[Plugin] ImageTrimmer

TIG

@dave r said:

Hi TIG,
I have updated to the most recent version of the plugin and tried running it on my PC. I get the following in the Ruby console and it appears the plugin quietly exits.

Error; #<NoMethodError; undefined method `length' for nil;NilClass>
> C;/Program Files/Google/Google SketchUp 8/Plugins/SKMtools/ImageTrimmer.rb;241;in `add_edges'
> C;/Program Files/Google/Google SketchUp 8/Plugins/SKMtools/ImageTrimmer.rb;220;in `make_edges'
> C;/Program Files/Google/Google SketchUp 8/Plugins/SKMtools/ImageTrimmer.rb;170;in `process_image'
> C;/Program Files/Google/Google SketchUp 8/Plugins/SKMtools/ImageTrimmer.rb;147;in `initialize'
> C;/Program Files/Google/Google SketchUp 8/Plugins/SKMtools/ImageTrimmer.rb;618;in `new'
> C;/Program Files/Google/Google SketchUp 8/Plugins/SKMtools/ImageTrimmer.rb;618
> C;/Program Files/Google/Google SketchUp 8/Plugins/SKMtools/image_class.rb;946;in `call'
> C;/Program Files/Google/Google SketchUp 8/Plugins/SKMtools/image_class.rb;946

The error shows that Nil lines were read from the your_image[Edges].dat file.
First test - is it writing the original image file your_image.png, and your_image[Edges].png and your_image[Edges].dat files into a folder called 'TrimmedImages' in your Model's folder ?
Second test - if it is can you 'read' all of them ?
Open the .dat with a plain-text-editor and see if it has 01s in it...
Does the Image you are processing have transparent areas?
Even if it did not it should still make a .dat file [just random ideas at the moment]...
Do you have appropriate permissions to read/write to the SKMtools folder and Model's folder ?
Do you have 'from.ini' and 'to.ini' files left in your ../Plugins/SKMtools folder?
If so read them with a plain-text-editor does the first say path_to_model_folder\TrimmedImages\your_image.png and the second path_to_model_folder\TrimmedImages\your_image ?
If not edit them to suit, if they don't exist make them containing appropriate paths [one line - no 'carriage-return'].
Also ensure there's a folder called 'TrimmedImages' on the specified path.
If you have the two '[Edges]' 'image' files mentioned above move them out of that folder.
However, you must have path_to_model_folder\TrimmedImages\your_image.png in there.
Now double-click on 'EdgeDetector.jar' in the ../Plugins/SKMtools folder - does it make the two files from the in the
'your_image.png' ??

Please test and report back...

Dave R

FWIW, When I reported the problem it was on my PC at home. I tried it here at work on this machine (also XP) and got the same results.

First test - is it writing the original image file your_image.png, and your_image[Edges].png and your_image[Edges].dat files into a folder called 'TrimmedImages' in your Model's folder ?

Yes it does do those things.

Second test - if it is can you 'read' all of them ?

Open the .dat with a plain-text-editor and see if it has 01s in it...

Yes. I can read all of the files and the .DAT file contains a lot of 0s and a few 1s.

Does the Image you are processing have transparent areas?

Yes. At least I can see the axes through the transparent areas.

Even if it did not it should still make a .dat file [just random ideas at the moment]...
Do you have appropriate permissions to read/write to the SKMtools folder and Model's folder ?

It's XP and I have admin rights. An earlier version of the plugin worked fine.

Do you have 'from.ini' and 'to.ini' files left in your ../Plugins/SKMtools folder?

No. those files aren't there.

If so read them with a plain-text-editor does the first say path_to_model_folder\TrimmedImages\your_image.png and the second path_to_model_folder\TrimmedImages\your_image ?
If not edit them to suit, if they don't exist make them containing appropriate paths [one line - no 'carriage-return'].

**Uh.... Can I do this in NotePad? Type, "path_to_model_folder\TrimmedImages\your_image.png" and save it as from.ini?

For the to.ini file is there an extension on your_image?[b]

Also ensure there's a folder called 'TrimmedImages' on the specified path.
If you have the two '[Edges]' 'image' files mentioned above move them out of that folder.
However, you must have path_to_model_folder\TrimmedImages\your_image.png in there.

[b]The .dat file stays or goes? I've moved the one image file with [Edges] in the name out of the folder but haven't continued because I need to make the INI files.**

Dave R

I beg to report that I tried with a different PNG image and it work. There must be something wrong with the other image I used. Is there a way to tell what that something is?

Humpmetwice

@unknownuser said:

To see if anything is messing with .jar files double-click on ../Plugins/EdgeDetector.jar and see what happens - if it opens with say 'WinRar' then edit that App's options to NOT open jar files... 'Jar' files should 'open' [execute] with Java...
It doesn't do anything once I click on it.

@unknownuser said:

Can you edit the permissions to that folder to allow you full access.
By everything I can tell I have full permission to the folders. Far as for all the other, I'm not sure I've done it right but nothing happens.

