Lumion - Test drive
-
thanks for sharing your experience Pete, I made a very quick try some days ago and my impression was to having my hands tied.... it looks great (except the specular objects reflect the sky also in interiors... 
) but without enough control for imported objects, I also cannot find a scale command. About pricing, it seems his direct competitor could be twinmotion2 that is even more expensive... 
-
@solo said:
Lumion is now downloaded and installed.
I’m running a full version....
Is this thread an advertisement? I don't care if it is, but if they are throwing you a copy of the program in return for your review then it should have been made clear from the start what was happening.
-
No John this is not an advert, this is a review from a SU users point of view. I will not be biased nor inflate or exaggerate the product, I have a one month full evaluation license to test this product as arranged with Lumion without any deals made or exchange for any endorsements, I do not own the full version and I need to be actively connected to their server to use it.
At the end of this exercise members of SCF can make a better informed decision if this product is right for them based on my conclusions, learning from my mistakes and their following along with the demo version.If this endeavor is a success and indeed helps some people then we will be doing this with other SU related software in future. At the end of the day I wanted to learn this product and have the time to do so, I thought why not document it, so please do not take offense or assume foul play. I hope my reviews and discussions about 3rd party apps helps this community as it's intended as we have been down this road before and I'm not up for another round of the same old arguements.
Can we please keep on topic now guys, or is this an exercise in futility?
-
Okay, so I played around a little more, this time I used some library objects like stones, trees, boats, people, birds and a bench.
Placing objects was easy and rather fun actually.
Getting the animated people to walk in a path took some head scrathing until I found that you need to be in movie mode to enable object animation.
The fly-through works very similar to Sketchup, instead of creating scenes you take a 'snapshot' as key frames and then you can preview your path. Once happy you save the video.
On the Lumion site the FAQ mentions .avi and mp4 available as video export, I only got an mp4 option and have posted an inquiry on their forum as to why.Here is a quick animation, from a very short time learning the product. I have much still to learn but so far so good.
[flash=600,400:35hzyq5r]http://vimeo.com/moogaloop.swf?clip_id=17939379[/flash:35hzyq5r]
-
Nice movie Solo
Small point: the reflection in the windows of the trees looks 'funky'
Have been trying it out myself and so far I'm very pleased. Very easy program with good help options [got a bit stuck with applying the materials
] and the mouse-WASD combo works very well for me since I've played a game or two 
[I do understand that the 'older' part of the community might need a bit of time adjusting to it ]Tried importing a skp, which went really well. Only negative thing that I can think of right now is that the SKP > DAE conversion seems to ignore cut out components [on the left of the pictures, the windows]:
ps. also can't seem to find the scale option, but I don't see this as a problem. Since everything inside the software is at good scale and the files I use are also.
-
There is a .skp import option?
I need to understand the glass material, I cut the reflection right down but reflections are still a little dodgy.
I was hoping that I could use my 3Dconnexion explorer but it's not supported, that would make life a whole lot easier.
-
Well no there is no straight SKP import but it can be done via the collada export in sketchup. I'm going to try other exports tomorrow to see if there are any that keep the cutout components intact.
-
Yeah, the reflection in the windows looks kinda odd. Did you render the movie at maximum quality, Pete? I understand that certain things, like reflection maps, do not update if you choose a lower quality.
BTW, what GPU do you have and how long did it take to render the video?
It would be cool if they released a 30-day fully functional trial...
-
I've also tried the demo and from what I understand the demo isn't limited to 30 days. I think they will have a 30 day version with save and a "infinite" demo without save.
My main issue is the feel that I can't control all that I want and can't change the "look".
Though its easy and fun to use, it have a distinctive look that isn't photoreal.
The sky for example.
It does look nice but not great and its not "exchangeable" for a sky box with photos.
How will I be able to make it look different than everybody else?
Also the inability to import animated components (without buying two really expensive software) and the lack of lights (there is only the sun) makes it hard to use for interiors. The quality of the ambient occlusion doesnt look all that great and there is no color bleeding which would really help getting it look more real.
Personally I think these programs need to mature for one or two versions to be what I need. They seem to be rushed to market.
I would also like to see some way of getting it interactive on to the web. Movies are great but I believe interactive visualisation is the future... -
@johnsenior1973 said:
Is this thread an advertisement? I don't care if it is, but if they are throwing you a copy of the program in return for your review then it should have been made clear from the start what was happening.
John, we discussed it (in private) whether Pete should do this and decided that yes, the community would definitely benefit from it. As it is not an advertisement here, you can see from my (sometimes exaggerated and little harsh) comments/questions above, too.
@solo said:
Can we please keep on topic now guys, or is this an exercise in futility?
OK, end of off-topic and sorry Pete for the above remarks but I hope it helps clarify-
Back to topic...
@pixero said:I've also tried the demo and from what I understand the demo isn't limited to 30 days. I think they will have a 30 day version with save and a "infinite" demo without save.
That would make much more sense to me. Without saving, you cannot test a whole bunch of things (I guess not even if you can save your custom materials and such...)
