Why is USA TV full of violence?
-
“Nobody ever went broke underestimating the taste of the American public.”
Henry Louis MenckenOr anyone else either!
-
I remember years ago when I first introduced 'Coupling' to my American wife she was amazed at what the BBC allowed as far as sexual innuendo and promiscuity.
I have been watching 'Spooks' (MI5 in the USA) and there is a whole lot of violence, on par with 24 IMO, so I do not believe this trend is exclusive to America.I'd rather have my kids watch a violent show on TV than any reality show actually, at least the violent show has an entertainment value.
-
You bring up some good points, bytor, especially the part about parents teaching their kids how to deal with all these influences. I'm not a parent, but at 45yo I've noticed a lot and have experienced attitude changes through the years, and it seems to me there are a lot of parents these days who are asleep at the wheel.
Also, when I was a kid in the movies and on TV it was always clear who was "bad" and who was "good", and you always rooted for the good guys. When playing, we were always the good guys. That's not always the case these days. In many video games and TV shows, the viewer/player identifies with the criminal. Is it any wonder that kids are shooting each other in schools when they are learning that guns are the answer to their problems? (this isn't limited to kids; here in Tennessee they've seem to have gone gun crazy, and have passed laws allowing citizens to carry guns just about anywhere. Recently, a man in his 60s shot and killed a man in his 70s 'cause he claimed the guy lunged into his car to do him harm - good thing he had his gun sitting on the seat next to him, huh?)
-
Solo, I agree on the reality shows, except Amazing Race, which I watch religiously. I tried watching an episode of Big Brother once - it was boring as an intern's first SketchUp model (oh, look, a cube. How quaint). But to each his/her own, I guess. (there are worse things on TV, but I won't mention Fox News Channel
) -
@solo said:
I remember years ago when I first introduced 'Coupling' to my American wife she was amazed at what the BBC allowed as far as sexual innuendo and promiscuity.
I have been watching 'Spooks' (MI5 in the USA) and there is a whole lot of violence, on par with 24 IMO, so I do not believe this trend is exclusive to America.actually the Beeb have been showing one of the most violent shows on TV for nearly 50 years now...
try calculating the body count in Doctor Who sometime....(nout counting mass bombings by various races)
-
@khai said:
try calculating the body count in Doctor Who sometime....(nout counting mass bombings by various races)
Then there's Midsomer Murders on ITV, total carnage..... but all done in such nice settings.
-
Ah, I don't mind a good murder mystery even if there are a load of murders in it but I really don't need to see slashing and blood flying all over the place. Okay, I'll make an exception for Hallibal Lecter
-
Mike
I think the Hannibal reference is interesting. While an excellent movie and definitely a greusome tale - it would be considered relatively tame compared to many of the new releases in the Horror genre. Another good movie example is the godfather series. The early ones were considered extreme depictions of violence in their day. They pale in comparison to some of the current TV shows dientified in this thread.
Another big difference though is the direction / production / writing with the movie examples above and many others from the old school. The talent level of the writers / directors / producers of a lot of today's tv / movies / entertainment media isn't even close to what it was before - of course it could be they are just playing to the audience. We seem to have lost the ability to stimulate the imagination with suggestion and perception. I will dare to compare it to growing up in the 70's when a young lad in social situations could often enjoy where his imaginination might take him. Nowadays - the way the lasses dress - there is nothing much left to the imagination!
Dean
-
@bytor said:
The talent level of the writers / directors / producers of a lot of today's tv / movies / entertainment media isn't even close to what it was before - of course it could be they are just playing to the audience.
The latter is true. Like all business endevours, tv is about making money. Hence most stuff we see on the tube, is run-off-the-mill junk.
There's still splendid stuff being aired, though. Though apparently only by HBO.
Deadwood, Six Feet Under, The Wire - all prime examples of what tv can be. -
I thinks a lot of the 'problem' is that it is now too easy to create gruesome special effects whereas in Hitchcock's time he had to stimulate our imagination. The Psycho Shower Stabbing Scene is a great example http://www.dailymotion.com/video/x6mau9_psycho-shower-stabbing-scene_shortfilms
Yep Dean, many young ladies these days don't leave much to the imagination.
-
I saw an article a while back that had some evidence for a plus side to all the realistic depictions of gore: people are not as freaked out by blood and gore in emergency situations and are more able to respond quickly and calmly. The article had some statistics about bystanders at auto accidents that seemed to support the idea.
Years ago my wife pointed out that only men faint at the sight of blood. Any woman who did so would be falling off the toilet several times every month.
And on another sub-thread, Solo's list of "Glenn Beck, Bill O'Rielly, and Bill Maher" missed an obvious distinction. Maher presents himself as a stand-up comic. He goes on tours, plays Vegas, does HBO specials, etc. He comments on the absurdity of political reality. Beck and O'Reilly, on the other hand, present themselves as legitimate political reporters and commentators yet they make things up to further their political agendas, as regularly pointed out by comedians like Jon Stewart and political commentators like Keith Olberman.
-
@mike lucey said:
Ah, I don't mind a good murder mystery even if there are a load of murders in it but I really don't need to see slashing and blood flying all over the place. Okay, I'll make an exception for Hallibal Lecter
When I was 9, a friend of mine and I went to see Frankenstein. It was the first time in my life I was exposed to Cinematic Crap. I spent well over 3/4 of the time in the theater's lobby, while the film was playing. I had the the most horrific nightmare that evening. I remember that event to this day. I have tried to avoid all such Cinematic Crap, all my life. The amount of Crap produced to entertain the masses has increased 100% over the past 10 years. It really started to pick up with the Hallibal Lecter Crap.
Perhaps soon to be followed by more Crap: The Kinder side of Jeffrey Dahmer.However what really gets me pissed off, is how all of this has allowed us to become divorced from reality as just another picture, such as as a beautiful Pelican covered with oil:
Advertisement