same components (books) of the Bible – God inspired them, also!

        Mike,
        It’s difficult to understand the Bible language, because many terms ar loaded with additional significance. You must read the entire Book, at least one time!
        If not, you will be in a ‘dangerous’ position like David_H: hard to comprehend or solve “why is Philemon part of the Bible?”.

        *“Oy Vey!”,*David_H,
        I read inclusive that ‘pretense Bible’: “the Book Of Mormon”…

        Cornel

        1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
        • Alan FraserA Offline
          Alan Fraser
          last edited by

          Whether we truly have free will or not is probably less important than if we perceive that we do.

          It's a little like the nature of matter. That desk in front of you is actually made up of particles so insubstantial compared to the emptiness surrounding them that there is practically nothing there. Yet you have no choice but to interact with it as if it was a solid object. Similarly, there has to be a concept of free will, because without it we have no concept of good and bad choices, no virtue, no evil, no crime....just predetermined response.

          3D Figures
          Were you required to walk 500 miles? Were you advised to walk 500 more?
          You could be entitled to compensation. Call the Pro Claimers now!

          1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
          • C Offline
            chango70
            last edited by

            @alan fraser said:

            Whether we truly have free will or not is probably less important than if we perceive that we do.

            It's a little like the nature of matter. That desk in front of you is actually made up of particles so insubstantial compared to the emptiness surrounding them that there is practically nothing there. Yet you have no choice but to interact with it as if it was a solid object. Similarly, there has to be a concept of free will, because without it we have no concept of good and bad choices, no virtue, no evil, no crime....just predetermined response.

            Without freewill actions will still have inderminant out come. At least thats what Chaos theory whould tell us.

            1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
            • plot-parisP Offline
              plot-paris
              last edited by

              @chango70 said:

              So NO we don't have 'free will' in a absolute sence, but we do have it in a limited sense.

              nicely said, chango.
              that means, we asume to have a free will as long as we are not able to look behind our own decisions. but we don't need to be afraid, because we will never be able to do that. our mind is just not able to go beyond it's own limits.

              so, as you said, the definition of a 'free will' is relative. so I think it is save to say:

              In a human scale, we have a free will

              1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
              • C Offline
                cornel
                last edited by

                “…our own decisions…”?!

                “But now, O LORD, you are our Father; we are the clay, and you are our potter; we are all the work of your hand.”
                (Isaiah 64:8)
                "[i]human scale" [/i]!!? 😕
                “O LORD, what is man that you regard him, or the son of man that you think of him?”
                (Psalms 144:3)

                The enigma of ‘free willing’ is deeper than present discussions!
                Voila a more realistic starting point:
                “For the creation was subjected to futility, not willingly, but because of him who subjected it, in hope that the creation itself will be set free from its bondage to corruption and obtain the freedom of the glory of the children of God.” (Romans 8:20-21)

                Cornel

                1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                • C Offline
                  cornel
                  last edited by

                  Solo wrote:,
                  “I doubt Cornel believes in evolution.”

                  I believe in devolution.

                  Jackson,
                  No one will “go to hell for eternity” for sins, because Jesus Christ paid for them!
                  Since you are confused about the “way of salvation”, you cannot comprehend the status of babies.

                  Cornel

                  1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                  • Alan FraserA Offline
                    Alan Fraser
                    last edited by

                    Slightly OT again. Regarding the question of infant mortality, this makes interesting reading.
                    http://politicsplusstuff.blogspot.com/2005/12/roman-catholic-church-reconsiders.html

                    The RC church only recently "informally" changed its mind about the destination of unbaptised infants. Previously, they did indeed go to Purgatory. So now it's all right...it's official...they only go to Limbo. The problem is that organised religion is doing this all the time....with or without God's permission. Taking a fixed position on this issue, like anything else, makes as much sense as taking an eternal, unmoving position on fashion.

                    3D Figures
                    Were you required to walk 500 miles? Were you advised to walk 500 more?
                    You could be entitled to compensation. Call the Pro Claimers now!

                    1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                    • soloS Offline
                      solo
                      last edited by

                      Amazing how the bible can be twisted to support your convenience. I bet Cornel can even find a passage that have nothing to do with squat that will even support the Iraq war.

                      http://www.solos-art.com

                      If you see a toilet in your dreams do not use it.

                      1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                      • C Offline
                        chango70
                        last edited by

                        @solo said:

                        Amazing how the bible can be twisted to support your convenience. I bet Cornel can even find a passage that have nothing to do with squat that will even support the Iraq war.

                        I am pretty sure that's happened already 😕 . It's pretty scary.

                        1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                        • CraigDC Offline
                          CraigD
                          last edited by

                          @unknownuser said:

                          CraigD,
                          re. your "Humans DO have free will!!"

                          There are a few conditions…

                          See an example!:
                          ”…and you will know the truth, and the truth will set you free[.” (John 8:32)

                          Cornel

                          You are obviously not married... 😉 HAHAHA

                          Google SketchUp

                          1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                          • C Offline
                            cornel
                            last edited by

                            Solo & Chongo...,
                            If you already read the Book of Daniel, you don’t have to wait for me …!
                            (re. Iraq)

                            Cornel
                            P.S.:
                            Versions of Proverbs 19:13, for CraigD:
                            “…a quarrelsome wife is as annoying as constant dripping.”
                            “…a wife’s quarreling is a continual dripping of rain.”
                            “…the contentions of a wife are a constant dripping.”

