Gatehouse WIP - Podium renders

Edson

thanks, fellas. i always appreciate hearing from you. those helpful guys at the podium forum have been making some suggestions for improvement which i will pursue in order to learn. for the client this is more than enough.

the clients have not seen it yet as i am developing the other building that goes with it: the clubhouse. soon i will post that here too.

Edson

an update to the first image. i improved the foreground with the help of sepo (grass texture) and gabriel johansson (post processing).

ely862me

sweeet..i m not an artist so my critique may be off subject but seems that the roof tiles aren t right in this scene imho..except from that ..wow

Edson

@ely862me said:

sweeet..i m not an artist so my critique may be off subject but seems that the roof tiles aren t right in this scene imho..except from that ..wow

thanks, elisei. what do you mean exactly by the roof tiles not being right? do you think the proportion is off or perhaps i should have used another kind of tiles? or perhaps there should be no tiles at all?

sepo

Looks good Edson...

Gaieus

What if they are not meant to be these (roundish) "Spanish" tiles, Ely?

ely862me

that s what i said before ,maybe i m off subject..
no i don t want them to be rounded spanish roof tiles ,just to be something that fits to this perfect design..anyway the spanish taste these days is rustic(rustico -es)something like this

but of course that doesn t fit at all with the design

anyway as i said imho
hope i didn t bother anyone

Elisei

ely862me

ok..let see 1st it seems that the tiles are too thick,u can see this at the base;
2nd they look like bricks ,
3rd the color looks pale
maybe isn t the right texture ..

but that s just my opinion ..el portero parece feliz

Saludos!

alexandre sk

nice work edson

its hard to fight against the clients about tiles here in the RS. hahaaha

but i think this is very good solution.

Edson

@ely862me said:

that s what i said before ,maybe i m off subject..
no i don t want them to be rounded spanish roof tiles ,just to be something that fits to this perfect design..anyway the spanish taste these days is rustic(rustico -es)something like this but of course that doesn t fit at all with the design

anyway as i said imho
hope i didn t bother anyone

Elisei

hi elisei,

you certainly do not bother me. i was thinking of a slightly different kind of tile, flatter than the one you show. but you do have a point in what you say: there is a somewhat excessive flatness to the tiles in the render. however, i do not wish to fall into the hopeless pursuit of the Perfect Render. i do these renders as an architect, that is, in order to offer the client a believable view of my design. this entails some imperfections, of course, as i am not willing to dedicate too much time to them.

looking at my renders from a rendering artist's point of view there is a lot that could be improved.

regards.

Daniel

Looks great, Edson.

Edson

@alexandre sk said:

nice work edson

its hard to fight against the clients about tiles here in the RS. hahaaha

but i think this is very good solution.

thanks, alexandre.

um abraço.

ely862me

I see ur point Mr. Edson .And as i said before u did a great design there .

Cheers!

Elisei