Can a car be art?
-
Solo, you yourself stated the Duesenburg automobile is art, but it has a function, can be useful - if it still runs, can still be used for it's intended purpose.
Sadly, there are some people who, yes, would consider Suri Cruise's gilded poop as art.
-
actually it can become a canvass.
-
@unknownuser said:
Solo, you yourself stated the Duesenburg automobile is art, but it has a function, can be useful - if it still runs, can still be used for it's intended purpose.
I believe the Duesenberg is now art, as it's function is purely for admiration and exhibition, it was not originally designed as art, nor intended, similar to da Vinci's 'helicopter' drawings was not intended as art but as a technical diagram, which now has no function for build but exists in a museum of sorts as a piece of art.
-
@unknownuser said:
actually it can become a canvass.
Ah, but the bus is not art, the art on it is art, therefore the bus is the gallery on which the art is displayed.
-
Off course a car can be art. To me that is evident.
It all depends on how and in which circumstances it is presented and what the artist wants to evoke with it.An example to illustrate: the 'urinoir' of Marcel Duchamps (early 20th century Dadaism):
On its own, a urinoir is a simple useful object, but placed in an extraordinary situation, it can evoke the surrealism of 'banality'.
-
so.... a car driving on the road is a car, but in a gallery it becomes art?
-
@solo said:
so.... a car driving on the road is a car, but in a gallery it becomes art?
No, think it through Pete. It's about the idea behind what the artist wants to express.
I can't imagine putting a car in a showroom would make it art just like that...but when it is modified etc...to express a powerful thought, concept or emotion than yes, off course.Hey Pete, I would have expected you would be the first one to be thinking out of the box . A bit disappointing?
, as I consider you to be an artist yourself. 
...As a personal note, I really like the concept of art to be relieved from any 'estethic' rules.
Estethics gets in the way of creation of ideas. Off course, art can still be 'beautiful', but it doesn't have to.
Take Stinkies work for example. I don't find his photos 'beautiful', but I admire the way he can transfer an emotion like 'emptyness' with it... -
@kwistenbiebel said:
@solo said:
so.... a car driving on the road is a car, but in a gallery it becomes art?
No, think it through Pete. It's about the idea behind what the artist wants to express.
I can't imagine putting a car in a showroom would make it art just like that...but when it is modified etc...to express a powerful thought, concept or emotion than yes, off course.Hey Pete, I would have expected you would be the first one to be thinking out of the box . A bit disappointing?
, as I consider you to be an artist yourself. ...As a personal note, I really like the concept of art to be relieved from any 'estethic' rules.
Estethics gets in the way of creation of ideas. Off course, art can still be 'beautiful', but it doesn't have to.
Take Stinkies work for example. I don't find his photos 'beautiful', but I admire the way he can transfer an emotion like 'emptyness' with it...excellent point kwist..
hey we know our buddy solo.. he knows it. he is just trying to create questions to build up controversy. just like a teacher teaching theory of knowledge where everythign can be correct. so he is a really fitting to create such wonderful corner thread like this that sparks controversy.
-
See my first post Chris, I clearly defined my real thoughts, but it is great to challenge others too.
-
...and great intermezzo's these little discussions are, Pete
-
I personally think that everything man creates with his mind, heart and body is art, doesn't matter if it has, had or will have a function.
Art is creation, this is what makes us more unique in nature than reason or conscienceness. While other animals have some degree of reason and conscienceness, that's why some use tools and have some other advanced abilities, they don't come close to what even the first humanoids made in terms originality and "beauty".
Just take a look at this ancient obsidian arrowhead, one of the first original creations of man, it has a simple shape but I still find it appealing.
-
Well said Marian!
I would certainly find this car art..Elisei
-
Lol, a Volvo hot rod.
Definitely not the first thing that pops into your mind when you think of a hot rod. Plus points for originality
-
@kwistenbiebel said:
@solo said:
so.... a car driving on the road is a car, but in a gallery it becomes art?
No, think it through Pete. It's about the idea behind what the artist wants to express.
I can't imagine putting a car in a showroom would make it art just like that...but when it is modified etc...to express a powerful thought, concept or emotion than yes, off course.Sorry, C-Man, Pete's right. Sign it, toss it in a gallery, and it is art. That's precisely the idea behind Duchamp's readymades. And he was right, obviously. Call it art, and it is art. Bad art, possibly, but still.
-
The definition of art is:
@unknownuser said:
art[ahrt]–noun:
- the quality, production, expression, or realm, according to aesthetic principles, of what is beautiful, appealing, or of more than ordinary significance.
That is the definition, and in that definition it says "or of more than ordinary significance" which means a car can be art.
Unless someone objects this. -
Then my penis is a masterpiece.
-
@solo said:
Then my penis is a masterpiece.
Man you gotta get off those [censored] websites man!
Even though it is true, but only the females might find that appealing to the eye... unless you count the homosexuals... -
The human foot is a masterpiece of engineering and a work of art. — Leonardo da Vinci
@ Pete
Who's gonna argue with what Da Vinci says is art?
Also if your penis is art, is it on display in some gallery? And have you replaced it with a PR render?
-
Also, is it signed?
Anyone else find it odd we're discussing the artistic merits of Pete's nether regions?
-
I don't know if it art. . .But I Like it!
Advertisement