KAPOW! ...and ....PHOOMPH!
-
WOW! It may seem as though I'm blowing this out of proportion, I'm not! As I have been writing, I have been chuckling at the same time because I have not run into this sort of thing being an issue at all. Believe me, I truly understand and agree with not posting images that are strictly modeled in programs that are not SU, what would be the point, take those to the proper forums. This issue is really not a problem, Biebel retrieved a model from Google Sketchup 3D Warehouse, used SU in composition and rendered with Sketchup Podium, seems fitting for the forum.
Also, for all I know maybe myself and others have retrieved something from the 3D warehouse or the various other means without knowing the origin of the original modeling and posted it! BIG DEAL, it may happen. I give credit to Biebel for not just claiming it was modeled in SU as I'm sure there may be some that due, hopefully not. I really don't mind the idea of a model taken from another program into SU, then rendered with Podium, as long as the person posting discloses what he has done. Or possibly the rule should be no other models except SU models, not sure. I have never posted in the SU Community forums models that were made with other programs, this is really not a concern for me. What is a concern for me is Biebel, I would also be disappointed to see him not post his work, I to am inspired by his work. Whatever works out I'm sure it will all be good.
-
Hi guys,
I just come in after a pleasant night out (yes Gaeius there was 'some' beer
).
This has become quite a lively discussion.
Not bad, a good discussion is cool from time to time, certainly on a friday to let some steam off before entering the weekend.I wanted to say to Coen that I understand your concerns and that being part of a team that runs a big community like this one isn't always the easiest job, but you guys are doing it well imho.
Don't let a difference in opinion demotivate you to keep on doing the job.
Things like this happen. You shared your opinion and I did likewise.
Whether renderings are posted here or elsewhere on the forum isn't that important. (I am sure you guys will sort things out).
Being able to share opinions though I consider very important.
The fact that people react to this in a passionate way is proof that this community is alive!Cheers,
kwistenbiebel -
Coen
I was simply trying to illustrate that if you wanted to have the "title" of forum represent all the intricate details of what are the acceptable methods the poster used to create the image than the title of the forum would need to be so complex. However the forum topic has a much more broad title "Renders Gallery" and it is my opinion that under that broad umbrella that that title infers that the images posted are acceptable.
If there is a guideline for the methods used to create and acceptable image than I could be wrong. If there are guidelines created and available then could you or one of the moderators show me how to access them.
Thanks
And indeed I agree that a discussion such as this is important and will help refine and shape how a community of people converse with each other. We must all agree that we are different people with different beliefs and likes dislikes etc. In a community of diverse people there must be a set of guiding principles that the moderators impose so that the majority of the community can in fact converse with each other in a recognized acceptable manner. I am simply trying to determine if you have established those principles for this particular forum and the entire site in general.
My post was obviously "opinionated" I can not separate my opinions from my comments. However I do hope that you or the moderators will have a discussion and provide the members with guidance on what are the acceptable methods behind the creation of and image that is acceptable as a post to the "Renders Gallery".
I do hope that you understand that by simply being here and giving you my opinions should indicate to you that I appreciate all of the work and efforts that went into creating this forum. I simply would not be here and would not be typing this message if I did not care about the forum.
So in a nutshell:
I disagree with those that think the methods used to create the Kapow and Phoomph images are not acceptable for this forum and if no specific guidelines exist to the contrary than they should be created so that this does not occur in the future without a documented guideline to fall back on as a reference for acceptable or unacceptable posts.
-
@unknownuser said:
Coen
I disagree with those that think the methods used to create the Kapow and Phoomph images are not acceptable for this forum and if no specific guidelines exist to the contrary than they should be created so that this does not occur in the future without a documented guideline to fall back on as a reference for acceptable or unacceptable posts.
I 100% Agree! Well said Phil.
-
It's an honor to be a part of a community of people who can share their own unique thoughts and still be a welcome part of the community. We will all benefit from exposure to the thoughts and ideas and creativity etc. of the other members. In particular for me as a sole proprietor working in isolation. This is my break room. it's where I go to chat and bounce ideas off of other people.
