[REQ] reveal solver

pilou

I suppose you have tryed the Flex Series and Click-Windows ?

juju

I suppose you have tryed the Flex Series and Click-Windows ?

Pilou, the point is not making the door / window, there are quite a number of different solutions for this. It is the formation of the opening with reveals and returns in brickwork, etc. as the case may be (depends on the amount of layers the wall consists of) and the automation / integration of this with an extension to do the doors / windows.

JQL

This is the main architectural issue we have with sketchup.

I usually follow the cutopening route, but it's not possible with wall layers and has many flaws when moving walls as windows shift positions.

Creating holes in walls and then inserting windows/doors is also troublesome as many openings are not simple pushpulls and if you have many, you can't change them swiftly.

Allowing for dynamic booleans would be a solution and fluid interactive has a pair of plugins that might work for you, if you work with solids:

http://www.fluidinteractive.com/products/sketchup-extensions/viz/

http://www.fluidinteractive.com/products/sketchup-extensions/bool/

Specially the bool extension might be very handy for you.

The other is even stronger as you have a lot of extra features, but it's also less direct if you want to achieve boolean operations fast.

juju

Thanks JQL, I am aware of their products but didn't really imagine using it in such a manner. I sent them a message, but it seems as though it may not be too intuitive unless there is a lot of work on the integration / workflow side of things.

JQL

My thoughts exactly.

Maybe they could adapt them, I don't know. But I believe I could find a useful workflow with them, just right now I don't have the right project to test them with.

driven

have you tried Face Cutter?

can you post an image and example .skp with your desired outcome...

john

pbacot

I have used two cutting component for double skins, but that doesn't help for more than two surfaces.

I have experimented with creating portions of walls that have the openings complete inside and out. Join to other wall segments.

My lintels and sills always come with the door component, so I don't quite understand original post. Can you post an example?

JQL

Face cutter won't do the job. It's a different tool.

fluid

I'm not sure I understand your post correctly, as pbacot suggested, could you please post an example?

There is a Viz related video:

[flash:2jor3y6u]https://www.youtube.com/v/f-jwWAHQfT8[/flash:2jor3y6u]

juju

@driven said:

have you tried Face Cutter?

facecutter simply cuts through all the faces, it doesn't create the reveal returns (in terms of construction methodology) nor does it create the lintel and sill.

@pbacot said:

My lintels and sills always come with the door component, so I don't quite understand original post.

Really? I only know of Window+ that does the sill for you with the window, but not in terms of construction methodology though. What is it that you don't understand?