[Plugin] Solids Trim and Keep (Pro Only)

Dave R

I believe Bool Tools will work on the free version of SketchUp but I understand if you need to have some paying clients to afford to buy it.

utiler

Well done, Jim! I would hope this is sorted in future versions of SU...

bmike

Nice... will give it a go!

irwanwr

is this OSCoolean plugin have any similarity with this Solids Trim and Keep plugin?

Dave R

I think it is similar to the Solid Tools. You should give it a try.

bmike

Very nice!
Been looking for this for a long long time!
This is the way Solid components should act with the native solid tools.

SketchUp Team:
If I wanted to trim a group, I would have done so!

Thanks much for this.

irwanwr

@dave r said:

I think it is similar to the Solid Tools. You should give it a try.

it seems that OSCoolean is a good tool. though it doesn't really work well when i tried to use it. perhaps it needs some updates or something. i don't know for sure.

ktkoh

The BooTools works very well I think it was 10 bucks but well worth the money. It edits the selected component however it deletes the component used to do the editing so if you want both after the operation make a copy of the cutting component. I use it with the free version and have been very plesed

Keith

irwanwr

@ktkoh said:

The BooTools works very well I think it was 10 bucks but well worth the money. It edits the selected component however it deletes the component used to do the editing so if you want both after the operation make a copy of the cutting component. I use it with the free version and have been very plesed

Keith

which free version and where, Keith?

Dave R

@irwanwr said:

@ktkoh said:

The BooTools works very well I think it was 10 bucks but well worth the money. It edits the selected component however it deletes the component used to do the editing so if you want both after the operation make a copy of the cutting component. I use it with the free version and have been very plesed

Keith

which free version and where, Keith?

I think he was referring to the free version of sketchUp.

irwanwr

i see. thank you Dave.
well, 10 bucks in a 3rd world country wont be easy to get.
meanwhile, i guess i'll just stick to Curviloft. it needs some wireframing to do and it does do it's job very well for skinning

Gaieus

How could I overlook this plugin???

Thanks Jim!!!

RODRIGOLEE

Hi,
its works to SketchUp 2014????

TIG

@rodrigolee said:

Hi,
its works to SketchUp 2014????
Install it in v2014 Pro and try it... report back...

RODRIGOLEE

@tig said:

@rodrigolee said:

Hi,
its works to SketchUp 2014????
Install it in v2014 Pro and try it... report back...

Someone tried to install the v2014 before? Isnt working with me.

Dave R

This was done just a moment ago with Trim and Keep in SU2014. I would have to conclude the plugin works. Are you using SU2014 Pro? Your profile still shows you are using SU8.

Screenshot - 7_10_2014 , 4_34_01 AM.png

TIG

The Plugin does works fine with all SketchUp versions [>=8].

Note that it runs from a 'Tools' menu item - 'Trim & Keep'...

However, it does have one glitch...
It always works fine with Solid Component-Instances, BUT it fails if the second picked object is a Solid Group.

See the Ruby Console errors...

This fail/error is sidestepped if you have other some other script loading which itself adds a group.definition method.

A simple fix is to either also have one of those other scripts loading, OR to edit the jf_trim_and_keep.rb file using a plain-text editor like Notepad/Notepad++/TextWrangler [NEVER a wordprocessor!]...

Add this extra code on the very end of the file's text and save it, restart Sketchup and try using the tool on Solid Groups again - it will then work fine with Solid Component-Instances AND Groups:

class Sketchup;;Group
    unless Sketchup;;Group.method_defined?(;definition)
        def definition()
          if self.entities.parent.instances.include?(self)
            return self.entities.parent
          else
            Sketchup.active_model.definitions.each{|definition|
                return definition if definition.instances.include?(self)
            }
          end
          return nil # This should never happen !
        end
    end#if
end#class

Dave R

Maybe that's it. The poster might be using groups instead of components. I didn't ask that because this plugin was written to work on components and keep them components after modifying them.

@unknownuser said:

This plugin allows you to trim a Component and have all instances update as well.

If the object getting trimmed is a group, there's no reason not to use the Trim tool from the Solid Tools set.

TIG

Unfortunately it does allow you to click on a Group, which causes the issue without a group.definition method available...
This tool does still have a use with Solid Groups, because then its result maintains the same name etc, the native tool messes up... it's renamed 'Difference'... and of course it loses its other properties like layer ?

Dave R

True, although I'm hoping for a change in that behavior along with the conversion from components to groups in the near future.