Which Output you like

Carloh

that's a tough one...they both look very good. at the first glance i would tend to the rendering.

Krisidious

number 2... very nice.

ArCAD-UK

Both very good images. The choice would depend who is viewing the image. In my experience the planners / council / local authority would prefer 1. and the client 2.

ccbiggs

Both are very good. But I prefer #2

mitraniulian

The first one seems very expresive

andybot

Hi Nomer,
The first one is too "computer generated" with the texture being so even. If there's a way you could give it more variety and hand-drawn feel, I would go for the first one.

Andy

Daniel

That's hard to say. If you posted either one individually, my reaction would be the same, as both express the project, only with differring language.

roland joseph

You spent considerable time creating the scene, materials, lighting, plants and then rendering and the image result is a success. The filtered watercolor is an imitation of the rendering. If the watercolor was created by hand and not a biproduct of the model it would then have a ranking against your rendering. From a practicle standpoint it seems hard to sell customers on digital NPR....most want to see images that portray fine material details, one against the other.

jarynzlesa

hi nomer,

i prefer NPR, but I think that the customer will appreciate the render.
nice work

nomeradona

thank you for all your responses..

Roger

I read the texture as rain, is that what was intended?

Tobobo

The render is outstanding!!!!

Mistro11

I like the render. Very cool.

Can you please share how you did the trees and foliage. I'm currently on the hunt for material to do some landscaping and natural environments.

nomeradona

@roger said:

I read the texture as rain, is that what was intended?
it was not actually more like colored pencil.

nomeradona

@tobobo said:

The render is outstanding!!!!
thanks tabobo.. it was done in vray sketchup while testing how to do caustics.

nomeradona

@mistro11 said:

I like the render. Very cool.

Can you please share how you did the trees and foliage. I'm currently on the hunt for material to do some landscaping and natural environments.

the palms are 3d. the foliage and trees behind is just a background image. because of su limitation in memory i just use 2d images in my bg. nothing special maybe.

Richard

I probably like the second one, simply because I really don't like faux watercolours etc but it's just a personal thing. I can still see the beauty in them though and number one from that respect is very good!

nomeradona

@richard said:

I probably like the second one, simply because I really don't like faux watercolours etc but it's just a personal thing. I can still see the beauty in them though and number one from that respect is very good!
thanks richard i can see your point.

sketchnl

Hello,

I like de second one.The water is looking good. And it gives me more feeling. First one is also very beautifull.

Greetz Jeremy