Oxer

@tig said:

First test - is it writing the original image file your_image.png, and your_image[Edges].png and your_image[Edges].dat files into a folder called 'TrimmedImages' in your Model's folder ?
Second test - if it is can you 'read' all of them ?
Open the .dat with a plain-text-editor and see if it has 01s in it...
Does the Image you are processing have transparent areas?
Even if it did not it should still make a .dat file [just random ideas at the moment]...
Do you have appropriate permissions to read/write to the SKMtools folder and Model's folder ?
Do you have 'from.ini' and 'to.ini' files left in your ../Plugins/SKMtools folder?
If so read them with a plain-text-editor does the first say path_to_model_folder\TrimmedImages\your_image.png and the second path_to_model_folder\TrimmedImages\your_image ?
If not edit them to suit, if they don't exist make them containing appropriate paths [one line - no 'carriage-return'].
Also ensure there's a folder called 'TrimmedImages' on the specified path.
If you have the two '[Edges]' 'image' files mentioned above move them out of that folder.
However, you must have path_to_model_folder\TrimmedImages\your_image.png in there.
Now double-click on 'EdgeDetector.jar' in the ../Plugins/SKMtools folder - does it make the two files from the in the
'your_image.png' ??

Please test and report back...

Hi TIG again,
I have probed the before instructions and now the two files ( my_image[Edges].dat & my_image[Edges].png) appear into TrimmedImages folder with the original image my_image.png, what i do now?
Thanks TIG.

TIG

@oxer said:

@tig said:

First test - is it writing the original image file your_image.png, and your_image[Edges].png and your_image[Edges].dat files into a folder called 'TrimmedImages' in your Model's folder ?
Second test - if it is can you 'read' all of them ?
Open the .dat with a plain-text-editor and see if it has 01s in it...
Does the Image you are processing have transparent areas?
Even if it did not it should still make a .dat file [just random ideas at the moment]...
Do you have appropriate permissions to read/write to the SKMtools folder and Model's folder ?
Do you have 'from.ini' and 'to.ini' files left in your ../Plugins/SKMtools folder?
If so read them with a plain-text-editor does the first say path_to_model_folder\TrimmedImages\your_image.png and the second path_to_model_folder\TrimmedImages\your_image ?
If not edit them to suit, if they don't exist make them containing appropriate paths [one line - no 'carriage-return'].
Also ensure there's a folder called 'TrimmedImages' on the specified path.
If you have the two '[Edges]' 'image' files mentioned above move them out of that folder.
However, you must have path_to_model_folder\TrimmedImages\your_image.png in there.
Now double-click on 'EdgeDetector.jar' in the ../Plugins/SKMtools folder - does it make the two files from the in the
'your_image.png' ??

Please test and report back...

Hi TIG again,
I have probed the before instructions and now the two files ( my_image[Edges].dat & my_image[Edges].png) appear into TrimmedImages folder with the original image my_image.png, what i do now?
Thanks TIG.

OK... so we now know that the ' EdgeDetector.jar' file IS working when it's double-clicked - as it does 'execute' and it makes the files we need.
We now need to find why it isn't 'executing' with UI.openURL() like it should.
Please try this in the Ruby Console...
Move the two '..[Edges].png' and ..[Edges]'.dat' files out of the 'TrimmedImages' folder temporarily.
To get a file to 'execute' on a MAC it's usual to change to the appropriate directory first - type
Dir.chdir(path_to_SKMtools) [you add the full path to the SKM folder]
To check where you are type Dir.pwd - it should now show you are 'in' the 'SKMtools' folder.
and then use
jar="EdgeDetector.jar" File.chmod(0777, jar) - to make sure it is 'executable'.
then type
UI.openURL("file:///"+jar)
The jar should 'open' - execute - and make the two '[Edges]' files we need.
If not can you try other options like
UI.openURL(jar)
or
UI.openURL(full_path_to_SKMtools/EdgeDetetcor.jar)
where the 'path' is the 'full path' to the required jar-file in the SKMtools folder...
any other permutations you can think of for trying to 'run' the 'EdgeDetetcor.jar' file would be appreciated...

I am a bit at a loss to sort out MAC problems like this direct - I don't have access to a MAC... BUT if you can help resolve this I'm sure lots of other MAC users will be grateful, as will I...

TIG

@dave r said:

I beg to report that I tried with a different PNG image and it work. There must be something wrong with the other image I used. Is there a way to tell what that something is?

There's a 'time-out' for making the two 'Edges' files so it might simply be taking too long and exiting - I tweaked the time-out so that it waits longer [60secs] before giving up - please try this alternative with the problem file and see if it helps... http://forums.sketchucation.com/viewtopic.php?p=293677#p293677

Any one else getting the files made but the tool not completing try this new version...

TIG

@unknownuser said:

@unknownuser said:

To see if anything is messing with .jar files double-click on ../Plugins/EdgeDetector.jar and see what happens - if it opens with say 'WinRar' then edit that App's options to NOT open jar files... 'Jar' files should 'open' [execute] with Java...
It doesn't do anything once I click on it.

@unknownuser said:

Can you edit the permissions to that folder to allow you full access.
By everything I can tell I have full permission to the folders. Far as for all the other, I'm not sure I've done it right but nothing happens.

