Harmondsworth Barn

pbacot

Just for structure? Was it necessary to shape the braces-or is it just that this was the gothic culture and they wouldn't have it any other way?

chedda

I believe everything is for structure. The gothic arch is the same it is transferring the load under compression. Cathedrals of the period follow a similar engineerIng although they are decorated, take buttresses and flying buttresses as an example. The arch and dome are merely ways of spanning voids and creating space the aesthetics are secondary.

pbacot

@chedda said:

I believe everything is for structure. The gothic arch is the same it is transferring the load under compression. Cathedrals of the period follow a similar engineerIng although they are decorated, take buttresses and flying buttresses as an example. The arch and dome are merely ways of spanning voids and creating space the aesthetics are secondary.

Arches are used in stone because it is segmented and all the stones need support as well as compress the arch by their weight. A board doesn't need to be arch shaped to transfer the same loads. Or...I'd like to learn more if this isn't the case. It's more work to shape it--and be artistic.

chedda

Perhaps your right, it's just historical taste. Or they used the curve to gain space or let light penetrate easier. I have a book on timber frames when im not busy I'll take a look. I don't believe it is purely artistic though, especially in a barn which is purely functional. I'm sure someone here has the answer.The curved sections are also in the roof, could it be they are sprung to create tension and rigidity in the frame ? Of course a stone arch transfers the force laterally and locks in place. Wood can also work in tension as well as compression.This guy shows some being cut

Cutting curved stock for timber frame buildings.

The Forestry Forum (www.forestryforum.com)

I think in this case he quotes its for clearance

Another link here:

Attention Required! | Cloudflare

(www.timberstructures.net)

I also suspect it could be connected with the nature of wood in that pieces are often curved.

This link suggests strength & beauty:

http://www.holderbros.com/blog/tagged-with/post-and-beam

So perhaps there is an aesthetic.

Finally another interesting link:

http://www.carpenteroakandwoodland.com/media/37030/timber%20framing%20guide%20-%20download%20format.pdf

I believe there is a lot of tradition connected to timber frames which may be symbolic.By the way my curves are all the same whereas in the actual building they are all different.

hellnbak

Impressive work

tadema

Brilliant! that should be in a frame and on your wall.
John

Bryan K

@tadema said:

Brilliant! that should be in a frame and on your wall.
John

What he said. ^

cmoreink

Good modeling and texturing, lighting is good too! The trucktor could be a bit rusty thou
cheers

pbacot

Thanks for the links... Impressive work. Yes I have always been interested in looking at farm structures and thinking how the structures and the arrangement of the homestead altogether developed from economy and necessity but also perseverance and love. The massing alone is always celebrated in painting and drawings.

chedda

Thanks for all the comments guys, pbabcot if you search medieval on the warehouse you will find some interesting models.

Roger

@chedda said:

Thanks Roger, is manchester terrier slang for doberman ? Everything looks small in this huge space. Perhaps he is wary of the owl ? Or maybe being a farm dog he is well fed with poachers. If there is enough interest in this model I will strip out the textures and post it here. Is there a size limit for skippy files ?

Manchester Terriers and Dobermans were both bred from a breed called "Black and Tans." The Manchester Terrier was developed to keep rats out of the grain kept in Manchester breweries/pubs. They like to chase things into corners and holes and tear them apart. In spite of obsessive behavior they are dedicated to humans. I trust mine with my four-year-old grandson. The dog will knock him down with enthusiasm, but will do nothing but lick him to death. Small animals are another story. I once saw my dog do a back flip to take a flying pigeon out of the air.

chedda

Thanks for the insight Roger, i've heard of black & tans. Being an englishman i also know about ratting with terriers they are quite vicous ! As a child i slept with our dog a labrador who instinctively protected me from wasps etc. Now i live in an apartment with 3 cats that's a different story.