Add_group slow on mac

[thomthom]

And we have no signs of "clearing the undo stack" will actually improve the performance of adding geometry, do we?

[driven]

@gwd said:

the Sketchup.send_action("saveDocument:") works on mac!

Was this a query? if so, the answer is yes, normally, but the way Dan has used it in the earlier snippets, the Dialog appears, but fails to change the windows name and the script then really does strange things in 'no mans land'

i.e. it's not 'Untitled Window', or your given name, just 'Sketchup'. The cursor pulses, the view disintegrates[holes appeared] then the whole computer freezes... repeatable, yes but I'll pass.

In my curiosity to learn some ruby, I cobbled together some additional test scripts and ran them on my mac.

Script 1: 1.52668809890747 and generates 2000 undo steps #### this is the original from this thread
Script 2: 0.175029039382935 and generates 1001 undo steps
Script:3: 0.419209957122803 and generates 2 undo steps
Script 4: 0.0664420127868652 and generates 2 undo steps #### this uses disable_ui and draws after the timer stops, so add 0.04 maybe...

My scripts a probably really badly constructed, but they reliably return this similar timings... john

#########################################################################
# timer snippet from http://stackoverflow.com/questions/2289381/how-to-time-an-operation-in-milliseconds-in-ruby
def time
  now = Time.now.to_f
  yield
  endd = Time.now.to_f
  endd - now
end

time{
# This code draws a line of points in 1.52668809890747
# and generates 2000 undo steps
 model = Sketchup.active_model
 entities = model.entities
for n in 1..1000 do
 g = entities.add_group
 g.name = n.to_s
 point1 = Geom;;Point3d.new(n*1,0,0)
 c = g.entities.add_cpoint point1
 g.explode
end
}
#########################################################################
def time
  now = Time.now.to_f
  yield
  endd = Time.now.to_f
  endd - now
end
time{
# This code draws a line of points in 0.175029039382935
# and generates 1001 undo steps
 model = Sketchup.active_model
 entities = model.active_entities
 centerpoint = Geom;;Point3d.new
 full_group = entities.add_group()
 (0..1000).each do |i|
 # Create a line of points
 centerpoint = [i*1,10,0]
 full_group.entities.add_cpoint centerpoint
end
full_group.explode
}
#########################################################################
def time
  now = Time.now.to_f
  yield
  endd = Time.now.to_f
  endd - now
end
time{
# This code draws a line of points in  0.389806985855103 on mac
# and generates 2 undo steps
require 'sketchup.rb'
require 'LangHandler.rb'

# Using language handler makes sure that the string "Create Line" gets translated.
# This is important as this string is shown in undo menu. 
$make_cp_line_string = LanguageHandler.new("gettingstarted.strings");

def cp_line()
     model = Sketchup.active_model
     selection = model.selection
  # Create a transaction so the box is one undo
  model.start_operation($make_cp_line_string.GetString("Create cp_Line"))

  entities = model.active_entities
  points_group = entities.add_group()
  centerpoint = Geom;;Point3d.new
  entities = points_group.entities
 
(0..1000).each do |i|
 # Create a line of points
 centerpoint = [i*1,20,0].to_a
 c_pl = points_group.entities.add_cpoint centerpoint
 points_group.name = "Points Group" 
 points_group.description = "Example Group" 
 selection.add points_group
 
 
 end #create
  model.commit_operation

end

cp_line
model = Sketchup.active_model
selection = model.selection
selection.length
selection.each { |entity| (entity.explode) }
}

##########################################################################
def time
  now = Time.now.to_f
  yield
  endd = Time.now.to_f
  endd - now
end
time{
# This code draws a line of points in 0.0667488574981689 with disable_ui on mac
# and generates 2 undo steps
require 'sketchup.rb'
require 'LangHandler.rb'