I am a firm believer in keeping things simple. As it is we have two gallery sections.
- SketchUP only
- created in SketchUP and RENDEREED in a third party app
I think there is room for a third Gallery section kind of the all other option
- Sketchup was used for some part of the image creation
I do like the idea of seeing images where sketchup was used as one component of the workflow regardless of how small. This can highlight some of the unique capabilities of sketchup. As it has been said we all use a multitude of applications in the pursuit of finding the best tool suited to allow our creativity out. SketchUP can indeed be considered just one tool in our tool belt. Let's agree to accomodate and welcome people who have a unique way to use SU in their creative pursuits.
Again Coen I would personally like to congratulate you on the sucessful creation of the SCF it has become a home for those SU regulars like myself who for what ever reason have not fully made the switch to the GOOGLE groups. Job WELL DONE. err but you may have to reign in us members once in a while.
-
Amen...
I agree that this should be put to a rest now...
I feel confident when saying, that we won't see renders of models, where SU hasn't been at least part of the project... Why would anyone want to do that, except if they want to show-off...
If a model is made in another application and rendered, people should post their work in a forum belonging to the application used for modelling...
Having said that, I do recall postings in the "old" SU Forum, where some users occasionally posted renders modelled using other applications... I.e. Viz models...
I can only take myself as an example... Personally I only use SU for modelling, but when it comes to renders, I do import i.e. Xfrog trees and scrub for the surroundings... But the model of typically a house have been made using SU... And I assume that such renders will be OK, as long as I don't post a render solely of the Xfrog trees...
But good discussion here...
-
Great, Coen, Great, you the man!
-
@frederik said:
... And I assume that such renders will be OK, as long as I don't post a render solely of the Xfrog trees...
Sorry to clip so much good info from your quote Frederick
and zoom in on a detail, but I can see benefits in showing a render of just an Xfrog tree.
It can actually be very educational because a lot is involved to get it right. What import settings to use to get it 'clean' in Sketchup. How to setup clipmaps for the leaves etc....I can see the benefits for people that want to add a nice tree in their renderings of Sketchup models. The same goes for adding 3d people or 3d cars in scenes.
Learning things from one another is one of the ingredients of the glue that holds a community like this together.
Cheers,
Kwistenbiebel -
Coen
Sorry that is an American expression
http://homepage.smc.edu/quizzes/cheney_joyce/rainreignrein.html
I meant the expression related the the leather strap used to control a horse.
To explain the analogy:
the forum and all its members is the horse.
and the creator/moderator/administrator is the one that sits on the horse and controls the Reins. Someone or some people will need to "Rein in" or guide the forum from time to time.
To use another expression related to horses:
I think we have beaten this horse to death now.
However it's snowing here in Minneapolis and a nice sleigh ride would be fun.
heheh as you all get to know me you will find that I use expressions and analogies alot. unfortunately many of these expressions and analogies don't translate to other languages very well.
kwistenbiebel I'm glad to see that you are still here communicating with us.
-
@kwistenbiebel said:
What import settings to use to get it 'clean' in Sketchup. How to setup clipmaps for the leaves etc....
I can see the benefits for people that want to add a nice tree in their renderings of Sketchup models. The same goes for adding 3d people or 3d cars in scenes.
Learning things from one another is one of the ingredients of the glue that holds a community like this together.
I fully agree with you regarding the above, Kwistenbiebel... However, the thing is, that I don't import the Xfrog trees directly into SU...
I haven't even dared trying, because of the high poly count, but I would assume that it will be more or less impossible to orbit the SU model...I add trees, scrub and grass directly in KT...
Doesn't work with current official version, but works excellent and very easy with next release which we hope to be able to release this month... -
strange thread...
So i use sketchup for make "dummy"(like some people make low-poly dummy in 3dsmax or silo for future improvement in mudbox, zbrush)... look at name of programm - Sketch-UPSo @Last dev.team don't want work at high-polygonal techincs - there are their rights....
