Rendering Challenge - Bathroom sink

Al Hart

Al, your sketchy edges say your ground is too high (maybe on purpose ?). But the charcoal effect is fine.

Oops - I need to learn better how to put a room around an existing object.

I'll lower the floor if I try any more renders.

[Edit: I replaced the image in the original post, with the vanity moved up]

Eulgrand

Kerkythea - MLT (BPT) approx. 70 passes (6 hours - my machine is sooo slow )
A bit of post-pro (heavy noise reduction + warm filter)

Bytor, definitely like your walls

Al Hart

@tallbridgeguy said:

This is my first interior and I really don't know how to get the lighting right. (and the walls and the)

Hopefully someone will offer some good advice.

My "first" advice is to add more lights - probably a ceiling light or 2.
Then,, when you get good lighting you should try adding some more reflection. I think you made the bowls reflective - but you should make the countertop reflective as well, and of course, the faucets. It may be that you have already made these reflective,and the highlighting will show up better when you add more lights.

@tallbridgeguy said:

thanks again for the challenge!

I guess I don't like the word challenge. I implies that only the best designers should participate. I think I'll call the next one a "Rendering Workshop". This should be a good place for renderers (people) of all levels to show their work and get advice and learn from others.

Al Hart

For this one, I turned off the lights and lit the candles. (I also used the post-rendering brightness slider to adjust the brightness of the final image. Otherwise auto-exposure compensates for the low lighting level.)

However, with this little light, my camera could not get good focus. (I set focal distance to 7' and the depth of field to 1.0 to blur the image. You can see the faucets are slightly out of focus.)

(IRender nXt - 16 rendering passes - 43 minutes - to let the candle light bounce off of the other surfaces.)

EarthMover

Here's a go using Fryrender...I only let it cook for 3 hours on my laptop, then did some post work in photoshop. I'll probably let it go overnight and update tomorrow.

Bathroom sink _122 passes copy.jpg

Al Hart

@earthmover said:

Here's a go using Fryrender...I only let it cook for 3 hours on my laptop, then did some post work in photoshop. I'll probably let it go overnight and update tomorrow.

It's hard for me to evaluate this view.

It may be just me, but the only feature I can really see and evaluate from this view is the daylight effect on the far wall. And of course, the excellent plant. But I would to see more of the shadows to the right of the plant to see how well the daylight effects are working.

If you decide to change the model, pehaps you can put the window on a different wall so it illuminates the sink more directly, and raise the camera above the sink so we can see it better.

alpro

Here's my Vray try, 12 mins at 1024x768. Only sunlight, coming through skylight. Some post pro, brightness/contrast adjustment, vignette, and resize.

tallbridgeguy

Darn everybody is still doing better than me! Oh well I am learning a lot.

KT - MLT for an 1.5 hours....

Al Hart

Some people are adding lights above the mirror.

Unfortunately the ones I grabbed from the 3D Warehouse added about 300,000 faces to my drawing.

But Ms. SketchUp could see better if there was some light up front.

notareal

@tallbridgeguy said:

There is no way I can compete with the last two renders so I cheated and added a diversion....and tried to add a story. I used Kerky with no clue about what I am doing....it seemed so simple in the brochure. (ha)
Trying to make a decent render shows how hard it actually is (well for me.)

Thanks for the challenge!

I assume you have already read getting started tutorial and tutorials master list.
Add more light and use some nice materials from file repository or Documentation and Sharing > materials and turn on soft shadows. Perhaps you could use some IES lights, easy to set, but you need to get definition files from manufacturers website. Bevel all edges... or use DOF to soften sharp edges.

brodie

I actually ran a render of this same vanity awhile back to give a client an idea of the difference between straight SU output and a rendered output. This was done in Maxwell at only 640x480. I'm afraid I don't remember how long it rendered. Probably 30 minutes or so. It was pretty quick and dirty so many of the materials are garbage. I nearly redid it when I realized how bad the material was on the base cabinet but it got my point across so I let it go.

-Brodie

bathroom vanity.jpg

Al Hart

@unknownuser said:

I actually ran a render of this same vanity awhile back to give a client an idea of the difference between straight SU output and a rendered output. This was done in Maxwell at only 640x480. I'm afraid I don't remember how long it rendered. Probably 30 minutes or so. It was pretty quick and dirty so many of the materials are garbage. I nearly redid it when I realized how bad the material was on the base cabinet but it got my point across so I let it go.

-Brodie

This is a good image. It quickly shows how just a little refection - the mirror and the faucets - can improve a rendering.

Of course, adding reflection to the rest of the surfaces (almost all of them are somewhat reflective in real life) will add even more realism.

olishea

earthmover-great image there

shwetabhseth

Just some stuff i had done with the same model when i was trying my hand at Vray!
I liked the realism of the wooden texture, though the aesthetics are questionable!!

Al Hart

@shwetabhseth said:

Just some stuff i had done with the same model when i was trying my hand at Vray!
I liked the realism of the wooden texture, though the aesthetics are questionable!!

Nice rendering shwet - I like the lighting and the way details such as the towels are brought out.

Now, as you say, we need to find a better room to put a wooden lavatory in.

Also, as another rendering adviser once told me "The secret of reflection is having something to reflect", the mirror, from this perspective, would be more interesting if it had something to reflect.

shwetabhseth

Thnx Al!
Well about the wooden lav, these days its common practice with minimalistic designs making there foray into mainstream!
And i couldn't agree with u more about the reflection....but i was a noobie when i did this...tho i am not better but i do understand these things around! ...
I really appreciate your comment!

and now...i think i might do another render with this model, something which makes me understand if i have bettered myself or not!

just another shot!

Al Hart

@shwetabhseth said:

and now...i think i might do another render with this model, something which makes me understand if i have bettered myself or not!

Nice work. Very realistic. Great job on the glass vase. (I have run into this same vase in other models, and it is always a challenge.)

And good choice of view and lighting to emphasize the highlights and reflections.

I don't know if you have been reading another of my threads about reflection

But I was arguing that almost every object in this model could have some reflection set on it (maybe not the towels), but I bet candles reflect light as well.

shwetabhseth

Sorry, i just started on the forums and this was my first post up here! hope to make my presence felt in the future though, so i haven't been through your post.
Just went thru it though.

I must comment that the way you have specified each of the inclusions in that thread is positively comprehend able and pretty well laid out. Cheers for that!
i hope soon ilk be able to apply these in a better render in the spirit of learning.

About adding reflections to all materials-It increases render times immensely, and i would also like to add that everyobkect we see, rather than having normal reflection, which we generally enable in rendering engines, instead has Specular reflections which is harder to understand and work with in rendering engines i believe.

I think i would go through your thread and add some qualitative information to it.

Al Hart

@shwetabhseth said:

I think i would go through your thread and add some qualitative information to it.

Thanks for the comments,

I extracted some of your comment, and added it to the Reflection Thread, along with a response.

tallbridgeguy

I tried a little different light setup, not great but I think a little better. I looked back at the other sink renders and most seem to be in the daylight.

Is daylight easier/harder to do than a night scene?