# Using language handler makes sure that the string "Create Line" gets translated.
# This is important as this string is shown in undo menu. 
$make_dcp_line_string = LanguageHandler.new("gettingstarted.strings");

def dcp_line()
     model = Sketchup.active_model
     selection = model.selection
     disable_ui = true
  # Create a transaction so the box is one undo
  model.start_operation($make_dcp_line_string.GetString("Create cp_Line"),disable_ui)

  entities = model.active_entities
  dis_pnts_group = entities.add_group()
  centerpoint = Geom;;Point3d.new
  entities = dis_pnts_group.entities
 
(0..1000).each do |i|
 # Create a line of points
 centerpoint = [i*1,30,0].to_a
 dc_pl = dis_pnts_group.entities.add_cpoint centerpoint
 dis_pnts_group.name = "Dis Points Group" 
 dis_pnts_group.description = "Example 2 Group" 
 selection.add dis_pnts_group
 
 
 end #create
  model.commit_operation

end

dcp_line
model = Sketchup.active_model
selection = model.selection
selection.length
selection.each { |entity| (entity.explode) }
disable_ui = false
}

##########################################################################

[Dan Rathbun]

Well, John, you've proved that disable_ui is much faster that not.

But the topic is about that add_group and explode group is slow. Which you've also proved, of course, by testing the same entity generation within only 1 group and then exploding it AFTER the loop.

I only speculated that Sketchup's writing to the Undo stack (and Undo Log file,) might slow things down.

There is a registry entry on PC for "MaxUndo" (under the "Preferences" key,) which is set to 100 by default. There is no UI control to change this "on-the-fly." (And likely Sketchup would not see any change to the attribute while running.) But I wonder if setting it to 0 before startup would it disable the undo feature all together ?? (I don't know what it's called in the Mac plist.)

But, regardless, ThomThom believes that it's not the undo stack, but instead the way the app seems to resort the model database, during add groups and explodes.
What if all the temp groups, were first added to a master group (to separate them from the rest of the model, and then after the loop, the master group was exploded ?)

[Dan Rathbun]

@dan rathbun said:

There is a registry entry on PC for "MaxUndo" (under the "Preferences" key,) which is set to 100 by default. There is no UI control to change this "on-the-fly." (And likely Sketchup would not see any change to the attribute while running.) But I wonder if setting it to 0 before startup would it disable the undo feature all together ?? (I don't know what it's called in the Mac plist.)

I just tried this.. set "MaxUndo" to 0 before SU start.

The undo operations do NOT appear on the Edit menu.

Sketchup still writes to the undo log, but after each tool operation, it writes a "Commit(0)" line.

Changing the attribute back to 100 while Sketchup is running has no effect (as I suspected.) And Sketchup will rewrite it's "live" "MaxUndo" value of 0, back to the registry attribute. So you must change it back to whatever limit you wish, while Sketchup is closed, in order to turn the Undo feature back on.

[Dan Rathbun]

Also, note. When "MaxUndo" is 0, calling Sketchup.send_action("editUndo:") still returns true, but nothing happens. (At least it does not BugSplat, which I did fear.)

[driven]

@dan rathbun said:

Well, John, you've proved that disable_ui is much faster that not.

But the topic is about that add_group and explode group is slow. Which you've also proved, of course, by testing the same entity generation within only 1 group and then exploding it AFTER the loop.

I only speculated that Sketchup's writing to the Undo stack (and Undo Log file,) might slow things down.
It appears to here, I can see a cursor image refresh as each group is created

@unknownuser said:

There is a registry entry on PC for "MaxUndo" (under the "Preferences" key,) which is set to 100 by default.There is no UI control to change this "on-the-fly." (And likely Sketchup would not see any change to the attribute while running.) But I wonder if setting it to 0 before startup would it disable the undo feature all together ?? (I don't know what it's called in the Mac plist.)

macSU .plist <key>SketchUp.Preferences.MaxUndo</key><string>100</string>
I think if you write to, then touch, then read SU uses the update, but I need to check if it works for SU prefs, it does for 'user' ruby ones.