Please try the newest version and report back http://forums.sketchucation.com/viewtopic.php?p=293677#p293677

Humpmetwice

@unknownuser said:

Please try the newest version and report back

Does the same as before. It adds a folder on my desktop called trimmedimages with the image I imported into SU in it but nothing has been done to it and I still get those two messages with nothing being done to the image in SU.

TIG

@unknownuser said:

@unknownuser said:

Please try the newest version and report back

Does the same as before. It adds a folder on my desktop called trimmedimages with the image I imported into SU in it but nothing has been done to it and I still get those two messages with nothing being done to the image in SU.

Your 'Java' installation can't access the 'jar' file... Have you tried updating your Java installation ? It might be 'old'...

Dave R

@tig said:

There's a 'time-out' for making the two 'Edges' files so it might simply be taking too long and exiting - I tweaked the time-out so that it waits longer [60secs] before giving up - please try this alternative with the problem file and see if it helps... http://forums.sketchucation.com/viewtopic.php?p=293677#p293677

Any one else getting the files made but the tool not completing try this new version...

I downloaded your updated file and gave it a try. Still no go with that image file. And it was much less than 60 seconds before it quit so I doubt it is a timeout issue. Curiously, I downloaded another and much simpler PNG with a transparent background and had the same problem. Then I tried it with an SU toolbar icon PNG and it worked perfectly. There must be something wrong with some PNG files.

TIG

@dave r said:

@tig said:

There's a 'time-out' for making the two 'Edges' files so it might simply be taking too long and exiting - I tweaked the time-out so that it waits longer [60secs] before giving up - please try this alternative with the problem file and see if it helps... http://forums.sketchucation.com/viewtopic.php?p=293677#p293677
Any one else getting the files made but the tool not completing try this new version...

I downloaded your updated file and gave it a try. Still no go with that image file. And it was much less than 60 seconds before it quit so I doubt it is a timeout issue. Curiously, I downloaded another and much simpler PNG with a transparent background and had the same problem. Then I tried it with an SU toolbar icon PNG and it worked perfectly. There must be something wrong with some PNG files.

The 'transparent' areas need to be 100% transparent and the 'solid' areas need to be 100% solid ?
Can you post a problem png image - or PM it if it's 'sensitive'.....

Dave R

Here's the second PNG I tried that didn't work. The other one is too large pixel-wise so I put it here instead.

Dave R

FWIW, I opened the wreath PNG (the one in the link) in my image editor, selected the background and made it transparent. I couldn't see any difference in the image, though. I got the same results with the revised version as I did before.

Humpmetwice

@unknownuser said:

Your 'Java' installation can't access the 'jar' file... Have you tried updating your Java installation ? It might be 'old'...

I am using vista so who knows?

Oxer

Hi TIG,
I have probe different combinations and to make it works this is the process in Ruby Console:

Type jar="EdgeDetector.jar"
Type UI.openURL("file:/Users/Oxer/Library/Application Support/Google SketchUp 8/SketchUp/plugins/SKMtools/"+jar)
With these two commands EdgeDetector runs and creates the 2 files into TrimmedImages folder.
Note that the path to EdgeDetector is to my User Account, on Mac you can place the Sketchup plugins in two locations:
a) /Users/User Name*/Library/Application Support/Google SketchUp/SketchUp/plugins
or
b) Library/Application Support/Google SketchUp/SketchUp/plugins

I hope this help you.

TIG

@unknownuser said:

@unknownuser said:

Your 'Java' installation can't access the 'jar' file... Have you tried updating your Java installation ? It might be 'old'...

I am using vista so who knows?

Strange I too run Vista with that version of Java... and have no problems!
Can you post screen-shots of your 'Java settings'...
Do you have full read/write/execute access-rights to the SKMtools folder and its contents?
I have a fix for a MAC problem that I'll post asap - this might also help you... watch this space...

TIG

Here's an update - http://forums.sketchucation.com/viewtopic.php?p=293677#p293677 - it addresses some glitches with the MAC file paths [I hope! Thanks for the assistance Oxer et al]...

Dave R

Thanks TIG.

Have you had an opportunity to look at the two images I was having difficulty with? They were randomly collected off the web and I'm guessing that if I could find two problem images that easily, others would also come across them. Maybe it has to do with images saved from websites?

TIG

@dave r said:

Thanks TIG.
Have you had an opportunity to look at the two images I was having difficulty with? They were randomly collected off the web and I'm guessing that if I could find two problem images that easily, others would also come across them. Maybe it has to do with images saved from websites?

You need to ensure that all sold areas are 'solid' with no transparency - edit the png, merge layers, flatten and select area of the transparent color and delete so transparency is only applied to the 'holes'...
I also tried and made the wreath image smaller so it processed faster...
But it still fails - must be something in the 'form'
As a result of your report I'm revisiting the Java in the EdgeDetector.jar as it had a glitch on the image's edge pixels.
I'm also adding a timed wait [3secs] for the 'dat' file to complete, as I found that 'dat' file was getting made BUT the Ruby was reading the file too soon so it wasn't getting the data...
I'll post updates when they are tested....