@pixero said:
How will I be able to make it look different than everybody else?
Without custom stuff, it is indeed a question. In my field, I would of course need custom materials/vehicles/people etc. only. I do not really mind the lack of 100% photoreal and distinctive look. It's a bit like those Shrek movies but I like it.
@ecuadorian said:
Yeah, the reflection in the windows looks kinda odd.
@hfm said:
Small point: the reflection in the windows of the trees looks 'funky'
@tridem said:
the specular objects reflect the sky also in interiors...
I guess these glitches will be ironed out in some later, patch release...
@hfm said:
Tried importing a skp, which went really well. Only negative thing that I can think of right now is that the SKP > DAE conversion seems to ignore cut out components [on the left of the pictures, the windows]:
This may also be an import bug (dae should keep the cutting feature of components) but I guess you could work it around by really cutting (intersecting and deletin) those areas for now...
@pixero said:
the lack of lights (there is only the sun) makes it hard to use for interiors
As I understand, interior lighting will come at a certain phase...
Pete, keep up with the experiments and share your experiences here, please.
(And disregard my rants...)
-
@ Pixero, I understand what you are saying and at moment I also feel that there are limited options for skies and landscapes not to mention the animated objects available. From what I gathered reading the Lumion forum it seems they are very open to suggestions, so who knows these are very early days, they hardly have tutorials available yet so I'm pretty sure that they will be boosting their content and templates soon.
The one issue I do have is creating your own content, besides SU, which is great for any stationary object, the animated stuff is what I'm thinking about. I do not worry about vegetation as I'm sure the user library will grow in time to cover almost anything you could want, however like Csaba was saying what if he needs some period pieces, like plebs and Romans?
I read yesterday that they have a lot planned for future updates, like particle effects, lighting and a wider variety of content.
The one thing about Lumion is it's a lot of fun, I really enjoyed playing around with it.
The movie creation is very easy, anyone who has ever made an animation in SU will pick it up fast. -
@solo said:
The movie creation is very easy, anyone who has ever made an animation in SU will pick it up fast.
Also, as I see, the camera movement is smoother than in SU which (if true) is an additional bonus.
-
Another quick animation.
[flash=600,400:3lk9dyzm]http://vimeo.com/moogaloop.swf?clip_id=17943096[/flash:3lk9dyzm]
-
Since I wouldn't have the time to evaluate this software, I think this is great.
Questions:
Would you be able in the end to export the animation file directly to a client in a format that would be easily viewable by them?
What are the file sizes coming in at?
Does the software recognize SketchUp scenes? -
@unknownuser said:
Would you be able in the end to export the animation file directly to a client in a format that would be easily viewable by them?
What are the file sizes coming in at?
Does the software recognize SketchUp scenes?You can export .mp4 and image sequence (the version I have does not have .avi) so I guess with a video editing app you can create just about any video format.
The sizes depend on your export/video resolution settings.No, Lumion does not recognise SU scenes, groups or components, and at moment there is no way to animate SU models.
-
Pete,
Your initial feeling on this? I felt it was alot like iClone. But with more advanced enviroment and a very forgiving UI.
-
Richard, Imagine iClone/Vue lite blend kinda.
These are very early days for Lumion, I do not think that they have a concrete road-map at this moment, judging by what I've read so far it looks like they are going to gauge the market for what heading to take.
At the moment it's a basic app with great potential, the ability to get a result fast is the best part. I'd like to see more options and better control over objects and materials. I'd also like to see things like an internal vegetation editor, maybe a way to create animated movements from base models.
I'm not sure at the moment who this app is geared towards, I'd really hope that it does not go towards the hobbyist with sword wielding nymphs and space adventurers but stay professional and maybe get a boost in the realism department.
-
This was made in MAX years ago. I hope Lumion enables custom object animation for escalators/elevators, custom animated textures for TV screens, etc., so I can do this kind of thing without the headache that MAX is.
[flash=853,505:2spwd5d8]http://www.youtube.com/v/CDj336O_vxA&fs=1[/flash:2spwd5d8]
-
Hi Remko, welcome and thanks for dropping by to clarify some things... Expect more quesrions however!
I think Pete (solo) was a good choice for this test drive and passing info to us. He uses a wide variety of different rendering applications so we can all "trust" his evaluation and opinion.
So notes...
@remko said:
Focus: Our focus is 100% on professionals creating visualizations. I mean architects and artists. We have no interest in hobbyists with this product.
True that I am not an architect and I would not even call myself an artist. However my work (when I model "professionally" and not just hand around to administrate these forums) involves archaeological visualization (I am an archaeologist by original profession so I am not doing this as a "hobby" although I may be a very lucky person because I like it as much as if it were my hobby really). When I model a Roman watchtower, I need Roman soldiers in there. When I model a Medieval house, I need some Medieval folks and horse carts and such).
I consider myself pretty efficient at modelling however I am far from being very fluent and effective at rendering. This is why I think that something like this "idiot proof" Lumion is (would be) a perfect solution for me. But of course, it also means custom content; people, vehicles, materials and such. I watched some videos and understand that I can import materials with my models and add shaders like normal maps and all but I would like to save these as well as save any custom content I make.