@unknownuser said:

But, regardless, ThomThom believes that it's not the undo stack, but instead the way the app seems to resort the model database, during add groups and explodes.
making a 1000 groups adds 2000 undoes, which is much slower than putting it in the langhandler (which I thought would have a big overhead) with only 1 undo +1 for the explode outside.
@unknownuser said:

What if all the temp groups, were first added to a master group (to separate them from the rest of the model, and then after the loop, the master group was exploded ?)
I'll try and work out a script to do a test, unless you want to...
I wasn't really doing this to post back, it's just an exercise in me understanding SU ruby (on mac), but the results seemed to be relevant to the OP's mac/group inquiry. Yell at me if it's not.
john

[driven]

@dan rathbun said:

Also, note. When "MaxUndo" is 0, calling Sketchup.send_action("editUndo:") still returns true, but nothing happens. (At least it does not BugSplat, which I did fear.)

One thing I have found when modifying NIB files, is you often need to save, open/close SU then re-save 'manual' preference list changes, to clear SU's cache. Not sure if it's the same with coded writes and maybe it's only the SU ones that are cached?
john

[Dan Rathbun]

@driven said:

... which is much slower than putting it in the langhandler (which I thought would have a big overhead) ...

The LanguageHandler class has nothing to do with this subject (speed & groups.) It's just a wrapper for a Hash, that has English (the keys,) strings translated to the user's local language.

Read the "langhandler.rb" file in the "Tools" dir, and you'll see it's quite simple. (I don't use this class, since it defaults to using the "Resources" path, and it's much simplier to just use plain old Hash of my own (which can be loaded from a UTF-8 encoded file.)

[Dan Rathbun]

For version 8.0M2,
@unknownuser said:

(http://support.google.com/sketchup/bin/static.py?hl)":1pr50735]SketchUp Writer C++ API: In earlier versions, ISketchUpGroup::CreateGroup became slower each time it was called. This shouldn't slow down any longer.

I would think that this fix was added into the application code as well.

@Guy: Is your friend's Mac running Sketchup version 8.0M2 ??

[GWD]

@dan rathbun said:

For version 8.0M2,
@unknownuser said:

(http://support.google.com/sketchup/bin/static.py?hl)":100134bg]SketchUp Writer C++ API: In earlier versions, ISketchUpGroup::CreateGroup became slower each time it was called. This shouldn't slow down any longer.

I would think that this fix was added into the application code as well.

@Guy: Is your friend's Mac running Sketchup version 8.0M2 ??

We use on Mac and PC the latest version from google's website. (PC 8.0.11752/MAC 8.0.11.751)

I did some more testing:

model = Sketchup.active_model
entities = model.entities
puts '- Start test1 add_group bug on MAC -'
start = Time.now
for n in 1..1000 do #changed this setting for the testing
	g = entities.add_group
	g.name = n.to_s
	point1 = Geom;;Point3d.new(n*10,0,0)
	c = g.entities.add_cpoint point1
end
puts 'Total time; ' + (start - Time.now).to_s  

Results:

At this moment we use a workaround. Place the groups in a new model (use the multiple documents on MAC), make a component of all the groups. Save this component and insert it in the model and explode it. The biggest problem of this workaround is that it's impossible to close the new temporary model with ruby. A other problem is that is still a lot slower than on PC.
Anybody a solution?

[Dan Rathbun]

WoW! Excellent test report. Shows that the Mac still has a problem.

I wonder if the difference has to do with Ruby.? The Mac is still running the initial release of v1.8.5, and the PC was updated to v1.8.6-p287.

There is a thread on how to point the symbolic references for Sketchup Ruby to a "normal" full Ruby install elesewhere on the Mac's harddrive. (You need to backup the current links, so you can switch back if necessary. Perhaps a shell script?)

I'd be interested in seeing the comparison for the Mac, running v1.8.5-p0 and v1.8.6-p287, ... (and perhaps even the latest patchlevel for v1.8.7)

[GWD]

@dan rathbun said:

WoW! Excellent test report. Shows that the Mac still has a problem.

I wonder if the difference has to do with Ruby.? The Mac is still running the initial release of v1.8.5, and the PC was updated to v1.8.6-p287.

There is a thread on how to point the symbolic references for Sketchup Ruby to a "normal" full Ruby install elesewhere on the Mac's harddrive. (You need to backup the current links, so you can switch back if necessary. Perhaps a shell script?)

