[plugin] Structural analysis - SketchStruct: 30 Oct 12: v201

pilou

Physical indeed!

Severe_dude

awesome it's the future

errror404

Sing me up!! If you guys can take it to the next level it could freaking awesome. BRB gotta try this thing!

dejanfortuna

Looks great keep up the good work.

dejanfortuna

Great tool, i hope you can finish what you have started.

mddc

it is so hard to make... congratulations!

sherwood11

Coool .. I'll check it out !

glro

@target2427 said:

Changelog
v2.0.1 - Added confirmation when choosing materials, now using .rbz install method

Cheers

don't know why: version 2.0.0 is downloaded following the link

and when y try, the ruby box says

Error: #<NoMethodError: undefined method []' for nil:NilClass> C:/PROGRA~2/Google/GOOGLE~3/Plugins/SketchStruct2.0.0/stiffness.rb:815:in member_load'
C:/PROGRA~2/Google/GOOGLE~3/Plugins/SketchStruct2.0.0/stiffness.rb:813:in each' C:/PROGRA~2/Google/GOOGLE~3/Plugins/SketchStruct2.0.0/stiffness.rb:813:in member_load'
C:/PROGRA~2/Google/GOOGLE~3/Plugins/SketchStruct2.0.0/stiffness.rb:858:in main' C:/PROGRA~2/Google/GOOGLE~3/Plugins/SketchStruct2.0.0/main.rb:98 C:/PROGRA~2/Google/GOOGLE~3/Plugins/SketchStruct2.0.0/stiffness.rb:815:in call'
C:/PROGRA~2/Google/GOOGLE~3/Plugins/SketchStruct2.0.0/stiffness.rb:815

no outputs are shown, only inputs

apart from that, it is a nice idea, wish it comes through

Krisidious

oh yeah... I'll be watching this one.

target2427

Sorry about this, I did upload the file but for some reason sourceforge did not pick it up as the latest version. I have manually overridden this now and the newest version should be available for download.

https://sourceforge.net/projects/sketchstruct/files/latest/download

@glro said:

@target2427 said:

Changelog
v2.0.1 - Added confirmation when choosing materials, now using .rbz install method

Cheers

don't know why: version 2.0.0 is downloaded following the link

and when y try, the ruby box says

Error: #<NoMethodError: undefined method []' for nil:NilClass> C:/PROGRA~2/Google/GOOGLE~3/Plugins/SketchStruct2.0.0/stiffness.rb:815:in member_load'
C:/PROGRA~2/Google/GOOGLE~3/Plugins/SketchStruct2.0.0/stiffness.rb:813:in each' C:/PROGRA~2/Google/GOOGLE~3/Plugins/SketchStruct2.0.0/stiffness.rb:813:in member_load'
C:/PROGRA~2/Google/GOOGLE~3/Plugins/SketchStruct2.0.0/stiffness.rb:858:in main' C:/PROGRA~2/Google/GOOGLE~3/Plugins/SketchStruct2.0.0/main.rb:98 C:/PROGRA~2/Google/GOOGLE~3/Plugins/SketchStruct2.0.0/stiffness.rb:815:in call'
C:/PROGRA~2/Google/GOOGLE~3/Plugins/SketchStruct2.0.0/stiffness.rb:815

no outputs are shown, only inputs

apart from that, it is a nice idea, wish it comes through

glro

I tried again the link and yes, now it is the last version

I tried a few times and it worked as expected; sometimes it didn't though

once i got this error message:

"Error: #<NoMethodError: undefined method []' for nil:NilClass> C:/Archivos de programa/Google/Google SketchUp 8/Plugins/SketchStruct2/read.rb:231:in get_nodal_loads'
C:/Archivos de programa/Google/Google SketchUp 8/Plugins/SketchStruct2/read.rb:230:in each' C:/Archivos de programa/Google/Google SketchUp 8/Plugins/SketchStruct2/read.rb:230:in get_nodal_loads'
C:/Archivos de programa/Google/Google SketchUp 8/Plugins/SketchStruct2/read.rb:11:in initialize' C:/Archivos de programa/Google/Google SketchUp 8/Plugins/SketchStruct2/main.rb:66:in new'
C:/Archivos de programa/Google/Google SketchUp 8/Plugins/SketchStruct2/main.rb:66
C:/Archivos de programa/Google/Google SketchUp 8/Plugins/SketchStruct2/read.rb:231:in `call'
C:/Archivos de programa/Google/Google SketchUp 8/Plugins/SketchStruct2/read.rb:231"

With another example, the program gave a result, but in the ruby box, it wrote
"no. joints: 4
no. bars: 3
no. restraints: 4
DOF: 8
Maxwell's number: 1
Errror, mechanism forming
no. degrees of freedom: 8"

Obviously, there is still a lot of work to do to make it a usable tool, but i like very much having it in the sketchup environment

sketchup trial

second trial

target2427

Hi

Just a couple of questions about how you created the structure.

When I run your file I get the same error, however, when I redraw the structure, the program runs fine.

Did you first draw your structure with SketchStruct installed?

and

Did you draw the structure manually, line by line?

Thanks

Tom

glro

@target2427 said:

Did you first draw your structure with SketchStruct installed?

and

Did you draw the structure manually, line by line?

Yes to the first question

No to the second

I had it drawn automatically by another plugin i am working on, that makes a model of a scaffolding

From this model, i kept only the axis line and applied to it loads, supports, material and geometric values.

I didn't guess it would make a difference with a structure drawn from scratch

file 1

target2427

Ok, it looks like the two plugins are incompatible at the moment. SketchStruct uses a couple of minor functions for numbering the edges, this is done as the lines are drawn by the user.

This is a simple function which probably be included in your plugin to allow the two plugins to work together.

If you want more info on how the numbering works, I will be happy to help.

Tom

glro

@target2427 said:

Ok, it looks like the two plugins are incompatible at the moment. SketchStruct uses a couple of minor functions for numbering the edges, this is done as the lines are drawn by the user.

This is a simple function which probably be included in your plugin to allow the two plugins to work together.

If you want more info on how the numbering works, I will be happy to help.

Tom

The plugin i am working on doesn't use any numbering for edges; it is probably done automatically by sketchup

It seems to me that it would be an enhancement for your plugin to be able to number edges of an existing drawing; this way the user could store models and re-use them

Anyway, this is how usual structural analysis softwares work

Thank you for your answer

target2427

I did attempt to achieve this with the automatic Sketchup numbering, however, I had problems as Sketchup does not save these consistently. i.e. the IDs would change between sessions after saving and loading.

Hopefully I can find a way to achieve this with the sketchup numbering. I will try to look for a way to include this in the next version.

jarynzlesa

it seems to be a very nice and useful pluging, but I can not set supports and load. don't know why.

Jim

Tom, this plugin is interfering with normal behavior of SketchUp[1].

I had a quick look at some of the code and there's a lot to go over. In the meantime, I recommend users of this plugin disable it in the Extensions dialog when not in use.

[1] http://sketchucation.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=180&t=49507

target2427

@jim said:

Tom, this plugin is interfering with normal behavior of SketchUp[1].

I had a quick look at some of the code and there's a lot to go over. In the meantime, I recommend users of this plugin disable it in the Extensions dialog when not in use.

[1] http://sketchucation.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=180&t=49507

I am aware of this and will try to fix this for the next version. Sometimes errors pop up in the Ruby console when drawing lines indirectly (squares, arcs...).

I apologise for the errors, but it is something being worked on

irwanwr

This plugin should be awesome. And may become another very good reason to tell my brother to learn SketchUp and not just CAD
I hope all bugs could be fixed and works as it should be.