I understand this may be a rather narrow slice of the cake and with a new product you cannot concentrate on weirdos like me but as I also understand from what many gentlemen above added, some customization is indeed a general feature request for many. After all, even architects work with many different materials all over the world and these all need to be "custom" to a certain extent.
So overall, I am really tempted but without the perspective option at least to be able to ad my stuff, I (for instance) cannot indeed justify the cost (for myself, again, and only for what I would/could be doing it, otherwise I think it's quite reasonable). So in this case I may remain a "hobbyist".
Anyway, I hope you hear what I am saying. Here is another example by the way. This person is building Rome and is currently rendering in Kerkythea. However I can already see the potential of Lumion in such a project. (And that is a professional project with his wife, who is also an archaeologist).
Also, see your Private Messages, please.
-
Hi, I'm Remko, one of the programmers of Lumion and I'm honored this board wants to review Act-3D's little tool
I decided to join in on the conversation to clarify things when needed and also to see what's happening here so we can feed it back into the development process.First, let me explain a bit about Lumion. Act-3D decided to build Lumion because we saw that a huge portion of our customers was using our 3D engine for architecture visualization. We also saw there was only a very small crowd that was capable of writing shaders and other difficult things.
In short Lumion is a tool designed to make it very easy to create architecture visualization. It's not designed to let you do everything but we designed it so you can get decent results very quickly. We are not pretending to be a tool similar to 3DS Max but instead we want to provide an alternative option. The core of our idea behind the product is that it should be accessible to anyone. Anyone should be able to create a movie. Some people might not create movies as nice as highly skilled artists but still we want Lumion to be easy and quick so everybody can use it.
So, that's a little bit of background, here's what you want to know:
Reflections: They can look odd because we do not use ray-tracing. Ray-tracing takes hours so to get reflective surfaces we generate a cube map which is used to approximate reflections. We do have some plans for accurate reflections on flat surfaces. On curved surfaces it's usually hard to see you are looking at fake reflections because of the distortion. In the next update you have the ability to position the reflection map grab position, reducing obvious flaws to a minimum. After that you'll see more improvements with each update.
Animation: You can animate elevators, people, cars etc.. but it's all very simple now. Act-3D wanted to start simple and expand. Right now you can define a linear movement or rotation for each object for every scene. Even though we might expand the animation capabilities you can expect everything to be simple. People should walk automatically and wheels should spin automatically - that sort of thing. There are even some wild ideas about automatic crowd animations and traffic. It's all technically doable so who knows where we will go in the future.
Focus: Our focus is 100% on professionals creating visualizations. I mean architects and artists. I must confess this was a topic that came up several times during development. Because of the GUI and the simplicity people might think it looks like a game. It's not. It's a professional tool with specific professionals in mind. When we started the GUI was more colorful and I mad it minimalistic black and white to make it look a bit more serious. We are quite satisfied with the GUI though. In the end I think people will appreciate what we've done in terms of the GUI. We wanted something that 'just works'.
Sketch-up integration: Right now Lumion is young. Lumion exists for one month now (our other software is available for 10 years now). As time progresses Lumion gets more users and more users means Act-3D can do more. Act-3D can definitely see the value of tighter Sketch-up integration. One of the key goals of Lumion was to offer quick workflow between Sketch-up and Lumion. The main thing in Lumion now that exposes this is the reload button. If you change your model in Sketch-up you can hit a reload button to update the model in Lumion. Act-3D worked a lot in visualization and I know from experience a lot time is lost updating the visualization of the model to the latest version of the model. With features like this Act-3D tries to make things easier.
Limited options/ customization: Act-3D thinks that Lumion already has a huge variety of models, landscapes and other options. The logical way for the future is more of this. Each update will offer more content and more features. Act-3D sees customization as an advanced feature so more options will appear for tweaking the landscape, providing your own textures but we want to be very careful with our GUI. We do not want to pile feature upon feature to end up with a tool which has enormous complexity. Act-3D thinks even very complex things can be presented in a clear and transparent way.By the way, you can already import any content you want and sue your own textures/configuration for materials. I saw a guy that made a mod, changing all tree textures so the trees had snow on them. Although not our intend it's a creative solution. You could create a custom sky by just importing a huge dome with a texture on it. If you hit the ctrl key you get many options to customize the look. We will expand features like this in the future. Act-3D is doing a lot of research at the moment about lighting, depth of field, post processing and quality improvement. As time progresses you will see a lot more options to create a distinct look.
Advertisement: Act-3D not sponsoring anyone on this website. Act-3D does not believe playing tricks on customers is a good way of doing business. Of course we want to get good reviews but the most sensible way to do this is by making great software. If it's crap let us know so we can make it better. Fortunately the overall the reactions until now are quite positive. Act-3D's approach is that you can find out for yourself. We're too small to do massive advertisement campaigns so our best bet is the software sells itself. Reviews are a great help for this.
Advertisement