                            1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                            • E Offline
                              ehaflett
                              last edited by

                              Great thread! I'm a bit late to it so forgive me. chongo70 I'm really digging your comments, great approach.

                              I'd like to add that from my atheist perspective the idea of free will is a purely religious construct, meaning that it can only be discussed within the framework of some religion. Without that it's quite absurd because it requires me to imagine someone in my head other than me. My actions are determined by the way my thoughts developed as I aged and how they were formed by my parents, peers, and environment. There is no entity (God) upon which to pin that developmental influence. That being said, is it fair to say that atheists have free will and religious people do not on the basis that their actions are either preprogrammed by or at least influenced by the word (will) of their God?

                              1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                              • C Offline
                                chango70
                                last edited by

                                @unknownuser said:

                                Solo & Chongo...,
                                If you already read the Book of Daniel, you don’t have to wait for me …!
                                (re. Iraq)

                                Cornel
                                P.S.:
                                Versions of Proverbs 19:13, for CraigD:
                                “…a quarrelsome wife is as annoying as constant dripping.”
                                “…a wife’s quarreling is a continual dripping of rain.”
                                “…the contentions of a wife are a constant dripping.”

                                Cornel

                                Can you quote the entire Old & New Testament back to back? Am I supposed to be impressed by that?

                                1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                • soloS Offline
                                  solo
                                  last edited by

                                  Eric you hit the nail on the head, Like you, I too am athiest and liberated from a scripted existence that most 'practicing' religious folk are restricted to.
                                  I make choices based on my values and morals and I accept the consequences of those decisions, this gives me the conclusion that I have free will. Unlike Cornel for instance, who really does not have free will as he is trapped to the regiment of his convictions, all decisions need to be qualified by his book of quotes and parables, and second guessing based on an eternity of harps and hymns or sulfur and brimstone.

                                  http://www.solos-art.com

                                  If you see a toilet in your dreams do not use it.

                                  1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                  • C Offline
                                    cornel
                                    last edited by

                                    Eric & Pete,
                                    (Am I ‘crazy’…?!)

                                    If you are atheists, you cannot explain entire “spirit” and part of the “soul”
                                    but you are ‘proud’ about your freedom...?!!

                                    Paradoxically…: 🤣
                                    Cornel

                                    P.S.:
                                    "The natural person () does not accept the things of the Spirit of God, for they are folly to him, and he is not able to understand them because they are spiritually discerned*." (1 Corinthians 2:14)
                                    (* - like an atheist...)

                                    1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                    • E Offline
                                      ehaflett
                                      last edited by

                                      @unknownuser said:

                                      P.S.:
                                      "The natural person () does not accept the things of the Spirit of God, for they are folly to him, and he is not able to understand them because they are spiritually discerned*." (1 Corinthians 2:14)
                                      (* - like an atheist...)

                                      Thanks Cornel, I coundn't have said it better myself. Funny thing about this quote is that religious people read it and feel sorry for atheists and atheists don't read it. Does 'Natural' maan 'atheist'? Does this mean spiritual/religious people are un-natural?

                                      1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                      • Mike LuceyM Offline
                                        Mike Lucey
                                        last edited by

                                        Excellently put Tomasz, You have said a lot in a few shorts sentences.

                                        Mike

                                        Support us so we can support you! Upgrade to Premium Membership!

                                        1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                        • T Offline
                                          tomasz
                                          last edited by

                                          Hi, thanks Plot for bringing in a new interesting thread. I intend to go back to the old one as well.

                                          I am sure we have free will. Without it we couldn't take responsibility for our actions.
                                          If we won't exercise this gift, we will be like an anonymous, colourless mass.

                                          As already pointed out, very often we are being pushed to do something, very often our emotions win and we do what in fairness we don't want to.

                                          There are people who doesn't care and do what they were told to without a trace of reflection.
                                          On the other hand, there are people with very well formed minds (souls), being able to exercise their gift.

                                          Tomasz

                                          Author of [Thea Render for SketchUp](http://www.thearender.com/sketchup)

                                          1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                          • soloS Offline
                                            solo
                                            last edited by

                                            Cornel wrote:

                                            @unknownuser said:

                                            If you are atheists, you cannot explain entire “spirit” and part of the “soul”
                                            but you are ‘proud’ about your freedom...?!!

                                            Um, Cornel focus for a second, you the one that insists on mentioning souls and spirits, let me try again .... I am athiest and I have spirits in a pub and soles on my shoes. I do not believe in ghosts holy or not, heaven nor hell. I do believe jesus existed, but not as the son of God born to a virgin but rather a very socially liberal dude with a magnetic personallity and a posse.

                                            http://www.solos-art.com

                                            If you see a toilet in your dreams do not use it.

                                            1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                            • 1
                                            • 2
                                            • 3
                                            • 4
                                            • 5
                                            • 6
                                            • 9
                                            • 10
                                            • 4 / 10
                                            • First post
                                              Last post
                                            Buy SketchPlus
                                            Buy SUbD
                                            Buy WrapR
                                            Buy eBook
                                            Buy Modelur
                                            Buy Vertex Tools
                                            Buy SketchCuisine
                                            Buy FormFonts

                                            Advertisement