Ruby Protocol Buffers

thomthom

Certainly sounds interesting.

Interesting indeed - but I don't understand exactly what it do or what you can do with it.

brewsky

I am trying to make an interface from my Sketchup BIM-Tools plugin, to a BIMserver(BIMserver.org) using protocol buffers.

These Ruby Protocol Buffers are exactly what I need!

I have been trying to copy parts of the code into my plugin folder, but frankly I have no idea what I'm doing here

Is there anyone with some experience in using this "library"?
Or maybe a few tips on "plugging" external libraries into the sketchup-ruby installation?

Any help is greatly appreciated!

Cheers!
Jan

thomthom

I would instead make a Ruby C Extension. Bundling along lots of ruby libs opens up for lots of potential clashes. Imagine if another plugin was bundling a slightly different version.

Dan Rathbun

I took a quick look through the code.

It requires a full Ruby install as it needs several standard library files. (I also novice some code in there for Ruby v1.9.x compatibility. Don't know if that would cause problems.)

Generally, from what I read, I do not care for the implementation. It creates modules (and perhaps only toplevel modules. This would heighten the probability of namespace clashes.)

Why they didn't implement a class and have the Ruby individual protocol buffer be an instance I do not know. It's what I would done.)

You need to realize that most Ruby Gems are written to run in their own Ruby process, started from the command line. The ruby script does it's task, and then that Ruby process ends.

SketchUp Embedded Ruby uses a persistent SHARED Ruby process, where we must be careful to run all out code within each of our own toplevel modules (namespaces.)

This code for example requires the Ruby command line option parser, which means it expects arguments to be in the ARGV array. In SketchUp Embedded Ruby this array is empty. NONE of the command line parameters used to start SketchUp.exe are passed into it's Ruby process.

Looks to me like WAY too much work to "SketchUpize" this utility.

What is wrong with class PStore ? .. or JSON string files ?

brewsky

Hi Dan,

Thanks for looking into this!
Too bad it's not easy to use from SketchUp.

A single protocol buffers class for ruby does indeed seem much better than all these modules.
Writing my own class for this seems way over my head(figuring out how the data is "serialized" and all).

JSON seems to have a similar purpose, and could be a good alternative.

But there are only a few ways to communicate with the TNO bimserver, from which protocol buffers seems to be the preferred solution.
Check out this page: http://code.google.com/p/bimserver/wiki/Interfaces
So in this case I don't think I can use JSON...(and would that be easy to load in SketchUp?)

(interesting subject though "serialization"(YAML, Marshall, JSON), using this I might be able to store my complete "wall"/"floor" objects in a sketchup attribute. Re-load an object instead of re-creating it!)

I hope I can find SOME way to communicate with bim-server, would be great if I could make a direct connection!

Dan Rathbun

[off:g7kpsrm3]( but possibly related )

Nested Attribute Dictionaries[/off:g7kpsrm3]

Dan Rathbun

@brewsky said:

Check out this page: http://code.google.com/p/bimserver/wiki/Interfaces
So in this case I don't think I can use JSON...

Ruby standard library has an extensive [url=http://www.ruby-doc.org/stdlib-1.8.6/libdoc/soap/rdoc/index.html:pxzi4drt]SOAP[/url:pxzi4drt] class, however again a full Ruby install is needed.

You may be better off trying the [url=http://code.google.com/p/bimserver/wiki/RESTInterface:pxzi4drt]REST[/url:pxzi4drt] interface as it uses HTTP1.1 protocol. See: [url=http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/REST:pxzi4drt]wikipedia/REST[/url:pxzi4drt]

brewsky

@dan rathbun said:

What is wrong with class PStore ? .. or JSON string files ?

BIMserver.org is implementing a JSON interface!
I have absolutely no idea where to start, but lets see if I can somehow make a connection from my BIM-Tools plugin to BIMserver using JSON

Dan Rathbun

@brewsky said:

@dan rathbun said:

... or JSON string files ?
BIMserver.org is implementing a JSON interface!

I have absolutely no idea where to start, ...
Start here... topic : JSON in Ruby

... read the first few posts where I explain the basics of converting to and from a Ruby Hash into a JSON string.

Then... scroll down to the method posts by Aerilius in which he "standardized" the conversions into methods. These can be pasted into your plugin sub-module, or added as a library sub-module, just within your toplevel "author" module, so it can be used by many of your plugins.
I show examples of doing this in the post prior to Aerilius' method postings.

brewsky

@dan rathbun said:

Start here...

Thanks Dan!

Dan Rathbun

... also an Attribute Dictionary is basically a hash written into the model dB. So they can be converted similarly.