What? No Menu?

Dan Rathbun

Weird!
If you send the following at the console, it works:
UI.menu('Plugins').add_item('Hello') { puts "World" }

Another thing. Each time you call UI.menu('Plugins') a new object is returned. I would think each of the standard menu objects would be created by the OEM extensions at startup, and the UI.menu method should return those, every time the method is called.

Is this a bug that has creeped into the latter versions?

thomthom

@dan rathbun said:

Weird!

"Maddening" was my thoughts on this. I really thought Iwas going mad as I thought I was doing something wrong. I spent and hour on this yesterday. Was testing some code in the console. Before I tried to paste it into a file.

@dan rathbun said:

Another thing. Each time you call UI.menu('Plugins') a new object is returned. I would think each of the standard menu objects would be created by the OEM extensions at startup, and the UI.menu method should return those, every time the method is called.

That had me puzzled as well.
The thing is, if you don't have any plugins installed, and you type UI.menu('Plugins') into the console, the Plugins top menu appear, but you still can't add menus to it via the console.

@dan rathbun said:

Is this a bug that has creeped into the latter versions?

Dunno - didn't try any earlier versions...

thomthom

Same thing in SU6.

Jim

That has always worked for me and still does. I typically use it to quickly reload a file:

UI.menu('Plugins').add_item("Reload and Run") { load "my_file.rb"; do_method }

thomthom

Yes, UI.menu('Plugins').add_item('Hello') { puts "World" } works.

But does
x = UI.menu('Plugins') x.add_item('Hello') { puts "World" }
work for you?

Jim

No, but this does:

x=UI.menu('Plugins');x.add_item("hi") { puts "hi" }

(single line.)

thomthom

...

This makes no sense...

cjthompson

I think it has something to do with the fact that UI.menu() returns a new object each time:

UI.menu("Plugins")
#<Sketchup;;Menu;0x5dbf1c0>
UI.menu("Plugins")
#<Sketchup;;Menu;0x5dbeff8>
UI.menu("Plugins")
#<Sketchup;;Menu;0x5dbee30>
UI.menu("Plugins")
#<Sketchup;;Menu;0x5dbec68>
UI.menu("Plugins")
#<Sketchup;;Menu;0x5dbeaa0>

thomthom

But still.... the exact same code saved as a .rb works.

cjthompson

That's because the code is executed all during one frame, which also explains why the one-liner works.

My guess is that Sketchup creates a new menu , adds the items, and does the validation each frame, instead of just using one menu.

Jim

frame?

cjthompson

I suppose refresh is a better term. I was referring to a frame in animation.

Dan Rathbun

Thread may be a better word.

Examine the eval.c file in the Ruby source and you'll see that files are treated a bit differently.

snicolo

@cjthompson said:

That's because the code is executed all during one frame, which also explains why the one-liner works.

My guess is that Sketchup creates a new menu , adds the items, and does the validation each frame, instead of just using one menu.

This is exactly right. It depends on the context available when commands are executed.

Another way to specify multi-line commands in Ruby is to use ''
You could do:

x = UI.menu('Plugins') \
x.add_item('Hello') { puts "World" } \
x.add_item('Hello2') { puts "World2" }

and it would work and be all executed as a single command.