Fake or Foto?

HFM

I got one wrong the light bulb

remus

A cool 12/12 for me

I reckon the gavel and door could have been either, though.

pilou

A foto itself is not a real fake?

ely862me

i must admit my glass eye is pretty blind

tomasz

Well done remus!

Ten out of twelve answers were correct in my case.
I have marked wrong the bulb and the door.

Tomasz

BTM

10/12 for me too. I got the alligator (or crocodile) and wrench wrong.

Ecuadorian

I know a program that can help you get almost 100% of the answers right... but that would be cheating, so I'll let this thread run for a while before posting the link to it.

jeff hammond

missed the clock radio and the bridge in london.

glenn

lightbulb for me too

boofredlay

Same for me... lightbulb.

FenS

10/12, egg and hammer wrong in my case. Nice one though!

Mr S

Lightbulb, Tower of London and the Egg fooled me.

remus

To make this a bit more constructive, what do you think it is that makes people suspect an image is CG?

For me the main thing is usually composition, particularly an overly perfect setup.

Tobobo

I only got 5

Marian

I only got 3 wrong.

chango70

I got all of them correct except for tower bridge.

HFM

@remus said:

To make this a bit more constructive, what do you think it is that makes people suspect an image is CG?

For me the main thing is usually composition, particularly an overly perfect setup.

For me it is only the 'overly perfect setup'. Things that make me think 'nothing is that perfect'

FenS

For me it is 'is that really possible in SU?, that must be real', or 'that really looks like something that you should make with SU'. I only got 2 wrong, but i would not have been supprised if would have misguessed every single one of them...

remus

I think the materials can often be a give away as well. For example the screw of the lightbulb has lots of little flecks of dirt and stress marks, stuff that would most likely be missed if it was modelled.

Having said that, the material on the gavel looks almost CG in its perfectness

BTM

True... That, and overuse and 'perfectness' of effects, like field of view, as well as perfectly tiled textures (pattern around radio clock), and perfectly straight edges with no blur; a few things that gave some of them away.