Model.save does not save

HPW

Have you searched for the file name. Seeing that you give the method a relative filename, do you know where it's saved?

Yes it is there. When I press the File/Save it gets written with it's new size.

What if you change one if your line to: savename = File.join(Fileskpdirname, skpbasename+".skp")

It gives a invalid filename-error.
Removing the path it does not complain anymore and return a true. But file is not updated.

Maybe it is important that I do this from a ruby starting on SU-startup.

thomthom

@hpw said:

@unknownuser said:

Have you searched for the file name. Seeing that you give the method a relative filename, do you know where it's saved?

Yes it is there. When I press the File/Save it gets written with it's new size.

? Aren't we talking about saving from Ruby?

@hpw said:

It gives a invalid filename-error.

Can you give an example of a filename with the path that doesn't work? Maybe you got some non-ASCII characters that causes problems.

HPW

@unknownuser said:

? Aren't we talking about saving from Ruby?

Yes, I copy a empty SKP to my work-directory and start SU with the filename in the commandline-parameter.
So I stand in my SKP-file yet.
Now the startup-ruby does import my autocad-file and does some processing on it.
Now I want to save and leave SU.
The ruby save does not work. But when I choose File/save or CTRL-S then it gets saved.

@unknownuser said:

Can you give an example of a filename with the path that doesn't work? Maybe you got some non-ASCII characters that causes problems.

No. My filesnames are as following:

20090708_080921161_samplecust@sampleurl_com_{E62CA959-8615-40C9-926E-4883168F8FEC}.skp

Date_time_email_GUID.skp

I also tried Hello.skp with no luck.

And why does the command only take a filename without path?

thomthom

@hpw said:

Yes, I copy a empty SKP to my work-directory and start SU with the filename in the commandline-parameter.
So I stand in my SKP-file yet.
Now the startup-ruby does import my autocad-file and does some processing on it.
Now I want to save and leave SU.
The ruby save does not work. But when I choose File/save or CTRL-S then it gets saved.

I'm not sure if SU will use the path that you opened the file from. It could be saved to a completely different location. Which is why I suggest you search your harddrive for it.

Not sure what the deal with full path is though. Have to look into that.

thomthom

I did a quick test myself.

File.dirname('test.skp')
This saved a file in my Sketchup folder. I'm guessing it's where your files are saved as well.

And I had no problems saving files using full path. But I wonder if you haven't used forward slashes (/) as Ruby require due to it's cross-platform nature.

'C:\test.skp' fails, but 'C:/test.skp' works.

You can use File.expand_path to convert relative paths to full paths and also sort out your slashes.
` File.expand_path('.')

C:/Programfiler/Google/Google SketchUp 7`

HPW

Thanks for the hint with the forward-slashes.
And I find some test-files in my 'Google Sketchup 7\Plugins' folder.

But there remains a problem.
I can not save to the filename of my currently open file.
That does not work.
When I modify the filename and save to a new file then it works.

thomthom

That's probably because SU has that file open and the Ruby script isn't allowed access to it.

HPW

@unknownuser said:

That's probably because SU has that file open and the Ruby script isn't allowed access to it.

But then it shouldn't return 'true' for success.
I would call it a bug.
Also the doc could be more improved with a sample with path and a hint to the forward-slash problem.

thomthom

It return true when you save over the currently open file?
And if you reopen that file - what do you get?

HPW

@unknownuser said:

It return true when you save over the currently open file?
And if you reopen that file - what do you get?

It return true when I try to save to the currently open file!
But it stays the same size and when I reopen it I get the same as before.

Al Hart

After wrestling with this problem for an hour or two for a routine I am writing to load a .SKP file, change it and resave it, I came up with this solution:

Replace \ with / in the file name (save does not seem to like )
Save the current model with a temporary name (in the same folder as the desired final name)
Close the current model (You have to close the model so you can modify the .skp file already on disk)
Remove the current .skp file (if it exists)
Move the temporary file to the desired file (rename())


	# routine to save a .SKP file with the same name as the current model
	# need to save file with a temporary name, close model, then move the temporary name to the real name
	def resave_file(sfile)
		# save() does not seem to like back slashes
		# replace them withforward slashes
		sfile.gsub!(Regexp.new("\\\\"), '/')
		printf("sfile; %s\n", sfile)
		
		# save to a temporary location first
		# this assumes the file name ends with .skp (or .SKP)
		sfile2 = sfile[0, sfile.length - 3] + 'TMP'
		printf("sfile2; %s\n", sfile2)
		bret = Sketchup.active_model.save(sfile2)
		printf("Save file; bret; %s\n", bret)
		return(bret) if !bret
		
		# now move sfile2 to sfile
		# remove existing file
		# need to close existing model first
		Sketchup.file_new
		if File.exists?(sfile)
			begin
			File.unlink(sfile)
			rescue
				warn "could not delete file; " + sfile
				return(false)
			end
		end#if
		
		bret2 = File.rename(sfile2, sfile)
		printf("Returning bret2; %s2\n", bret2)
		return(bret2)
		
	end#def

If you need to file to still be open after the save, you could open it again.

Let me know if it works for you