And all post-work i will make in Cinema4D(or 3dsmax), autocad, i can: smooth models using nurbs(some plug-ins), xrog-imports, rendering(use maxwell, fry and ect) organic models...
And i think Max G. made his models in poser, using interposer(special cinema4d's plug-in, exchange data between c4d and poser)
-
Actually Coen, you are wrong. The textured cars are not original FF models...certainly...we offer them under licence from another company. They were imported into SU and tweaked by Allister.
However, the Roman figures of mine were most certainly done in Sketchup...how else could I keep them that low-poly? -
Hey Alan,
What Roman figures? Could you point me there?
I'm not a FF subscriber for most of the stuff there is more contemporary than what I'd need but I might become a convert...
-
@gaieus said:
Hey Alan,
What Roman figures? Could you point me there?
I'm not a FF subscriber for most of the stuff there is more contemporary than what I'd need but I might become a convert...Gai, check Coen's post on the page prior to this one. Here is a link. http://www.sketchucation.com/forums/scf/viewtopic.php?p=11925#p11925
The second link he provides takes you here:
http://www.formfonts.com/viewModel.php?view=1&id=8465&config=1 -
This is an interesting discussion...and quite relevant, I think, to these forums in general. But specific to this "rendering" forum: not so much. For me, rendering techniques, hints and tips, is the subject of this forum, and, of course, their use on sketchup exports...not sketchup specifically. Sure, if there was no use of the info to users of our fav program, then fine, I see the point.
Wouldn't it be grand for me if we had a couple of accomplished watercolorists posting their wet-work occasionally to suggest image techniques to help my fax-wet efforts.
-
No Coen, there are not "plenty" of models that aren't SketchUp meshes. There are those couple of dozen cars...that's about it. And I've only put the "about" in just in case there is some individual models somewhere that I don't know about.
I might add that I wouldn't be this picky if you hadn't seen your way to wading into another thread with some other "facts" about Form Fonts.
Gai, I've only had the time to do a few variations of a man in a simple tunic yet. I am planning on some female characters, both pleb and pat, as well as other male figures in toga, pallium, paenula and military. I just haven't had the time to do them yet, but I'm working on them...in SKETCHUP. See attached. A few very low poly statues probably wouldn't hurt, either.
-
Coen, I'm always glad to hear your opinions...and personally think, as others have said here, that your original intentions for these forums are good know, and expressing them keeps us grounded and focused. The trouble you feel you get into doing so is regretable and shouldn't dissuade you in the least...as you certainly haven't the history of forcing anything on us.
Another forum...I hope not! But if things get out of hand that is an option I suppose.
-
Tom
I use a tablet for sketching and I have been playing with water color finishes for my doodles, however they have zilch to do with SU and thus no place here to post them.
Do you know another venue for me to post them as i could use your help achieving a water color result similar to yours. -
Pete, no...this is the only place I go (maybe part of the reason I'm less stringent in my attitudes about what is appropriate here :`) But, I do know that this place (and the one before it) is where I learned as much as I know concerning rendering, presentation, and such. Your specific example does not at all seem out of place here. We are a bunch of SU fanatics sharing our brain's beef and brevity, and, as with beauty, the use of it all is in the eye of the beholder.
If someone asks a question about a problem with an autocad drawing should I first ask if it will be used in SU before sharing my knowledge? So why does a rendering tech have to first be similarly vetted? The answers to the DWC questions you might ask about your non-SU sketches obviously have relevance to SU exports as well. I just don't see the problem. (I do sometimes wonder if my watercolors should be placed in the render gallery instead of the sketchup gallery, even though the focus is obviously PR rendering programs...? But I fear they would be lost there.)
This gallery we're in is the venue I would suggest is perfectly proper...my two cents. (The corner bar would be my second choice.)
-
My opinion is that discussions around any part of your work flow that has SketchUp as a component, could be useful to other users and therefore relevant. Perhaps a new forum category for help with parts of your work flow that are outside of SketchUp would be good...? I certainly would be interested in learning about how some folks coordinate different software packages to create their final product.
Just a thought.
Cheers,
- CraigD
Advertisement