I'd be interested in seeing the comparison for the Mac, running v1.8.5-p0 and v1.8.6-p287, ... (and perhaps even the latest patchlevel for v1.8.7)

And here are the results for ruby 1.8.7 on mac:

100 - 0.58 sec
200 - 1.69 sec
400 - 10.55 sec
600 - 33.39 sec
1000 - 147 sec

Almost no difference with ruby 1.8.5

[Dan Rathbun]

Bummer... definately the problem is in the C++ code.

[jhauswirth]

Looking at the add_group Ruby code, its the same on both platforms.
One reason (don't know if this is true) it could be slower on the Mac
is the notifications that are sent around could be updating the Mac
UI, like the component browser. This may be more efficiently done on
the PC.

Also, the same code (duplicate code/cut-n-pasted it looks like) that
I fixed in the C++ API was also being used in the Ruby code.
The bug report only mentioned the C++ API, so that's what got fixed.

[thomthom]

@jhauswirth said:

Looking at the add_group Ruby code, its the same on both platforms.
One reason (don't know if this is true) it could be slower on the Mac
is the notifications that are sent around could be updating the Mac
UI, like the component browser. This may be more efficiently done on
the PC.

I have noticed that if you use Sketchup.status_text within a loop it will be very slow under OSX. It seems that the UI is forcefully freshened all the time, while on Windows you get "white-out" and the UI stops updating - but completes the loop much much faster.

But if it is the UI that slows things down, then running the test with start_operation and disable_ui argument set to true, should show a good performance increase, right?

[Dan Rathbun]

@John: thanks for taking a look at this, and "weighing in."

@GWD: Are all these groups to be added REALLY have all the same objects (like the example,) and just have a different location (transform) ?

[GWD]

@dan rathbun said:

@John: thanks for taking a look at this, and "weighing in."

@GWD: Are all these groups to be added REALLY have all the same objects (like the example,) and just have a different location (transform) ?

Dan,

No this is just a quick test that reproduce the problem. We have at this moment 2 totaly different script which have this problem.

[GWD]

@thomthom said:

@jhauswirth said:

Looking at the add_group Ruby code, its the same on both platforms.
One reason (don't know if this is true) it could be slower on the Mac
is the notifications that are sent around could be updating the Mac
UI, like the component browser. This may be more efficiently done on
the PC.

I have noticed that if you use Sketchup.status_text within a loop it will be very slow under OSX. It seems that the UI is forcefully freshened all the time, while on Windows you get "white-out" and the UI stops updating - but completes the loop much much faster.

But if it is the UI that slows things down, then running the test with start_operation and disable_ui argument set to true, should show a good performance increase, right?

I tested it with start_operation and it as no effect!

[GWD]

I just did some testing with adding components instead of groups (see script below). And the result is shokking. Placing 600 component give about the same time as the 600 groups 0.7 sec on PC and 27 sec on MAC. BUT after the script ended the MAC keep on showing the busy icon for very long time. More than 5 minutes (then i killed sketchup). I did the same test on mac with different number of components and this are the results:

50 components 0.29 sec running script 17 sec busy icon after script
100 components 0.85 sec running script 35 sec busy icon after script
200 components 3.8 sec running script 2 min 25 sec busy icon after script
300 components 7.6 sec running script more than 5 min sec busy icon after script
600 components 27 sec running script more than 5 min busy icon after script

require 'sketchup'
UI.menu("PlugIns").add_item("bugMAC Test2") {
model = Sketchup.active_model
entities = model.entities
puts '- Start test1 add_group bug on MAC -'
start = Time.now
for n in 1..600 do 
	newdef = model.definitions.add		
	newdef.name = n.to_s
	point1 = Geom;;Point3d.new(n*10,0,0)
	newdef.entities.add_cpoint point1 
	pt = Geom;;Point3d.new 0,0,0
	trans = Geom;;Transformation.new pt
	i = model.entities.add_instance(newdef, trans) 
	i.make_unique	
end
puts 'Total time; ' + (start - Time.now).to_s  
} 

[GWD]

No solutions?